AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: Who was America's first murderer? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

29m 48s

Introduction and Episode Context

  • Josh introduces SYSK Selects episode featuring "America's First Murderer" from 2011
  • Classic episode combining history and true crime
  • Recorded 10 years prior, acknowledges outdated language/perspectives
  • Episode 398 discussion and Schoolhouse Rock references

Plymouth Colony Background

  • Pilgrims were Puritans/separatists - extremely pious people who left Europe
  • Sailed to Massachusetts, landed in Plymouth
  • Two groups on Mayflower: Puritans and "The Strangers"
    • Strangers: Catholics, sailors, Africans, various non-Puritans
    • Puritans were rigid, didn't like Catholics

Historical Records and Bias

  • Primary source: Mort's Relation (1622) by William Bradford
    • Written by Plymouth governor to attract funding/investors
    • Functioned as lengthy brochure, not objective history
    • Painted colony in positive light, downplayed problems
  • Bradford's "Of Plymouth Plantation" - his personal journal
  • Small group controlled information flow from colony
  • Many crimes/issues glossed over or unreported

The Billington Family

  • John Billington, wife Eleanor, sons Little John (John Jr.) and Francis
  • Described by Bradford as "one of the profanest families"
  • Called John a "knave" (scoundrel) who "rails against authority"
  • Family consistently caused problems for Puritan leadership

Early Incidents

  • Mutiny involvement by John Billington on Mayflower voyage
  • Son (Francis or John Jr.) fired musket in cabin near half-filled gunpowder keg
    • Nearly destroyed entire Mayflower
  • John Jr. wandered 20 miles, found by Native Americans
    • Taken to village, decorated with beads
    • Rescue expedition to Cape Cod required
    • Massasoit (Wampanoag sachem) helped locate him
    • Billington Sea (pond) named after John Jr.

Continued Troubles

  • John Billington scoffed at Captain Miles Standish
  • Refused military service
  • 1624: Named co-conspirator in Oldham-Lyford conspiracy
    • Secret meetings about overthrowing Puritan regime
    • Denied involvement, let off with apology
  • Threatened with hog-tying (brutal torture method)
    • Ankles tied to neck, could cause death
  • Eleanor Billington: locked in stocks, whipped, fined 5 pounds for slandering neighbors
  • Granddaughter Dorcas: sentenced to whipping for sexual intercourse at age 22

Colony Crime Reality vs. Myth

  • By 1690: only 755 people in Plymouth Colony
  • Extensive criminal activity despite small population
  • Bestiality cases (called "buggery"):
    • Thomas Granger: indicted for bestiality with mare, cow, two goats, sheep, two calves, turkey - sentenced to hang
    • John Walker: "laid with" female dog
    • Multiple other bestiality cases with whipping/stocks punishment
  • Sodomy cases: John Alexander and Thomas Roberts (1637) - received "hot irons" punishment
  • Rape incidents occurred but underreported
  • Crimes recorded but never promoted in official accounts

The Murder of John Newcomen

  • Occurred ~10 years after Mayflower landing
  • Billington as original settler had land parcel from Mayflower Compact
  • Victim: John Newcomen, 17-year-old newcomer to Plymouth
  • Conflict over hunting rights and property
  • Newcomen repeatedly stole from Billington's traps, poached on his land
  • Newcomen was a "saint" (Puritan in good standing with Bradford)
  • Saints had more rights than "strangers" like Billington

The Shooting

  • Billington caught Newcomen stealing again
  • Chased him with blunderbuss (short, flared musket like sawed-off shotgun)
  • Newcomen hid behind tree
  • Billington shot at tree, hit Newcomen in shoulder
  • Non-lethal wound but Newcomen died within 3 days from infection
  • Bradford's account: described as "waylaying" (premeditated murder)
  • Stranger accounts: portrayed as property defense against repeat offender

Trial and Execution

  • Governor Bradford sentenced Billington to death by hanging
  • Same Bradford who had disliked Billington for years
  • Bradford wrote both the sentence and the historical record
  • Billington believed he would be spared due to colony's need for people
  • Thomas Morton's "New English Canaan" described Billington as "beloved by many"
  • Strangers generally supported Billington as fellow outsider

Historical Perspective

  • Bradford controlled both justice and historical narrative
  • Painted himself and Puritans favorably, Billington poorly
  • First murder may have been more complex than official record suggests
  • Demonstrates importance of questioning historical sources
  • Multiple perspectives reveal bias in primary accounts

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome