AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: Who Committed the 1912 Villisca Ax Murders? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

46m 21s

Introduction and Setup

  • Josh introduces 2017 episode on Villisca ax murders as "most unsettling murders in American True Crime history"
  • Hosts Josh Clark, Chuck Bryant, Jerry discuss third ax murder episode after Lizzie Borden
  • Wikipedia lists 30 ax murders, article mentions 10 alone
  • Called Villisca Town Hall to confirm pronunciation
  • Villisca, Iowa entirely known for this murder - villisca-iowa.com dedicated to case

The Crime - June 9-10, 1912

  • Location: 508 East 2nd Street, Villisca, Iowa (Montgomery County)
  • Victims: 8 people total
    • Moore family: Joe and Sarah Moore (parents), children Herman, Katherine, Boyd, Paul
    • Sleepover guests: Lena and Aina Stillinger sisters (friends of Katherine)
  • All attended Presbyterian Children's Day Mass that Sunday
  • Home by 10-10:30 PM, lights out, house settled

Murder Details

  • Killer entered through unlocked back door after midnight
  • Used Joe Moore's own ax from property (weapon of convenience - every house had axes in 1912)
  • Prepared oil lamp: removed chimney, bent wick in half for low light
  • Methodical killing pattern:
    • Started upstairs with Joe and Sarah Moore
    • Used blunt end of ax, struck so hard gouged ceiling
    • Killed parents in sleep positions without waking them
    • Proceeded to children's room, killed all without waking others
    • Lena Stillinger (older) may have awakened when reached downstairs
  • Post-mortem mutilation: flipped ax, used sharp end to bash all faces/heads
    • Joe Moore struck 30 times in head
    • All victims' faces completely caved in

Killer's Behavior After Murders

  • Covered all windows with sheets
  • Covered all mirrors in house
  • Covered victims' faces with sheets/pillowcases
  • Pulled girls' dresses up over faces
  • Wrapped 2-pound slab of bacon in dish towel, left on bedroom floor
  • Bowl of bloody water found - washed self and ax
  • Remained in house until before 5 AM (murders around midnight)

Discovery and Crime Scene Contamination

  • 5 AM: Neighbor Mary Peckham noticed no activity (unusual for farm family)
  • 7 AM: Called Joe Moore's store, employee confirmed no-show
  • Ross Moore (Joe's brother) called, unlocked front door, discovered bodies
  • Marshal Hank Horton called to scene
  • First responders: Doctors Jay Clark Cooper, Edgar Huff, Minister Wesley Ewing
  • 100+ townspeople tramped through house
  • Town drunk took skull fragments as mementos
  • Local druggist tried to photograph scene for preservation, was thrown out
  • Crime scene completely compromised
  • 30 trains daily through Villisca - killer likely escaped by train

Suspect #1: Frank F. Jones

  • State senator, prominent Methodist businessman
  • Motive: Joe Moore worked for him 7 years, left 1907 over 16-hour/6-day work schedule
  • Moore started rival business, took John Deere contract
  • Moore had affair with Jones's daughter-in-law (widely known via party line operator)
  • Jones and Moore crossed street to avoid each other
  • Town divided: Methodists defended Jones, Presbyterians suspected him
  • Detective James Wilkerson (Burns Detective Agency) suspected Jones hired killer
  • Suspected hitman: William "Blackie" Mansfield
  • Mansfield had airtight alibi - in Illinois, payroll records confirmed
  • Later convicted of ax murder of own family (1914-15)
  • Wilkerson's campaign ruined Jones's political career, cost re-election

Suspect #2: Lynn George Jacqueline Kelly (George Kelly)

  • English traveling preacher, 5'2" 119 pounds
  • "Known sexual deviant" with mental health issues
  • Present at Children's Day service with wife
  • Left town morning after murders on train
  • Witness claimed he referenced murders before discovery (later recanted)
  • Left-handed (coroner determined left-handed assailant from blood spatter)
  • Placed lewd ad in Omaha World Herald for nude stenographer
  • Letter "so obscene, lewd, lascivious and filthy" court wouldn't record it
  • Returned week later posing as Scotland Yard detective for house tour
  • Signed confession: "I killed children upstairs first...God wanted me to do it"
  • Later recanted confession
  • Only person to go to trial (twice)
  • First trial: 11-1 jury in his favor
  • Second trial: complete acquittal
  • Evidence too flimsy

Serial Killer Theory

  • 1911-1912: at least 10 ax murders in Midwest
  • Ed Epperly (55-year expert) narrowed to 5 connected cases:
    • Colorado Springs, Colorado (1911)
    • Monmouth, Illinois (1911)
    • Ellsworth, Kansas (1911)
    • Paola, Kansas (1912)
    • Villisca, Iowa (1912)

Common Elements Across Cases

  • Oil lamps with chimneys removed, wicks bent in half
  • Axes used (4 of 5 cases) - weapons of convenience
  • Mirrors and windows covered
  • Telephone covered (looked like face)
  • Female victims found with nightgowns raised, undergarments removed
  • Killer attempted second murders in same towns
  • All train towns - linked by rail network

Henry Lee Moore Red Herring

  • Killed mother Georgia Moore and Mary Wilson in Columbia, Missouri (December 1912)
  • Murders started after his prison release, ended after his capture
  • Motive: wanted family house deeds (greed, not serial killing)
  • Not the serial killer despite timeline coincidence

Specific Serial Killer Evidence

  • Colorado Springs: killed adjacent family same night
  • Villisca: telephone operator heard doorknob tried 2 hours after Moore murders
  • Paola: Mrs. Longmire and daughter awakened by broken glass, saw man in dining room with broken oil lamp chimney, escaped through window

Modern Assessment

  • 1912 forensics inadequate - would be solved today
  • Gloves confounded only detection method (eyewitness testimony)
  • Train-hopping serial killer theory most credible
  • Never caught, identity unknown
  • Case remains unsolved over 100 years later

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome