AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: The Case of Sacco and Vanzetti | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
55m 52s
Episode Introduction
- Chuck introduces classic SYSK episode from March 2019
- Topic: The case of Sacco and Vanzetti
- Hosts: Josh Clark, Charles W. Chuck Bryant, guest producer Josh
- Focus: True crime history from 1920s
Historical Context - 1920s America
- Two Italian immigrant anarchists in United States
- Followers of Luigi Galliani - anarchist leader who advocated violence
- Published anarchist publications
- Authorized bombings and assassination attempts
- Anarchist period: assassinated 5-6 major heads of state in 10-year period
- Including President McKinley in United States
- Red Scare climate - communism/socialism/anarchism debates
- Political radicals worldwide engaged in violence, riots
- US judges/politicians deporting immigrant anarchists rapidly
The Braintree Robbery - April 15, 1920
- Location: Braintree, Massachusetts (10 miles south of Boston)
- Shoe manufacturing center with multiple companies
- Shelly Neil: American Express agent/armed guard courier
- Picked up $30,000 cash from 9:18 AM train ($427,000 in 2018 money)
- Weekly payroll for Slater & Morel and New Balance shoe companies
- Noticed suspicious large car with curtains outside office
- Witnesses reported car with 4-5 Italian-looking men driving around town 9 AM-12 PM
The Crime
- 3 PM: Paymaster Freddy Parmenter and guard Alessandro Berardelli transporting payroll
- Location: Pearl Street
- Gunfire erupted - both men shot
- Berardelli hit first, lost gun, begged for life
- Shot in chest - bullet punctured lungs, major artery, lodged in hip
- Parmenter hit multiple times, staggered across street, collapsed
- Stolen amount: approximately $15,000
- Blue Buick touring car picked up shooters and fled
- Key detail: Shooter wore felt cap
- Dozens of eyewitnesses present
- Crime scene contaminated - civilians picked up evidence before police arrival
Investigation Begins
- Car disappeared for several days
- Found in Bridgewater woods (south of Braintree)
- License plates removed
- Other tire tracks nearby suggesting car switch
- Parallel investigation: Ferruccio Coacci
- Anarchist scheduled for deportation April 15th
- Failed to appear, called immigration claiming sick wife
- Investigation revealed wife not sick
- Suddenly eager to leave country quickly
- Suspect in previous similar robbery
Police Investigation Intensifies
- Police Chief Michael Stewart investigated Coacci's residence
- Met Mike Boda (Coacci's roommate)
- Showed two-car garage/shed
- Overland car "in shop for repairs"
- Large tire tracks matching Buick found in second stall
- Stewart returned later - found empty apartment, Boda gone
- Contacted garage owner Simon Johnson - asked to call if anyone retrieved car
The Trap - May 5th, 9 PM
- Man claiming to be Mike Boda arrived at garage
- Johnson's wife answered door
- Johnson instructed wife to call police from neighbor's house
- Wife saw motorcycle with sidecar outside
- Observed two men speaking Italian waiting nearby
- Boda became suspicious of delay, fled without car
- Two Italian men left on foot toward Bridgewater rail line
Arrest of Sacco and Vanzetti
- Stewart alerted Brockton police about two Italian men on streetcar
- Police boarded train in Brockton
- Arrested Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti
- Both armed:
- Sacco: .32 Colt pistol
- Vanzetti: .38 Harrington & Richardson (unusual 5-chamber revolver)
- Both gave inconsistent, evolving stories during questioning
- Anarchist pamphlets found on them
- Key evidence: Sacco absent from 3K shoe factory work on April 15th
Defense Committee Formation
- Anarchist community formed Sacco-Vanzetti Defense Committee
- Carlo Tresca (anarchist leader) hired Fred Moore (California radical lawyer)
- Moore's strategy: International publicity campaign
- Mobilize radicals, anarchists, union members worldwide
- Paint defendants as hardworking blue-collar workers being railroaded
- Turn public sentiment against government/prosecutors
- Highlight xenophobia and political persecution
Trial Begins - May 1921
- Judge Webster Thayer presiding
- Prosecutor: Frederick Katzmann (district attorney)
- Weak circumstantial evidence case
- Eyewitness testimony problems:
- Original statements vs. court testimony differed significantly
- Witnesses more certain after year of newspaper exposure
- No single witness placed both defendants at scene
- Ballistics evidence central but problematic:
