AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: What's the misery index? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
44m 23s
Introduction and Personal Updates
- Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant hosting Stuff You Should Know podcast
- Chuck's middle name discussion: Charles W (Wayne) Bryant, not named after Wayne Gretzky
- Chuck picking up 4 new Last Chance garage hats from Inman Park shop
- Thanks to Katie (custom patch maker) at tulip cake.com (c-u-l-i-p cake)
- Thanks to Lamud hats (l-a-m-o-o-d) for big heads/oversized hats
- Overdue thanks to Matt Street at fatbison.com for wood carved sign used in TV show
Economics as "New Astrology"
- Article by Alan J. Levinovitz on aeon.co comparing economics to ancient Chinese astrology
- Economics valid for understanding past, flawed for future forecasting
- Problem: economists act like they have definitive answers despite liberal vs conservative economics disagreement
Arthur Okun and Origins of Misery Index
- Arthur Okun worked on Kennedy's Council of Economic Advisors (1961)
- US in recession when Kennedy took office
- Okun convinced Kennedy to simultaneously increase government spending AND cut taxes (unusual approach)
- Strategy successful, US entered economic boom
- Okun became head of Council of Economic Advisors under Johnson
Okun's Law Discovery
- Analyzed data from 1948-1960 (when unemployment recording began)
- Found: GNP rises 3% for every 1% unemployment falls
- Caveat: only applies when unemployment between 3-7.5%
- Became verified economic principle called "Okun's Law"
1970s Economic Crisis and Stagflation
- 1973 Arab Oil Embargo following Egypt/Syria invasion of Golan Heights/Sinai Peninsula
- US found supplying arms to Israel, Arab states shut off oil to US
- Oil prices rose 37%, gas rationing implemented
- Led to unprecedented stagflation: high inflation + high unemployment simultaneously
- Previously economists assumed these were mutually exclusive
- Economic disruption lasted entire decade
Creation of Misery Index (1973)
- Okun created simple formula: yearly inflation rate + unemployment rate
- Example: 5% inflation + 2% unemployment = 7% misery index
- Designed to measure average American's daily economic experience
- Could analyze historical data back to 1948 (limited by unemployment data availability)
Presidential Elections and Misery Index Correlation
- 1956: Misery index 6.53, Eisenhower reelected
- 1968: Index 8.13, Johnson/Humphrey lost to Nixon
- Nixon's first term: Index rose to 11.67, still got reelected
- 1974: All-time high 17.01 during Watergate
- Theory: Watergate might not have been fatal if misery index was lower
Carter and Reagan Era
- Ford briefly lowered index to 12.66, insufficient to prevent Carter victory
- Carter campaigned citing misery index
- Under Carter: Index reached all-time high 21.98
- Reagan used Carter's misery index against him in campaign
- Reagan lowered index to 9.55 by end of term
Presidential Performance Through Misery Index
- Bush Sr.: Index increased slightly
- Clinton: Brought down to 7.35
- Bush Jr.: Rose from 7.35 to 11.4
- Obama: Decreased to 7.87
- 2000 election considered rare instance where misery index didn't predict outcome
- 2008 financial crisis exposed flaws: low misery index despite stock market crash and rising unemployment
Enhanced Misery Index Versions
Robert Barro's 1996 Improvements
- Book: "Getting It Right: Markets and Choices in a Free Society"
- Added 4 measurements to original formula:
- Inflation rate during last year of presidency vs average over successor's term
- Same comparison for unemployment
- Changes in 30-year government bond yield
- Difference in long-term GDP growth rates
- Results: Clinton and Reagan performed best under Barro misery index
Steve Hanke's 2006 Global Version
- Added interest rates, subtracted annual GDP percentages
- Adapted for international use, including countries with price controls
- Used black market exchange rates to determine real inflation
- 2014 results: Venezuela most miserable (79.4), Japan least miserable (5.41), US ranked 19th with 11 rating
Alternative Measurements and Criticisms
Unemployment Statistics Debate
- Standard reports use U3 unemployment (middle of 6 measurements)
- U6 includes discouraged workers and involuntary part-time workers
- Critics argue U6 provides more accurate unemployment picture
Huffington Post Real Misery Index (2009)
- Used U6 unemployment statistics
- Added inflation rates for essentials: food, drink, fuel, healthcare
- Included credit card delinquency, housing costs, food stamp usage, home equity loan delinquencies
- 2008 comparison: Okun index 8.1 vs HuffPo index 29.9
- Discontinued after ~5 years
Academic Research on Weighting
- 2001 paper using 23 years of life satisfaction surveys
- Found unemployment causes 1.7x more misery than inflation
- Suggests multiplying unemployment by 1.7 before adding to inflation for accurate weighting
- Based on single question life satisfaction surveys across multiple countries
Modern Economics and Neoliberalism Discussion
- Both hosts express interest in exploring neoliberalism's influence
- Observation that Republican/Democrat policies increasingly similar
- Neoliberalism as unifying framework affecting all political levels
Listener Feedback on Misophonia
- Letter from Texas listener with misophonia (neurological disorder)
- Extreme emotional response to specific sounds (high-pitched 's' sounds)
- Causes instant headaches, affects family relationships and learning
- Documentary recommendation: "Quiet Please"
- Hosts plan future episode on misophonia
