AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: What are think tanks all about? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
45m 45s
Introduction and Definition
- Josh introduces "Stuff You Should Know" episode on think tanks from September 2018
- Think tanks = nonprofit organizations where smart people research problems and develop policy solutions
- Ideally nonpartisan, fact-based, evidence-driven research to influence public policy
- Goal: identify problems → research solutions → present to policymakers → influence public debate → policy adoption
Historical Origins
- Plato's Academy (ancient Greece) - considered world's first think tank
- Philosophers gathered to discuss reality, existence, knowledge
- Developed foundational concepts like probability vs absolute truth
- Modern think tanks emerged:
- 1831: Royal United Services Institution (UK) - military science
- 1910: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace (US)
- 1916: Brookings Institution - most famous American think tank
Golden Age Accomplishments
- Brookings Institution major achievements:
- Helped construct FDR's New Deal
- Developed Marshall Plan after WWII
- Marshall Plan: restored Europe to 25% above pre-war production levels in 2 years
- Prevented Western Europe from adopting communism
- RAND Corporation contributions:
- Developed computers, Internet, spy satellites, Space Program
- Originally R&D (Research & Development) focused on technology
- Post-WWII proliferation due to government needing research support
Tax Exemption and Regulations
- 1913: Think tanks granted tax-exempt status
- 1950s: Congress imposed restrictions for tax exemption:
- Must be nonpartisan
- Cannot officially support/endorse candidates
- Must provide objective educational information
- Must serve public good
Modern Transformation to Advocacy
- 1980s: Heritage Foundation provided Reagan with 2,000+ policy recommendations
- Reagan implemented ~67% during his two terms
- Progressive Policy Institute similarly advised Clinton administration
- Rise of advocacy think tanks with explicit political alignments:
- Center for American Progress (liberal) - founded after 2000 Democratic losses
- Heritage Foundation (conservative)
- American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC)
Corporate Funding Problems
- Shift from philanthropic endowments to corporate/wealthy donor funding
- Donors now micromanage and direct research outcomes
- Examples of corporate influence:
- Koch brothers + Exxon Mobile funded climate change denial research ($120M to 100+ groups)
- Atlas Economic Research Foundation, International Policy Network
- Walton Family Foundation funded both conservative causes and Obama's ACA
- Strategic: ACA employer healthcare mandates hurt small competitors more than Walmart
Brookings Institution Decline
- Historically centrist (scored 53/100 on liberal scale)
- Now soliciting corporate donations, hired lobbyist as strategic development chief
- Lenard Corporation example: $400K for credibility, conferences, talking heads
- Circulating drafts to donors for input before publication
Current Challenges
- Death of expertise phenomenon
- Public distrust due to manipulation and misinformation
- Internet/social media competition:
- Shortened news cycles
- TED talks, Facebook videos more influential than research papers
- Example: RAND's thorough vaccine-autism debunking vs Facebook anti-vax groups
- Think tanks losing relevance to democratized information sources
ALEC and State Policy Networks
- Corporate Bill Mill churning out hundreds of model bills annually
- State Policy Network: confederation in every state + Puerto Rico
- Uses courts rather than legislation to overturn laws
- Corporate interests directly writing legislation
Financial Transparency Issues
- Tax-exempt status allows non-disclosure of donors
- Unregistered lobbyist organizations in practice
- Both liberal and conservative think tanks affected
- 2013: The Nation revealed Center for American Progress positions shaped by donors
