AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: What's the misery index? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

44m 23s

Introduction and Personal Updates

  • Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant hosting Stuff You Should Know podcast
  • Chuck's middle name discussion: Charles W (Wayne) Bryant, not named after Wayne Gretzky
  • Chuck picking up 4 new Last Chance garage hats from Inman Park shop
    • Thanks to Katie (custom patch maker) at tulip cake.com (c-u-l-i-p cake)
    • Thanks to Lamud hats (l-a-m-o-o-d) for big heads/oversized hats
  • Overdue thanks to Matt Street at fatbison.com for wood carved sign used in TV show

Economics as "New Astrology"

  • Article by Alan J. Levinovitz on aeon.co comparing economics to ancient Chinese astrology
  • Economics valid for understanding past, flawed for future forecasting
  • Problem: economists act like they have definitive answers despite liberal vs conservative economics disagreement

Arthur Okun and Origins of Misery Index

  • Arthur Okun worked on Kennedy's Council of Economic Advisors (1961)
  • US in recession when Kennedy took office
  • Okun convinced Kennedy to simultaneously increase government spending AND cut taxes (unusual approach)
  • Strategy successful, US entered economic boom
  • Okun became head of Council of Economic Advisors under Johnson

Okun's Law Discovery

  • Analyzed data from 1948-1960 (when unemployment recording began)
  • Found: GNP rises 3% for every 1% unemployment falls
  • Caveat: only applies when unemployment between 3-7.5%
  • Became verified economic principle called "Okun's Law"

1970s Economic Crisis and Stagflation

  • 1973 Arab Oil Embargo following Egypt/Syria invasion of Golan Heights/Sinai Peninsula
  • US found supplying arms to Israel, Arab states shut off oil to US
  • Oil prices rose 37%, gas rationing implemented
  • Led to unprecedented stagflation: high inflation + high unemployment simultaneously
  • Previously economists assumed these were mutually exclusive
  • Economic disruption lasted entire decade

Creation of Misery Index (1973)

  • Okun created simple formula: yearly inflation rate + unemployment rate
  • Example: 5% inflation + 2% unemployment = 7% misery index
  • Designed to measure average American's daily economic experience
  • Could analyze historical data back to 1948 (limited by unemployment data availability)

Presidential Elections and Misery Index Correlation

  • 1956: Misery index 6.53, Eisenhower reelected
  • 1968: Index 8.13, Johnson/Humphrey lost to Nixon
  • Nixon's first term: Index rose to 11.67, still got reelected
  • 1974: All-time high 17.01 during Watergate
  • Theory: Watergate might not have been fatal if misery index was lower

Carter and Reagan Era

  • Ford briefly lowered index to 12.66, insufficient to prevent Carter victory
  • Carter campaigned citing misery index
  • Under Carter: Index reached all-time high 21.98
  • Reagan used Carter's misery index against him in campaign
  • Reagan lowered index to 9.55 by end of term

Presidential Performance Through Misery Index

  • Bush Sr.: Index increased slightly
  • Clinton: Brought down to 7.35
  • Bush Jr.: Rose from 7.35 to 11.4
  • Obama: Decreased to 7.87
  • 2000 election considered rare instance where misery index didn't predict outcome
  • 2008 financial crisis exposed flaws: low misery index despite stock market crash and rising unemployment

Enhanced Misery Index Versions

Robert Barro's 1996 Improvements

  • Book: "Getting It Right: Markets and Choices in a Free Society"
  • Added 4 measurements to original formula:
    • Inflation rate during last year of presidency vs average over successor's term
    • Same comparison for unemployment
    • Changes in 30-year government bond yield
    • Difference in long-term GDP growth rates
  • Results: Clinton and Reagan performed best under Barro misery index

Steve Hanke's 2006 Global Version

  • Added interest rates, subtracted annual GDP percentages
  • Adapted for international use, including countries with price controls
  • Used black market exchange rates to determine real inflation
  • 2014 results: Venezuela most miserable (79.4), Japan least miserable (5.41), US ranked 19th with 11 rating

Alternative Measurements and Criticisms

Unemployment Statistics Debate

  • Standard reports use U3 unemployment (middle of 6 measurements)
  • U6 includes discouraged workers and involuntary part-time workers
  • Critics argue U6 provides more accurate unemployment picture

Huffington Post Real Misery Index (2009)

  • Used U6 unemployment statistics
  • Added inflation rates for essentials: food, drink, fuel, healthcare
  • Included credit card delinquency, housing costs, food stamp usage, home equity loan delinquencies
  • 2008 comparison: Okun index 8.1 vs HuffPo index 29.9
  • Discontinued after ~5 years

Academic Research on Weighting

  • 2001 paper using 23 years of life satisfaction surveys
  • Found unemployment causes 1.7x more misery than inflation
  • Suggests multiplying unemployment by 1.7 before adding to inflation for accurate weighting
  • Based on single question life satisfaction surveys across multiple countries

Modern Economics and Neoliberalism Discussion

  • Both hosts express interest in exploring neoliberalism's influence
  • Observation that Republican/Democrat policies increasingly similar
  • Neoliberalism as unifying framework affecting all political levels

Listener Feedback on Misophonia

  • Letter from Texas listener with misophonia (neurological disorder)
  • Extreme emotional response to specific sounds (high-pitched 's' sounds)
  • Causes instant headaches, affects family relationships and learning
  • Documentary recommendation: "Quiet Please"
  • Hosts plan future episode on misophonia

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome