AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: Planned Obsolescence: Engine of the Consumer Economy | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

55m 49s

Introduction and Personal Context

  • Josh introduces episode as "select" - one of more eye-opening/maddening episodes about wasteful aspects of global economy
  • Chuck recalls childhood with same refrigerator entire life - even got refaced after 25 years
  • Things used to last "forever and ever" - 50-year fridges were normal
  • Discussion of what changed and why products don't last anymore

Definition and Concept of Planned Obsolescence

  • Companies deliberately making products last shorter time to force repeat purchases
  • Multiple approaches: build cheap, use inferior materials, create incompatibility
  • Particularly prevalent in smartphones - updates slow phones, batteries fail after 3 years
  • Not illegal but companies won't admit to it
  • Debate over whether it's real, deliberate, or just part of modern economy

Historical Origins - Light Bulb Industry

  • Edison's original light bulbs (late 1800s) used carbon filaments 8x thicker than later tungsten
  • Centennial light bulb from 1901 still working in California fire station after 118 years
  • Initially electric companies installed/maintained systems including bulb replacement
  • Feebas cartel (1920s) - electric companies worldwide met secretly in Geneva, Switzerland
  • Literal collusion to make light bulbs last shorter time to sell more
  • Proof that planned obsolescence was definitely real in early post-industrial age

Automotive Industry Development

  • Alfred P. Sloan (GM President) created "Dynamic obsolescence"
  • Make little updates each year to same car to create desire for newer model
  • Trade in working cars for newer, flashier versions after couple years
  • Before this, cars made when real innovation occurred (every 5-7 years)
  • Model T, Model A era - "box with wheels" approach

Term Creation and Early Advocacy

  • "Planned obsolescence" first appeared in 1932 pamphlet by Bernard London (real estate broker)
  • Pamphlet: "Ending the Depression Through Planned Obsolescence"
  • Proposed artificial expiration dates with tax penalties for continued use beyond date
  • 15 of original 20 copies still exist in libraries
  • Same year: Roy Sheldon and Egmont Arens wrote "Consumer Engineering: A New Technique for Prosperity"
  • Called it "creative waste" - make less durable things to stimulate economy during Depression
  • Foundation for modern consumer economy

Brooks Stevens and 1950s Formalization

  • Milwaukee industrial designer worked automobile/appliance industries
  • 1954 advertising conference speech: "instilling in buyer desire to own something newer, better, sooner than necessary"
  • Advocated making things obsolete to keep people working and making stuff
  • By 1960 (6 years later): Vance Packard's "The Waste Makers" exposed problems

Vance Packard - Early Social Critic

  • Pre-Ralph Nader social critic
  • Wrote "The Hidden Persuaders" (advertising/subliminal advertising)
  • "The Naked Society" (1960s consumer privacy)
  • "The Ultra Rich: How Much is Too Much" (1989)
  • Fought against wasteful, invasive society until death
  • Laid groundwork for modern social reporting (Gladwell, Friedman followed)

Evidence of Declining Quality

  • Definite progression of increasing shoddiness and shortened lifespan
  • Not just nostalgia - proven deterioration in product durability
  • Vintage appliances on Etsy/eBay still work after decades
  • Sunbeam mixer from 1930 still works perfectly
  • Dad's Sears hose from 1960s lasted until 1990s, replaced free under lifetime guarantee

Modern Offenders - Apple

  • Class action lawsuit for update that slowed phones
  • Apple claimed protecting battery life by slowing performance
  • Offered $29 battery replacements (down from $79)
  • Replaced 11 million batteries in 2018 (up from 1-2 million average year)
  • iPhone batteries not user-replaceable
  • Incompatibility issues: no headphone jacks, USB ports without dongles/adapters
  • $9.99 headphone adapters - multiple needed for different devices
  • Creating incompatibility between old/new models forces additional purchases

Printer Cartridge Scam

  • Smart chips in cartridges communicate with printer
  • Chips stop printing at preset ink level, not when actually empty
  • Prevent use of cheaper third-party cartridges
  • Cartridges designed not to be refilled, must be thrown away
  • Epson makes printers with refillable reservoirs and recyclable bottles (no smart chips)

Auto Industry Continuation

  • Discontinuing parts that could keep cars running longer
  • Minor cosmetic changes for new model years
  • Retiring popular car models to force new purchases
  • Control over parts market and authorized repair shops

Repair Control Strategy

  • Companies control who can repair products with authorized parts
  • Void warranty if repaired elsewhere
  • Raise repair costs to near-replacement price
  • Stop manufacturing parts to make repair impossible
  • Force consumers toward "buy new" rather than repair

Clothing Industry Decline

  • Levi's example: used to last decades, now rip after 5 months
  • Russians would trade Yugos for American jeans historically
  • Some companies make quality clothes but expensive
  • Most brands pump out cheap clothes with artificial style changes

College Textbook Racket

  • New editions with minimal changes (mainly page numbers)
  • Forces purchase of new books instead of used
  • Information usually not significantly different
  • Could sell supplements separately for much less

Toy Industry - Contrived Durability

  • Purposefully using inferior parts that break quickly
  • Switchblade comb example - breaks after 50 uses
  • Repair costs exceed replacement cost for cheap items
  • Death of repair shops - very few TV repair shops remain

Statistical Evidence

  • 2015 Öko Institute (Germany) study:
    • Electrical/electronic products replaced due to breaking within 5 years: 3.2% (2004) to 8.3% (2012)
    • Large household appliances replaced within 5 years: 7% (2004) to 13.3% (2013) - doubled
  • Most evidence anecdotal from appliance repair technicians
  • Appliance repair costs often 25-33% of replacement cost
  • $1,500 refrigerator becomes $2,000 after first repair

Environmental Impact

  • 350 million ink cartridges thrown in US landfills annually
  • 348 million cartridges not even empty due to smart chips
  • Only 6% of small appliances recycled in US
  • E-waste particularly environmentally damaging
  • Millions of items thrown away rather than repaired

European Response - Ecodesign Directive

  • Resource efficiency standards alongside energy efficiency
  • Durability and repairability requirements
  • Mandatory labeling of expected lifespan
  • Consumers can make informed choices (5-year vs 7-year appliance)
  • Seven-year appliance more resource efficient by definition

US Right to Repair Movement

  • Started in UK, spread to US
  • 2018: 18 states introduced right to repair bills
  • Require companies make devices repairable by consumers/independent shops
  • Warranty can't be voided for unauthorized repair
  • Repair shops should access parts and manuals
  • Universal parts where possible
  • Stop making repair artificially difficult

Economic Arguments For Planned Obsolescence

  • Keeps army of employees working at companies
  • Technological innovation driven by replacement cycles
  • Phone companies compete through innovation to justify 3-year upgrades
  • Value engineering - balance durability with affordability
  • $500 phone every few years vs $5,000 phone every few years
  • Military-grade materials would make products unaffordable

Consumer Responsibility

  • Öko Institute: 1/3 of appliance replacements motivated by wanting newer/better unit despite old one working
  • 2012: 60% of replaced TVs still functioning
  • Consumer desire for latest color/style drives some replacement
  • Question: Did consumer society create planned obsolescence or vice versa?

Listener Mail

  • Tom from Rockford, Illinois about daughter Grace
  • Grace graduating high school, attending University of Minnesota
  • Majoring in cellular and organismal physiology
  • Show influenced her desire for knowledge and education
  • Family coming to Chicago show
  • Grace turning 18, looking forward to voting
  • Show empowered her positions on social issues

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome