AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: The Unsolved Mystery Disappearance of the Sodder Children | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

44m 16s

Episode Introduction & Background

  • Josh introduces 2016 episode as sysk select about Solder children disappearance
  • Tragic story of 5 children who vanished after Christmas Eve house fire in 1945
  • One of Josh's all-time favorite episodes

George Solder's Immigration & Early Life

  • Born in Sardinia 1895, immigrated to US 1908 at age 13
  • Older brother returned to Italy immediately after Ellis Island
  • Worked Pennsylvania Railroad, moved to Smithers West Virginia
  • Started own trucking business hauling coal and dirt
  • Solidly middle class, described as "one of the best middle class families in Fayetteville"

Family Formation & Italian Community

  • Married Jenny Cipriani (came from Italy at age 3)
  • Met at store called "the music box"
  • Had 10 children in 20 years
  • Moved to Fayetteville, part of small Italian community
  • George well-known for outspoken political opinions, particularly hatred of Mussolini
  • Got into arguments with locals who felt differently about Mussolini

Pre-Fire Warning Signs

  • Stranger appeared months before asking for work
    • Examined fuse box, said "wiring here is going to cause a fire someday"
    • George had recently had wiring inspected and redone for new electric stove
  • Life insurance salesman incident
    • Tried to sell policies for children, George refused
    • Salesman became irate: "your house is going to go up in smoke, your GD house"
    • "Your children are going to be destroyed"
    • "You will be repaid for the dirty things you've been saying about Mussolini"
    • Same man later served on coroner's inquest jury that ruled fire was faulty wiring
  • Older son reported man parked across from house watching school bus and younger children

Christmas Eve 1945 - The Night of the Fire

  • Family opened some presents Christmas Eve as tradition
  • 5 youngest children (Maurice 14, Martha 12, Lewis 10, Jenny 8, Betty 5) asked to stay up late with new toys
  • Sister Marion (17) had surprised them with toys from five-and-dime where she worked
  • Parents George and Jenny went to bed ~10pm with 2-year-old Sylvia
  • 23-year-old John and 16-year-old George Jr also went to bed
  • Eldest son away in military fighting WWII

The Fire Begins

  • 12:30am: Phone rings, wrong number call
    • Woman asking for unknown person
    • Party sounds in background (laughter, clinking glasses)
    • Woman laughed weirdly and hung up
  • Jenny went downstairs, found lights on, doors unlocked
  • Locked doors, turned off lights, left one child asleep on couch
  • Assumed 5 missing children had gone upstairs to bed
  • ~1:30am: Jenny heard heavy thump on roof and sliding sound
  • Went back to sleep, later awoke to house on fire

The Fire & Escape Attempts

  • Parents escaped with 2-year-old Sylvia
  • Marion (17), John (23), George Jr (16) got out safely
  • 5 children trapped on upper floor, only way down was single staircase
  • George broke window, cut arm badly trying to get inside
  • Downstairs completely engulfed, couldn't reach staircase
  • Conflicting accounts: sons initially said they physically shook siblings awake, later said they only called out
  • George's ladder missing from usual spot (found 75 feet away in ditch)
  • Both work trucks wouldn't start despite working earlier that day

Fire Department Response

  • Daughter went to neighbor to call fire department - no operators on duty
  • Another neighbor went to tavern to call - also couldn't reach operator
  • Someone physically tracked down fire chief FJ Morris
  • Morris said he couldn't drive fire truck, had to wait for someone who could
  • Fire department used "phone tree" system to alert volunteers
  • Fire truck arrived 7 hours later at 8am
  • House burned completely in 30-45 minutes
  • Fire chief later defended delay saying house burned too fast for them to help

Initial Investigation & Burial

  • No remains of 5 children found in rubble
  • Fire chief said children burned to nothing
  • Cursory examination found appliances and other items but no human remains
  • State Police Inspector ruled faulty wiring as cause
  • January 2nd: George buried site with 5 feet of fill dirt for memorial garden
  • Wasn't supposed to do this - should have left site open for continued investigation

Family Begins to Suspect

  • George knew wiring wasn't faulty - recently inspected and redone
  • Christmas tree lights still on during fire (Jenny had left them on)
  • Family started noticing strange details and inconsistencies
  • No human remains found despite thorough burning of other materials
  • National press attention began

Family's Investigation Efforts

  • Jenny taught herself forensics about burning remains
  • Conducted experiments burning animal bones - always left remains
  • Consulted crematorium: 2000 degrees for 2 hours needed to completely burn body
  • House fire nowhere near that hot, only burned 30-45 minutes
  • Researched other fires - found 7-person fire where all remains were recovered
  • 1949: Hired forensic investigator to excavate memorial site

1949 Excavation Results

  • Found coins, dictionary belonging to children
  • Discovered vertebrae, sent to Smithsonian Institution
  • Smithsonian report: bones from individual aged 16-17 (max 22)
  • Oldest missing child was 14, so bones didn't match
  • Bones not charred, not from fire
  • Either planted or came from fill dirt (possibly disturbed unmarked grave)
  • Found green rubber casing from incendiary device/bomb
  • Smithsonian noted curious absence of children's remains

Official Response & Private Investigation

  • Governor and State Police Superintendent declared case hopeless and closed
  • Family hired private detective who heard rumor about fire chief
  • Fire chief admitted to burying fresh beef liver in box at site
  • Hoped someone would find it, think it was body part, and close case
  • FBI offered help through J. Edgar Hoover but required local invitation
  • Local police declined FBI assistance

Sightings & Leads

  • Woman at truck stop 50 miles west: saw children morning after fire
    • Served them breakfast, got into car with Florida plates
  • Charleston hotel: 4 children checked in with 2 Italian women and 2 men
    • Children seemed scared, adults spoke Italian and left quickly
  • Lady claimed to see children in car driving by during fire
  • 1967 Houston letter: claimed Lewis lived there, got drunk and revealed identity
  • Various reports of Martha in western convent
  • George traveled country chasing leads, always returned empty-handed

The 1968 Mysterious Letter

  • Letter addressed specifically to Jenny, postmarked Kentucky
  • Contained photo of Italian man in mid-20s
  • Back inscription: "Lewis Solder I love brother Frankie"
  • Additional cryptic text: "i-l-i-l boys a little boys" and "a90132 or 35"
  • Family thought photo could be Lewis but features didn't perfectly match
  • Mystery never solved

The Billboard Campaign

  • Family erected billboard on their property in 1950s
  • Featured large pictures of 5 children with names and ages
  • Described family's theory of what happened
  • Initially offered $5,000 reward, later increased to $10,000
  • Billboard remained until 1980s
  • Famous throughout West Virginia (except to McElroy family)

Additional Suspicious Details

  • Telephone lines were cut
  • Bus driver claimed to see someone throwing "fireballs" onto house
  • Private investigator hired to trace 1968 letter disappeared completely
  • May have been scam artist who took desperate family's money

Mafia Theory

  • Leading theory: George approached by mafia, rebuffed advances
  • Mafia heavily involved in coal and trucking business in area
  • George's personality fit someone who would tell mafia to "stick it"
  • Anti-Mussolini stance may have made additional enemies
  • Family rationalized children's silence as protecting parents from danger

Later Years & Legacy

  • George died 1968, Jenny died 1989
  • Billboard removed after Jenny's death
  • Sylvia (2-year-old survivor) last surviving Solder child
  • Earliest memories are of fire night and father bleeding trying to enter house
  • Promised parents to keep story alive
  • Participates in online sleuth websites discussing case
  • Vertebrae evidence lost to time, can't be DNA tested now

Expert Opinion

  • NPR's Stacy Horn researched extensively
  • Personally believes children died in fire
  • Media tends to play up mystery angle
  • Enough weird circumstances that wouldn't be shocked if children survived
  • Case remains one of strangest unsolved mysteries in American history

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome