AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: Who was America's first murderer? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
29m 48s
Introduction and Episode Context
- Josh introduces SYSK Selects episode featuring "America's First Murderer" from 2011
- Classic episode combining history and true crime
- Recorded 10 years prior, acknowledges outdated language/perspectives
- Episode 398 discussion and Schoolhouse Rock references
Plymouth Colony Background
- Pilgrims were Puritans/separatists - extremely pious people who left Europe
- Sailed to Massachusetts, landed in Plymouth
- Two groups on Mayflower: Puritans and "The Strangers"
- Strangers: Catholics, sailors, Africans, various non-Puritans
- Puritans were rigid, didn't like Catholics
Historical Records and Bias
- Primary source: Mort's Relation (1622) by William Bradford
- Written by Plymouth governor to attract funding/investors
- Functioned as lengthy brochure, not objective history
- Painted colony in positive light, downplayed problems
- Bradford's "Of Plymouth Plantation" - his personal journal
- Small group controlled information flow from colony
- Many crimes/issues glossed over or unreported
The Billington Family
- John Billington, wife Eleanor, sons Little John (John Jr.) and Francis
- Described by Bradford as "one of the profanest families"
- Called John a "knave" (scoundrel) who "rails against authority"
- Family consistently caused problems for Puritan leadership
Early Incidents
- Mutiny involvement by John Billington on Mayflower voyage
- Son (Francis or John Jr.) fired musket in cabin near half-filled gunpowder keg
- Nearly destroyed entire Mayflower
- John Jr. wandered 20 miles, found by Native Americans
- Taken to village, decorated with beads
- Rescue expedition to Cape Cod required
- Massasoit (Wampanoag sachem) helped locate him
- Billington Sea (pond) named after John Jr.
Continued Troubles
- John Billington scoffed at Captain Miles Standish
- Refused military service
- 1624: Named co-conspirator in Oldham-Lyford conspiracy
- Secret meetings about overthrowing Puritan regime
- Denied involvement, let off with apology
- Threatened with hog-tying (brutal torture method)
- Ankles tied to neck, could cause death
- Eleanor Billington: locked in stocks, whipped, fined 5 pounds for slandering neighbors
- Granddaughter Dorcas: sentenced to whipping for sexual intercourse at age 22
Colony Crime Reality vs. Myth
- By 1690: only 755 people in Plymouth Colony
- Extensive criminal activity despite small population
- Bestiality cases (called "buggery"):
- Thomas Granger: indicted for bestiality with mare, cow, two goats, sheep, two calves, turkey - sentenced to hang
- John Walker: "laid with" female dog
- Multiple other bestiality cases with whipping/stocks punishment
- Sodomy cases: John Alexander and Thomas Roberts (1637) - received "hot irons" punishment
- Rape incidents occurred but underreported
- Crimes recorded but never promoted in official accounts
The Murder of John Newcomen
- Occurred ~10 years after Mayflower landing
- Billington as original settler had land parcel from Mayflower Compact
- Victim: John Newcomen, 17-year-old newcomer to Plymouth
- Conflict over hunting rights and property
- Newcomen repeatedly stole from Billington's traps, poached on his land
- Newcomen was a "saint" (Puritan in good standing with Bradford)
- Saints had more rights than "strangers" like Billington
The Shooting
- Billington caught Newcomen stealing again
- Chased him with blunderbuss (short, flared musket like sawed-off shotgun)
- Newcomen hid behind tree
- Billington shot at tree, hit Newcomen in shoulder
- Non-lethal wound but Newcomen died within 3 days from infection
- Bradford's account: described as "waylaying" (premeditated murder)
- Stranger accounts: portrayed as property defense against repeat offender
Trial and Execution
- Governor Bradford sentenced Billington to death by hanging
- Same Bradford who had disliked Billington for years
- Bradford wrote both the sentence and the historical record
- Billington believed he would be spared due to colony's need for people
- Thomas Morton's "New English Canaan" described Billington as "beloved by many"
- Strangers generally supported Billington as fellow outsider
Historical Perspective
- Bradford controlled both justice and historical narrative
- Painted himself and Puritans favorably, Billington poorly
- First murder may have been more complex than official record suggests
- Demonstrates importance of questioning historical sources
- Multiple perspectives reveal bias in primary accounts