- Field just beginning - experts were self-taught amateurs
- No genuine ballistics comparison expertise existed yet
Evidence Presented
Prosecution Evidence
- Hat allegedly belonging to Sacco
- Hair comparison conducted (early forensics)
- Katzmann avoided presenting hair evidence due to reliability concerns
- Factory boss George Kelly testified it was Sacco's hat with nail hole
- Hat actually too small for Sacco's head in court demonstration
- Questionable chain of custody - not secured for 30 hours
- Ballistics: Bullet from Berardelli matched Sacco's gun type
- Vanzetti's gun allegedly same type as Berardelli's stolen weapon
Defense Evidence
- Alibis: Sacco in Boston, Vanzetti in Plymouth
- Witnesses testified seeing defendants elsewhere
- Later revealed defense witnesses were friends/coached
- Both prosecution and defense engaged in witness manipulation
Verdict and Aftermath
- Jury deliberated 5.5 hours after 6-week trial
- Verdict: Guilty on all charges
- Sacco cried "I'm innocent" in Italian
- International protests erupted:
- South America, France, Lisbon demonstrations
- Bombings occurred worldwide
- Death sentence: Electric chair
Appeals Process
- Fred Moore filed numerous motions for new trial
- Judge Thayer denied all motions
- Appeals went to federal court, eventually Supreme Court
- Supreme Court refused to hear case (state vs. federal jurisdiction)
- Motion filed based on Judge Thayer's perceived anti-anarchist bias
- William Thompson replaced Moore as defense attorney
- Relentless appeals continued until execution eve
Prison Confession - Celestino Madeiros
- Fellow prisoner passed note confessing to crime
- Claimed Sacco and Vanzetti innocent
- Said he was with four other men, met in Providence bar
- Details partially matched (five men, car switch in woods)
- Inconsistencies: Wrong timing, wrong container for money
- Thompson attempted to use for new trial motion
- Judge Thayer rejected motion
- International press coverage increased pressure
Lowell Commission
- Governor Alvin Fuller appointed three-person advisory committee
- Led by Harvard President Lawrence Lowell
- Investigated case due to international pressure
- Final report: Sacco guilty "beyond reasonable doubt"
- Vanzetti guilty "on the whole, in our opinion"
- Unusual wording for Vanzetti sparked speculation
- Lowell later claimed no indication of innocence intended
Execution - August 23, 1927
- Reunited at Charlestown State Prison after 6 years separation
- Massive police presence due to international tensions
- Sacco executed first:
- Cried "Long Live Anarchy" in Italian
- Said "Farewell my wife and child and all my friends" in English
- Screamed "Mama" when switch thrown
- Vanzetti executed second:
- Proclaimed innocence
- Said "I forgive all of you who are about to do this to me"
- Warden cried during execution
International Reaction
- Riots worldwide: 6 died in Germany riot
- American Embassy in Paris bombed (tanks deployed for execution night)
- 5,000 protesters destroyed American property in Geneva, Switzerland
- Sacco and Vanzetti became symbols of wrongful execution
- Viewed as political prisoners killed for beliefs
Later Revelations
1941 - Carlo Tresca Statement
- Anarchist leader said Sacco guilty (trigger man) but Vanzetti innocent
- Other anarchists heard similar from Tresca
1961 - Ballistics Testing
- Modern testing confirmed bullet came from Sacco's gun
- Some still claimed bullet was planted
- Doug Linder's analysis debunked planted bullet theory
- Prosecution ballistics witnesses gave cautious testimony
- If conspiracy existed, would have given more forceful testimony
2005 - Upton Sinclair Letters
- Famous author researched case, met with Fred Moore
- Moore allegedly confessed: Sacco guilty, Vanzetti innocent
- Defense fabricated alibi witnesses
- Moore faced dilemma: Separating cases would doom Sacco
- Vanzetti reportedly told Moore to try saving Sacco (who had wife/child)
- Vanzetti sacrificed chance at acquittal to help Sacco
Giovanni Gamba's Account
- Son reported father's deathbed confession (1982)
- Father was anarchist involved in defense planning
- Confirmed Sacco guilty, Vanzetti innocent
Historical Assessment
- Likely outcome: Sacco guilty, Vanzetti innocent
- Both executed due to political climate, weak evidence, judicial bias
- Case became symbol of xenophobia and political persecution
- International cause célèbre lasting decades
- Highlighted problems with early forensic evidence
- Demonstrated power of public opinion in legal cases
