AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: What's the deal with Stradivarius violins? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

40m 30s

Introduction and Violin Basics

  • Josh introduces episode selection from September 2016 on Stradivarius violins
  • Chuck discusses personal experience buying violin, took one lesson, became "expert"
  • Also bought steel guitar, keyboard, piano - pattern of buying instruments without learning
  • Violin vs fiddle: no difference, just different playing styles (hillbillies vs others)

Early Violin History

  • 16th century: violin initially considered cheap tavern instrument
  • Church in Italy ordered destruction of violins due to poor reputation
  • 1564: Catherine de Medici ordered 38 violins from Nicholas Amati, changing violin's respectability
  • Cremona, Italy became center of violin production due to Amati family
  • Amatis credited as de facto inventors of violin, cello, viola as recognized today

Violin Construction and Design

  • Violin shape designed for sound quality, not aesthetics
  • Curves allow equal resonance of all notes
  • C-bouts (waist cuts) allow bow to play strings without hitting body
  • Parts: scroll, peg box, tuning pegs, neck, fingerboard, upper bout, lower bout, C-bout, F-holes, bridge, tailpiece, chin rest

Antonio Stradivari Background

  • Born ~1644 in Cremona, early life mysterious
  • 1666: First violin with inscription "made by Antonio Verdi of Cremona pupil of Nicola Amati"
  • Debate whether actually pupil or career move (Amati still alive, could have disputed)
  • 1680: Moved into home, started gaining recognition
  • 1684: When Nicola Amati died, Stradivari became Cremona's best violin maker
  • Made violins, cellos, guitars, mandolins, harps

Stradivari's Innovations and Golden Period

  • Modified Amati design: straighter C-bout, longer F-holes, larger scroll
  • Developed signature deep red-brown varnish formula
  • Master woodworker with flawless craftsmanship
  • Golden period: 1700-1720/1725 - produced best violins in history
  • 1716: Built "The Messiah" - his crowning achievement, never sold, kept in workshop
  • Famous violins from golden period: Messiah (1716), Elard (1715), Bets (1704)

Personal Life and Legacy

  • First wife: 6 children, died 1698
  • Second wife: 5 more children (11 total)
  • Called "Maestro in the bedroom"
  • Sons followed footsteps but couldn't match father's work
  • Post-1720: Continued working but eyesight failing, hands less steady
  • Worked into 90s, building violins for ~70 years
  • Made 1,000-1,500 stringed instruments total, ~650 survive today

Violin Naming and Characteristics

  • Stradivarius violins named after most famous player who owned them
  • Superstition: violins take on character of player who plays them most
  • More playing = better sound (scientifically proven)
  • 1996 study: vibration lowers dampening coefficient, longer note resonance
  • Breaking in instruments improves sound quality

Theories About Stradivarius Excellence

  • Old theories debunked: salt water soaking, volcanic ash coating, dragon's blood varnish
  • Little Ice Age theory: colder temperatures produced slower-growing, more uniform spruce wood
    • Problem: same wood available to other European makers, their violins don't sound like Stradivarius
  • Texas A&M Professor Joseph Nagaveri's varnish theory:
    • Analyzed varnish chemically, found borax and chromium
    • Theory: chemicals added for protection actually weakened wood, made it porous
    • Created richer, more powerful tone
    • Received significant pushback from violin community

Expert Opinions

  • James Ehnes (violinist): "probably thousand things make them special, never just one key"
  • BBC documentary violin maker: right place, right time, plus exceptional craftsman
  • Resistance to idea that excellence was accidental
  • Stradivarius objectively better than other violins, even 300 years later

Current Market and Values

  • Prices vary widely: $3.544 million record, then $3.6 million (Molitor)
  • 2014: Kreutzer estimated $7.5-10 million, failed to reach reserve
  • 2011: One sold for $16 million
  • Wealthy collectors driving prices up dramatically
  • Instruments bought for hundreds of thousands 20-30 years ago now worth 10-20x more
  • Shame great players can't afford them unless from wealthy families

The Messiah Violin

  • Most valuable Stradivarius, considered priceless
  • Owned by Ashmolean Museum at Oxford University
  • Rarely played, kept in pristine condition
  • Features nativity scene inlay on tailpiece
  • BBC documentary showed violinist holding with white cotton gloves

Fakes and Forgeries

  • Massive production of fakes began immediately after Stradivari's death
  • 18th-19th century: mass-produced violins with Stradivarius labels, largely from Germany/Czechoslovakia
  • Buyers knew they were knockoffs at time of purchase
  • Problem: old violins with authentic-looking labels saying "Stradivarius cremonesis facibat ano [year]"
  • People finding in attics think they've found real Stradivarius
  • Appraisers frustrated by constant calls from hopeful owners

Authentication Reality

  • Only ~650 authentic Stradivarius violins exist worldwide
  • All basically accounted for by experts
  • Very small community tracks ownership
  • Like finding new Rembrandt - experts know what exists and where
  • Famous theft: Stradivarius stolen from concert violinist, found 30+ years later in Milwaukee thief's attic
  • Joshua Bell possibly left Stradivarius in taxi cab

Listener Mail

  • Email from Rebecca "Bex" Bloomfield praising Chuck's comments about women in STEM fields
  • Appreciated Chuck's point about what could have been achieved if women allowed in science from start
  • Noted Chuck made point well without mansplaining
  • Emphasized both men and women should have choice in careers regardless of gender

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome