AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: What's the deal with Stradivarius violins? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
40m 30s
Introduction and Violin Basics
- Josh introduces episode selection from September 2016 on Stradivarius violins
- Chuck discusses personal experience buying violin, took one lesson, became "expert"
- Also bought steel guitar, keyboard, piano - pattern of buying instruments without learning
- Violin vs fiddle: no difference, just different playing styles (hillbillies vs others)
Early Violin History
- 16th century: violin initially considered cheap tavern instrument
- Church in Italy ordered destruction of violins due to poor reputation
- 1564: Catherine de Medici ordered 38 violins from Nicholas Amati, changing violin's respectability
- Cremona, Italy became center of violin production due to Amati family
- Amatis credited as de facto inventors of violin, cello, viola as recognized today
Violin Construction and Design
- Violin shape designed for sound quality, not aesthetics
- Curves allow equal resonance of all notes
- C-bouts (waist cuts) allow bow to play strings without hitting body
- Parts: scroll, peg box, tuning pegs, neck, fingerboard, upper bout, lower bout, C-bout, F-holes, bridge, tailpiece, chin rest
Antonio Stradivari Background
- Born ~1644 in Cremona, early life mysterious
- 1666: First violin with inscription "made by Antonio Verdi of Cremona pupil of Nicola Amati"
- Debate whether actually pupil or career move (Amati still alive, could have disputed)
- 1680: Moved into home, started gaining recognition
- 1684: When Nicola Amati died, Stradivari became Cremona's best violin maker
- Made violins, cellos, guitars, mandolins, harps
Stradivari's Innovations and Golden Period
- Modified Amati design: straighter C-bout, longer F-holes, larger scroll
- Developed signature deep red-brown varnish formula
- Master woodworker with flawless craftsmanship
- Golden period: 1700-1720/1725 - produced best violins in history
- 1716: Built "The Messiah" - his crowning achievement, never sold, kept in workshop
- Famous violins from golden period: Messiah (1716), Elard (1715), Bets (1704)
Personal Life and Legacy
- First wife: 6 children, died 1698
- Second wife: 5 more children (11 total)
- Called "Maestro in the bedroom"
- Sons followed footsteps but couldn't match father's work
- Post-1720: Continued working but eyesight failing, hands less steady
- Worked into 90s, building violins for ~70 years
- Made 1,000-1,500 stringed instruments total, ~650 survive today
Violin Naming and Characteristics
- Stradivarius violins named after most famous player who owned them
- Superstition: violins take on character of player who plays them most
- More playing = better sound (scientifically proven)
- 1996 study: vibration lowers dampening coefficient, longer note resonance
- Breaking in instruments improves sound quality
Theories About Stradivarius Excellence
- Old theories debunked: salt water soaking, volcanic ash coating, dragon's blood varnish
- Little Ice Age theory: colder temperatures produced slower-growing, more uniform spruce wood
- Problem: same wood available to other European makers, their violins don't sound like Stradivarius
- Texas A&M Professor Joseph Nagaveri's varnish theory:
- Analyzed varnish chemically, found borax and chromium
- Theory: chemicals added for protection actually weakened wood, made it porous
- Created richer, more powerful tone
- Received significant pushback from violin community
Expert Opinions
- James Ehnes (violinist): "probably thousand things make them special, never just one key"
- BBC documentary violin maker: right place, right time, plus exceptional craftsman
- Resistance to idea that excellence was accidental
- Stradivarius objectively better than other violins, even 300 years later
Current Market and Values
- Prices vary widely: $3.544 million record, then $3.6 million (Molitor)
- 2014: Kreutzer estimated $7.5-10 million, failed to reach reserve
- 2011: One sold for $16 million
- Wealthy collectors driving prices up dramatically
- Instruments bought for hundreds of thousands 20-30 years ago now worth 10-20x more
- Shame great players can't afford them unless from wealthy families
The Messiah Violin
- Most valuable Stradivarius, considered priceless
- Owned by Ashmolean Museum at Oxford University
- Rarely played, kept in pristine condition
- Features nativity scene inlay on tailpiece
- BBC documentary showed violinist holding with white cotton gloves
Fakes and Forgeries
- Massive production of fakes began immediately after Stradivari's death
- 18th-19th century: mass-produced violins with Stradivarius labels, largely from Germany/Czechoslovakia
- Buyers knew they were knockoffs at time of purchase
- Problem: old violins with authentic-looking labels saying "Stradivarius cremonesis facibat ano [year]"
- People finding in attics think they've found real Stradivarius
- Appraisers frustrated by constant calls from hopeful owners
Authentication Reality
- Only ~650 authentic Stradivarius violins exist worldwide
- All basically accounted for by experts
- Very small community tracks ownership
- Like finding new Rembrandt - experts know what exists and where
- Famous theft: Stradivarius stolen from concert violinist, found 30+ years later in Milwaukee thief's attic
- Joshua Bell possibly left Stradivarius in taxi cab
Listener Mail
- Email from Rebecca "Bex" Bloomfield praising Chuck's comments about women in STEM fields
- Appreciated Chuck's point about what could have been achieved if women allowed in science from start
- Noted Chuck made point well without mansplaining
- Emphasized both men and women should have choice in careers regardless of gender
