AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: The Disappearance of the Yuba County Five | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

49m 51s

Introduction and Background

  • Josh introduces 2018 episode reselection about Yuba County Five mystery
  • Inspired by recent guest appearance on Shannon McGarvey's "Yuba County Five" podcast from Mopac audio
  • Five friends met at Yuba City vocational rehabilitation center for cognitively impaired/challenged individuals
  • Ted Weir (32, oldest), Jackie Hewitt (24, youngest), Jack Madruga (between 24-32), Bill Sterling, Gary Matthias
  • Three had intellectual/developmental disabilities, Madruga considered "slow" by mother, Matthias treated for schizophrenia
  • Known as "the boys" - lived at home with parents, predictable scheduled lives, played basketball together
  • Madruga and Matthias had driver's licenses, team played for Gateway Gators

February 24, 1978 - The Night They Disappeared

  • Boys left homes around Marysville/Yuba City to travel 50 miles north to Cal State Chico
  • Attended basketball game where Cal State LA beat Cal State Chico 86-84
  • Around 10 PM went to Bears Market convenience store
  • Purchased: Hostess cherry pie, Langendorf lemon pie, Snickers bar, Marathon bar, couple Pepsis, quart and half of milk
  • Expected home that night - had basketball game next day for Gateway Gators, extremely excited
  • Matthias told mother not to let him oversleep, clothes laid out
  • Never returned home - families called police Saturday evening, Madruga's mother called cops by 8 PM

Discovery of the Car

  • Tuesday: Jack Madruga's 1969 Mercury Montego found 70 miles from basketball game
  • Located up mountain road, different direction from home (southeast of game, not toward home)
  • Car found at snow line with window rolled down
  • Quarter tank gas remaining, started immediately when police hotwired (keys missing)
  • Wheels had spun some but car wasn't stuck - five men could have pushed free
  • No engine trouble, maps of California found inside
  • Food wrappers found, only Marathon bar partially uneaten
  • No damage to underside despite deep ruts on road - suggests careful slow driving
  • None of boys were outdoorsy - Sterling had camped there 8 years prior but disliked it
  • Weir had gone deer hunting once but didn't enjoy outdoors

Joseph Shones' Account

  • 55-year-old Joseph Shones scouting camping area around 5:30 PM same night
  • Volkswagen Beetle got stuck 50 yards further than Mercury would be found
  • Suffered mild heart attack while pushing car
  • Left car running with heater, laid inside gathering strength
  • Couple hours later: saw car lights, silhouettes of men, woman with baby - called for help, ignored
  • Few hours later: heard whistling sounds, flashlight beams 50 yards away
  • Second group believed to be the five boys - again called for help, sounds stopped
  • Car eventually ran out of gas, walked 8 miles to Mountain House lodge
  • Passed empty Mercury on way out, didn't think much of it until news reports
  • Likely last person to see boys alive

Search Efforts and Weather

  • Night after disappearance: storm dumped nearly foot of snow on mountain
  • Search teams with helicopters, horseback riders found nothing
  • Snow made search extremely difficult through winter months

June 4, 1978 - Discovery of Ted Weir

  • Motorcycle bikers found smell at old Forest Service trailer camp
  • Window broken to enter trailer, Ted Weir's decomposing body inside
  • Wrapped in sheets, tucked under head in way he couldn't have done himself
  • Originally 200 pounds, found weighing 100-120 pounds (lost 80-100 pounds)
  • Leather shoes missing, beard indicated 8-13 weeks survival
  • If 13 weeks, died just days before discovery
  • Personal items on nightstand: ring with "Ted" engraved, gold necklace, wallet with money
  • Mysterious gold Waltham watch with missing crystal - none of families recognized it
  • Cabin 20 miles from car location
  • Feet terribly frostbitten

The Trailer's Supplies

  • Forest Service emergency trailer fully stocked with year's worth of food for all five boys
  • Only 12 C-rations opened and eaten, other dehydrated food/fruit cups untouched
  • No fire built despite paperback novels, wood furniture, matches available
  • Propane tank in outside shed - only needed to turn on for gas heat
  • Broken window never covered up
  • Gary Matthias's tennis shoes found inside trailer
  • Theory: Matthias was there, took Ted's larger leather shoes due to frostbite, left to seek help

Discovery of Other Remains

  • Day after Weir found: Sterling and Madruga remains discovered
  • Found on different sides of road, 11.5 miles from car (9 miles from trailer)
  • Madruga partially eaten by animals, found face-up by stream with hand around watch
  • Sterling's bones scattered over 50 feet in woods
  • Day later: Jackie Hewitt's father found son's spine quarter-mile from trailer
  • Hewitt's Levi's, shirt, stylish platform "Gethers" shoes found nearby
  • Next day: Hewitt's skull found 100 yards downhill

Gary Matthias - The Missing Fifth

  • Only one never found, still listed on Yuba County sheriff's missing persons page
  • Army veteran, treated for schizophrenia but stable for 2 years on medication
  • Worked in stepfather's gardening business, considered "sterling success case"
  • Left medication at home expecting to return same night
  • Previous violent episodes in Germany but none recently while medicated
  • Tennis shoes found in trailer suggest he was there
  • Theory: Used P-38 military can opener to feed himself and Ted, then left seeking help

Investigation and Theories

  • Lieutenant Lance Ayers led investigation, had attended high school with Weir
  • Became obsessed with case, even consulted psychics
  • Drove every street in Oroville searching for red house based on psychic tip
  • Snow cat had packed path day before, creating walkable route to trailer
  • Water witcher found disposable lighter 3/4 mile from trailer - families said boys didn't carry lighters
  • Madruga's mother Mabel believed someone tricked or threatened boys into going up mountain
  • Theory boys witnessed something at basketball game and were chased - disputed by careful driving
  • Alternative theory: simple wrong turn, got lost, made poor survival decisions

Unanswered Questions

  • Why go up mountain instead of back down toward civilization?
  • Why not utilize abundant food supplies in trailer?
  • Why not build fire with available materials?
  • Why not use propane heat?
  • What happened to Gary Matthias?
  • Whose watch was found with Ted Weir?
  • Who were the people Joseph Shones saw?
  • Why make such poor survival decisions despite being in well-stocked shelter?

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome