AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: The Unsolved Mystery Disappearance of the Sodder Children | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
44m 16s
Episode Introduction & Background
- Josh introduces 2016 episode as sysk select about Solder children disappearance
- Tragic story of 5 children who vanished after Christmas Eve house fire in 1945
- One of Josh's all-time favorite episodes
George Solder's Immigration & Early Life
- Born in Sardinia 1895, immigrated to US 1908 at age 13
- Older brother returned to Italy immediately after Ellis Island
- Worked Pennsylvania Railroad, moved to Smithers West Virginia
- Started own trucking business hauling coal and dirt
- Solidly middle class, described as "one of the best middle class families in Fayetteville"
Family Formation & Italian Community
- Married Jenny Cipriani (came from Italy at age 3)
- Met at store called "the music box"
- Had 10 children in 20 years
- Moved to Fayetteville, part of small Italian community
- George well-known for outspoken political opinions, particularly hatred of Mussolini
- Got into arguments with locals who felt differently about Mussolini
Pre-Fire Warning Signs
- Stranger appeared months before asking for work
- Examined fuse box, said "wiring here is going to cause a fire someday"
- George had recently had wiring inspected and redone for new electric stove
- Life insurance salesman incident
- Tried to sell policies for children, George refused
- Salesman became irate: "your house is going to go up in smoke, your GD house"
- "Your children are going to be destroyed"
- "You will be repaid for the dirty things you've been saying about Mussolini"
- Same man later served on coroner's inquest jury that ruled fire was faulty wiring
- Older son reported man parked across from house watching school bus and younger children
Christmas Eve 1945 - The Night of the Fire
- Family opened some presents Christmas Eve as tradition
- 5 youngest children (Maurice 14, Martha 12, Lewis 10, Jenny 8, Betty 5) asked to stay up late with new toys
- Sister Marion (17) had surprised them with toys from five-and-dime where she worked
- Parents George and Jenny went to bed ~10pm with 2-year-old Sylvia
- 23-year-old John and 16-year-old George Jr also went to bed
- Eldest son away in military fighting WWII
The Fire Begins
- 12:30am: Phone rings, wrong number call
- Woman asking for unknown person
- Party sounds in background (laughter, clinking glasses)
- Woman laughed weirdly and hung up
- Jenny went downstairs, found lights on, doors unlocked
- Locked doors, turned off lights, left one child asleep on couch
- Assumed 5 missing children had gone upstairs to bed
- ~1:30am: Jenny heard heavy thump on roof and sliding sound
- Went back to sleep, later awoke to house on fire
The Fire & Escape Attempts
- Parents escaped with 2-year-old Sylvia
- Marion (17), John (23), George Jr (16) got out safely
- 5 children trapped on upper floor, only way down was single staircase
- George broke window, cut arm badly trying to get inside
- Downstairs completely engulfed, couldn't reach staircase
- Conflicting accounts: sons initially said they physically shook siblings awake, later said they only called out
- George's ladder missing from usual spot (found 75 feet away in ditch)
- Both work trucks wouldn't start despite working earlier that day
Fire Department Response
- Daughter went to neighbor to call fire department - no operators on duty
- Another neighbor went to tavern to call - also couldn't reach operator
- Someone physically tracked down fire chief FJ Morris
- Morris said he couldn't drive fire truck, had to wait for someone who could
- Fire department used "phone tree" system to alert volunteers
- Fire truck arrived 7 hours later at 8am
- House burned completely in 30-45 minutes
- Fire chief later defended delay saying house burned too fast for them to help
Initial Investigation & Burial
- No remains of 5 children found in rubble
- Fire chief said children burned to nothing
- Cursory examination found appliances and other items but no human remains
- State Police Inspector ruled faulty wiring as cause
- January 2nd: George buried site with 5 feet of fill dirt for memorial garden
- Wasn't supposed to do this - should have left site open for continued investigation
Family Begins to Suspect
- George knew wiring wasn't faulty - recently inspected and redone
- Christmas tree lights still on during fire (Jenny had left them on)
- Family started noticing strange details and inconsistencies
- No human remains found despite thorough burning of other materials
- National press attention began
Family's Investigation Efforts
- Jenny taught herself forensics about burning remains
- Conducted experiments burning animal bones - always left remains
- Consulted crematorium: 2000 degrees for 2 hours needed to completely burn body
- House fire nowhere near that hot, only burned 30-45 minutes
- Researched other fires - found 7-person fire where all remains were recovered
- 1949: Hired forensic investigator to excavate memorial site
1949 Excavation Results
- Found coins, dictionary belonging to children
- Discovered vertebrae, sent to Smithsonian Institution
- Smithsonian report: bones from individual aged 16-17 (max 22)
- Oldest missing child was 14, so bones didn't match
- Bones not charred, not from fire
- Either planted or came from fill dirt (possibly disturbed unmarked grave)
- Found green rubber casing from incendiary device/bomb
- Smithsonian noted curious absence of children's remains
Official Response & Private Investigation
- Governor and State Police Superintendent declared case hopeless and closed
- Family hired private detective who heard rumor about fire chief
- Fire chief admitted to burying fresh beef liver in box at site
- Hoped someone would find it, think it was body part, and close case
- FBI offered help through J. Edgar Hoover but required local invitation
- Local police declined FBI assistance
Sightings & Leads
- Woman at truck stop 50 miles west: saw children morning after fire
- Served them breakfast, got into car with Florida plates
- Charleston hotel: 4 children checked in with 2 Italian women and 2 men
- Children seemed scared, adults spoke Italian and left quickly
- Lady claimed to see children in car driving by during fire
- 1967 Houston letter: claimed Lewis lived there, got drunk and revealed identity
- Various reports of Martha in western convent
- George traveled country chasing leads, always returned empty-handed
The 1968 Mysterious Letter
- Letter addressed specifically to Jenny, postmarked Kentucky
- Contained photo of Italian man in mid-20s
- Back inscription: "Lewis Solder I love brother Frankie"
- Additional cryptic text: "i-l-i-l boys a little boys" and "a90132 or 35"
- Family thought photo could be Lewis but features didn't perfectly match
- Mystery never solved
The Billboard Campaign
- Family erected billboard on their property in 1950s
- Featured large pictures of 5 children with names and ages
- Described family's theory of what happened
- Initially offered $5,000 reward, later increased to $10,000
- Billboard remained until 1980s
- Famous throughout West Virginia (except to McElroy family)
Additional Suspicious Details
- Telephone lines were cut
- Bus driver claimed to see someone throwing "fireballs" onto house
- Private investigator hired to trace 1968 letter disappeared completely
- May have been scam artist who took desperate family's money
Mafia Theory
- Leading theory: George approached by mafia, rebuffed advances
- Mafia heavily involved in coal and trucking business in area
- George's personality fit someone who would tell mafia to "stick it"
- Anti-Mussolini stance may have made additional enemies
- Family rationalized children's silence as protecting parents from danger
Later Years & Legacy
- George died 1968, Jenny died 1989
- Billboard removed after Jenny's death
- Sylvia (2-year-old survivor) last surviving Solder child
- Earliest memories are of fire night and father bleeding trying to enter house
- Promised parents to keep story alive
- Participates in online sleuth websites discussing case
- Vertebrae evidence lost to time, can't be DNA tested now
Expert Opinion
- NPR's Stacy Horn researched extensively
- Personally believes children died in fire
- Media tends to play up mystery angle
- Enough weird circumstances that wouldn't be shocked if children survived
- Case remains one of strangest unsolved mysteries in American history
