AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: Who Committed the 1912 Villisca Ax Murders? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
46m 21s
Introduction and Setup
- Josh introduces 2017 episode on Villisca ax murders as "most unsettling murders in American True Crime history"
- Hosts Josh Clark, Chuck Bryant, Jerry discuss third ax murder episode after Lizzie Borden
- Wikipedia lists 30 ax murders, article mentions 10 alone
- Called Villisca Town Hall to confirm pronunciation
- Villisca, Iowa entirely known for this murder - villisca-iowa.com dedicated to case
The Crime - June 9-10, 1912
- Location: 508 East 2nd Street, Villisca, Iowa (Montgomery County)
- Victims: 8 people total
- Moore family: Joe and Sarah Moore (parents), children Herman, Katherine, Boyd, Paul
- Sleepover guests: Lena and Aina Stillinger sisters (friends of Katherine)
- All attended Presbyterian Children's Day Mass that Sunday
- Home by 10-10:30 PM, lights out, house settled
Murder Details
- Killer entered through unlocked back door after midnight
- Used Joe Moore's own ax from property (weapon of convenience - every house had axes in 1912)
- Prepared oil lamp: removed chimney, bent wick in half for low light
- Methodical killing pattern:
- Started upstairs with Joe and Sarah Moore
- Used blunt end of ax, struck so hard gouged ceiling
- Killed parents in sleep positions without waking them
- Proceeded to children's room, killed all without waking others
- Lena Stillinger (older) may have awakened when reached downstairs
- Post-mortem mutilation: flipped ax, used sharp end to bash all faces/heads
- Joe Moore struck 30 times in head
- All victims' faces completely caved in
Killer's Behavior After Murders
- Covered all windows with sheets
- Covered all mirrors in house
- Covered victims' faces with sheets/pillowcases
- Pulled girls' dresses up over faces
- Wrapped 2-pound slab of bacon in dish towel, left on bedroom floor
- Bowl of bloody water found - washed self and ax
- Remained in house until before 5 AM (murders around midnight)
Discovery and Crime Scene Contamination
- 5 AM: Neighbor Mary Peckham noticed no activity (unusual for farm family)
- 7 AM: Called Joe Moore's store, employee confirmed no-show
- Ross Moore (Joe's brother) called, unlocked front door, discovered bodies
- Marshal Hank Horton called to scene
- First responders: Doctors Jay Clark Cooper, Edgar Huff, Minister Wesley Ewing
- 100+ townspeople tramped through house
- Town drunk took skull fragments as mementos
- Local druggist tried to photograph scene for preservation, was thrown out
- Crime scene completely compromised
- 30 trains daily through Villisca - killer likely escaped by train
Suspect #1: Frank F. Jones
- State senator, prominent Methodist businessman
- Motive: Joe Moore worked for him 7 years, left 1907 over 16-hour/6-day work schedule
- Moore started rival business, took John Deere contract
- Moore had affair with Jones's daughter-in-law (widely known via party line operator)
- Jones and Moore crossed street to avoid each other
- Town divided: Methodists defended Jones, Presbyterians suspected him
- Detective James Wilkerson (Burns Detective Agency) suspected Jones hired killer
- Suspected hitman: William "Blackie" Mansfield
- Mansfield had airtight alibi - in Illinois, payroll records confirmed
- Later convicted of ax murder of own family (1914-15)
- Wilkerson's campaign ruined Jones's political career, cost re-election
Suspect #2: Lynn George Jacqueline Kelly (George Kelly)
- English traveling preacher, 5'2" 119 pounds
- "Known sexual deviant" with mental health issues
- Present at Children's Day service with wife
- Left town morning after murders on train
- Witness claimed he referenced murders before discovery (later recanted)
- Left-handed (coroner determined left-handed assailant from blood spatter)
- Placed lewd ad in Omaha World Herald for nude stenographer
- Letter "so obscene, lewd, lascivious and filthy" court wouldn't record it
- Returned week later posing as Scotland Yard detective for house tour
- Signed confession: "I killed children upstairs first...God wanted me to do it"
- Later recanted confession
- Only person to go to trial (twice)
- First trial: 11-1 jury in his favor
- Second trial: complete acquittal
- Evidence too flimsy
Serial Killer Theory
- 1911-1912: at least 10 ax murders in Midwest
- Ed Epperly (55-year expert) narrowed to 5 connected cases:
- Colorado Springs, Colorado (1911)
- Monmouth, Illinois (1911)
- Ellsworth, Kansas (1911)
- Paola, Kansas (1912)
- Villisca, Iowa (1912)
Common Elements Across Cases
- Oil lamps with chimneys removed, wicks bent in half
- Axes used (4 of 5 cases) - weapons of convenience
- Mirrors and windows covered
- Telephone covered (looked like face)
- Female victims found with nightgowns raised, undergarments removed
- Killer attempted second murders in same towns
- All train towns - linked by rail network
Henry Lee Moore Red Herring
- Killed mother Georgia Moore and Mary Wilson in Columbia, Missouri (December 1912)
- Murders started after his prison release, ended after his capture
- Motive: wanted family house deeds (greed, not serial killing)
- Not the serial killer despite timeline coincidence
Specific Serial Killer Evidence
- Colorado Springs: killed adjacent family same night
- Villisca: telephone operator heard doorknob tried 2 hours after Moore murders
- Paola: Mrs. Longmire and daughter awakened by broken glass, saw man in dining room with broken oil lamp chimney, escaped through window
Modern Assessment
- 1912 forensics inadequate - would be solved today
- Gloves confounded only detection method (eyewitness testimony)
- Train-hopping serial killer theory most credible
- Never caught, identity unknown
- Case remains unsolved over 100 years later
