AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: Planned Obsolescence: Engine of the Consumer Economy | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
55m 49s
Introduction and Personal Context
- Josh introduces episode as "select" - one of more eye-opening/maddening episodes about wasteful aspects of global economy
- Chuck recalls childhood with same refrigerator entire life - even got refaced after 25 years
- Things used to last "forever and ever" - 50-year fridges were normal
- Discussion of what changed and why products don't last anymore
Definition and Concept of Planned Obsolescence
- Companies deliberately making products last shorter time to force repeat purchases
- Multiple approaches: build cheap, use inferior materials, create incompatibility
- Particularly prevalent in smartphones - updates slow phones, batteries fail after 3 years
- Not illegal but companies won't admit to it
- Debate over whether it's real, deliberate, or just part of modern economy
Historical Origins - Light Bulb Industry
- Edison's original light bulbs (late 1800s) used carbon filaments 8x thicker than later tungsten
- Centennial light bulb from 1901 still working in California fire station after 118 years
- Initially electric companies installed/maintained systems including bulb replacement
- Feebas cartel (1920s) - electric companies worldwide met secretly in Geneva, Switzerland
- Literal collusion to make light bulbs last shorter time to sell more
- Proof that planned obsolescence was definitely real in early post-industrial age
Automotive Industry Development
- Alfred P. Sloan (GM President) created "Dynamic obsolescence"
- Make little updates each year to same car to create desire for newer model
- Trade in working cars for newer, flashier versions after couple years
- Before this, cars made when real innovation occurred (every 5-7 years)
- Model T, Model A era - "box with wheels" approach
Term Creation and Early Advocacy
- "Planned obsolescence" first appeared in 1932 pamphlet by Bernard London (real estate broker)
- Pamphlet: "Ending the Depression Through Planned Obsolescence"
- Proposed artificial expiration dates with tax penalties for continued use beyond date
- 15 of original 20 copies still exist in libraries
- Same year: Roy Sheldon and Egmont Arens wrote "Consumer Engineering: A New Technique for Prosperity"
- Called it "creative waste" - make less durable things to stimulate economy during Depression
- Foundation for modern consumer economy
Brooks Stevens and 1950s Formalization
- Milwaukee industrial designer worked automobile/appliance industries
- 1954 advertising conference speech: "instilling in buyer desire to own something newer, better, sooner than necessary"
- Advocated making things obsolete to keep people working and making stuff
- By 1960 (6 years later): Vance Packard's "The Waste Makers" exposed problems
Vance Packard - Early Social Critic
- Pre-Ralph Nader social critic
- Wrote "The Hidden Persuaders" (advertising/subliminal advertising)
- "The Naked Society" (1960s consumer privacy)
- "The Ultra Rich: How Much is Too Much" (1989)
- Fought against wasteful, invasive society until death
- Laid groundwork for modern social reporting (Gladwell, Friedman followed)
Evidence of Declining Quality
- Definite progression of increasing shoddiness and shortened lifespan
- Not just nostalgia - proven deterioration in product durability
- Vintage appliances on Etsy/eBay still work after decades
- Sunbeam mixer from 1930 still works perfectly
- Dad's Sears hose from 1960s lasted until 1990s, replaced free under lifetime guarantee
Modern Offenders - Apple
- Class action lawsuit for update that slowed phones
- Apple claimed protecting battery life by slowing performance
- Offered $29 battery replacements (down from $79)
- Replaced 11 million batteries in 2018 (up from 1-2 million average year)
- iPhone batteries not user-replaceable
- Incompatibility issues: no headphone jacks, USB ports without dongles/adapters
- $9.99 headphone adapters - multiple needed for different devices
- Creating incompatibility between old/new models forces additional purchases
Printer Cartridge Scam
- Smart chips in cartridges communicate with printer
- Chips stop printing at preset ink level, not when actually empty
- Prevent use of cheaper third-party cartridges
- Cartridges designed not to be refilled, must be thrown away
- Epson makes printers with refillable reservoirs and recyclable bottles (no smart chips)
Auto Industry Continuation
- Discontinuing parts that could keep cars running longer
- Minor cosmetic changes for new model years
- Retiring popular car models to force new purchases
- Control over parts market and authorized repair shops
Repair Control Strategy
- Companies control who can repair products with authorized parts
- Void warranty if repaired elsewhere
- Raise repair costs to near-replacement price
- Stop manufacturing parts to make repair impossible
- Force consumers toward "buy new" rather than repair
Clothing Industry Decline
- Levi's example: used to last decades, now rip after 5 months
- Russians would trade Yugos for American jeans historically
- Some companies make quality clothes but expensive
- Most brands pump out cheap clothes with artificial style changes
College Textbook Racket
- New editions with minimal changes (mainly page numbers)
- Forces purchase of new books instead of used
- Information usually not significantly different
- Could sell supplements separately for much less
Toy Industry - Contrived Durability
- Purposefully using inferior parts that break quickly
- Switchblade comb example - breaks after 50 uses
- Repair costs exceed replacement cost for cheap items
- Death of repair shops - very few TV repair shops remain
Statistical Evidence
- 2015 Öko Institute (Germany) study:
- Electrical/electronic products replaced due to breaking within 5 years: 3.2% (2004) to 8.3% (2012)
- Large household appliances replaced within 5 years: 7% (2004) to 13.3% (2013) - doubled
- Most evidence anecdotal from appliance repair technicians
- Appliance repair costs often 25-33% of replacement cost
- $1,500 refrigerator becomes $2,000 after first repair
Environmental Impact
- 350 million ink cartridges thrown in US landfills annually
- 348 million cartridges not even empty due to smart chips
- Only 6% of small appliances recycled in US
- E-waste particularly environmentally damaging
- Millions of items thrown away rather than repaired
European Response - Ecodesign Directive
- Resource efficiency standards alongside energy efficiency
- Durability and repairability requirements
- Mandatory labeling of expected lifespan
- Consumers can make informed choices (5-year vs 7-year appliance)
- Seven-year appliance more resource efficient by definition
US Right to Repair Movement
- Started in UK, spread to US
- 2018: 18 states introduced right to repair bills
- Require companies make devices repairable by consumers/independent shops
- Warranty can't be voided for unauthorized repair
- Repair shops should access parts and manuals
- Universal parts where possible
- Stop making repair artificially difficult
Economic Arguments For Planned Obsolescence
- Keeps army of employees working at companies
- Technological innovation driven by replacement cycles
- Phone companies compete through innovation to justify 3-year upgrades
- Value engineering - balance durability with affordability
- $500 phone every few years vs $5,000 phone every few years
- Military-grade materials would make products unaffordable
Consumer Responsibility
- Öko Institute: 1/3 of appliance replacements motivated by wanting newer/better unit despite old one working
- 2012: 60% of replaced TVs still functioning
- Consumer desire for latest color/style drives some replacement
- Question: Did consumer society create planned obsolescence or vice versa?
Listener Mail
- Tom from Rockford, Illinois about daughter Grace
- Grace graduating high school, attending University of Minnesota
- Majoring in cellular and organismal physiology
- Show influenced her desire for knowledge and education
- Family coming to Chicago show
- Grace turning 18, looking forward to voting
- Show empowered her positions on social issues
