AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: The Disappearance of the Yuba County Five | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
49m 51s
Introduction and Background
- Josh introduces 2018 episode reselection about Yuba County Five mystery
- Inspired by recent guest appearance on Shannon McGarvey's "Yuba County Five" podcast from Mopac audio
- Five friends met at Yuba City vocational rehabilitation center for cognitively impaired/challenged individuals
- Ted Weir (32, oldest), Jackie Hewitt (24, youngest), Jack Madruga (between 24-32), Bill Sterling, Gary Matthias
- Three had intellectual/developmental disabilities, Madruga considered "slow" by mother, Matthias treated for schizophrenia
- Known as "the boys" - lived at home with parents, predictable scheduled lives, played basketball together
- Madruga and Matthias had driver's licenses, team played for Gateway Gators
February 24, 1978 - The Night They Disappeared
- Boys left homes around Marysville/Yuba City to travel 50 miles north to Cal State Chico
- Attended basketball game where Cal State LA beat Cal State Chico 86-84
- Around 10 PM went to Bears Market convenience store
- Purchased: Hostess cherry pie, Langendorf lemon pie, Snickers bar, Marathon bar, couple Pepsis, quart and half of milk
- Expected home that night - had basketball game next day for Gateway Gators, extremely excited
- Matthias told mother not to let him oversleep, clothes laid out
- Never returned home - families called police Saturday evening, Madruga's mother called cops by 8 PM
Discovery of the Car
- Tuesday: Jack Madruga's 1969 Mercury Montego found 70 miles from basketball game
- Located up mountain road, different direction from home (southeast of game, not toward home)
- Car found at snow line with window rolled down
- Quarter tank gas remaining, started immediately when police hotwired (keys missing)
- Wheels had spun some but car wasn't stuck - five men could have pushed free
- No engine trouble, maps of California found inside
- Food wrappers found, only Marathon bar partially uneaten
- No damage to underside despite deep ruts on road - suggests careful slow driving
- None of boys were outdoorsy - Sterling had camped there 8 years prior but disliked it
- Weir had gone deer hunting once but didn't enjoy outdoors
Joseph Shones' Account
- 55-year-old Joseph Shones scouting camping area around 5:30 PM same night
- Volkswagen Beetle got stuck 50 yards further than Mercury would be found
- Suffered mild heart attack while pushing car
- Left car running with heater, laid inside gathering strength
- Couple hours later: saw car lights, silhouettes of men, woman with baby - called for help, ignored
- Few hours later: heard whistling sounds, flashlight beams 50 yards away
- Second group believed to be the five boys - again called for help, sounds stopped
- Car eventually ran out of gas, walked 8 miles to Mountain House lodge
- Passed empty Mercury on way out, didn't think much of it until news reports
- Likely last person to see boys alive
Search Efforts and Weather
- Night after disappearance: storm dumped nearly foot of snow on mountain
- Search teams with helicopters, horseback riders found nothing
- Snow made search extremely difficult through winter months
June 4, 1978 - Discovery of Ted Weir
- Motorcycle bikers found smell at old Forest Service trailer camp
- Window broken to enter trailer, Ted Weir's decomposing body inside
- Wrapped in sheets, tucked under head in way he couldn't have done himself
- Originally 200 pounds, found weighing 100-120 pounds (lost 80-100 pounds)
- Leather shoes missing, beard indicated 8-13 weeks survival
- If 13 weeks, died just days before discovery
- Personal items on nightstand: ring with "Ted" engraved, gold necklace, wallet with money
- Mysterious gold Waltham watch with missing crystal - none of families recognized it
- Cabin 20 miles from car location
- Feet terribly frostbitten
The Trailer's Supplies
- Forest Service emergency trailer fully stocked with year's worth of food for all five boys
- Only 12 C-rations opened and eaten, other dehydrated food/fruit cups untouched
- No fire built despite paperback novels, wood furniture, matches available
- Propane tank in outside shed - only needed to turn on for gas heat
- Broken window never covered up
- Gary Matthias's tennis shoes found inside trailer
- Theory: Matthias was there, took Ted's larger leather shoes due to frostbite, left to seek help
Discovery of Other Remains
- Day after Weir found: Sterling and Madruga remains discovered
- Found on different sides of road, 11.5 miles from car (9 miles from trailer)
- Madruga partially eaten by animals, found face-up by stream with hand around watch
- Sterling's bones scattered over 50 feet in woods
- Day later: Jackie Hewitt's father found son's spine quarter-mile from trailer
- Hewitt's Levi's, shirt, stylish platform "Gethers" shoes found nearby
- Next day: Hewitt's skull found 100 yards downhill
Gary Matthias - The Missing Fifth
- Only one never found, still listed on Yuba County sheriff's missing persons page
- Army veteran, treated for schizophrenia but stable for 2 years on medication
- Worked in stepfather's gardening business, considered "sterling success case"
- Left medication at home expecting to return same night
- Previous violent episodes in Germany but none recently while medicated
- Tennis shoes found in trailer suggest he was there
- Theory: Used P-38 military can opener to feed himself and Ted, then left seeking help
Investigation and Theories
- Lieutenant Lance Ayers led investigation, had attended high school with Weir
- Became obsessed with case, even consulted psychics
- Drove every street in Oroville searching for red house based on psychic tip
- Snow cat had packed path day before, creating walkable route to trailer
- Water witcher found disposable lighter 3/4 mile from trailer - families said boys didn't carry lighters
- Madruga's mother Mabel believed someone tricked or threatened boys into going up mountain
- Theory boys witnessed something at basketball game and were chased - disputed by careful driving
- Alternative theory: simple wrong turn, got lost, made poor survival decisions
Unanswered Questions
- Why go up mountain instead of back down toward civilization?
- Why not utilize abundant food supplies in trailer?
- Why not build fire with available materials?
- Why not use propane heat?
- What happened to Gary Matthias?
- Whose watch was found with Ted Weir?
- Who were the people Joseph Shones saw?
- Why make such poor survival decisions despite being in well-stocked shelter?
