AI summary by TwinMind
Seven - No, Wait, Five - Mysteries of the Art World | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
46m 43s
Introduction and Format Discussion
- Josh Clark and Chuck Bryan hosting "Stuff You Should Know" Art World Edition
- Recording episodes in pairs - just finished pogs episode
- Discussing old top-ten list format from HowStuffWorks website
- Original article had 7 entries, hosts deciding how many to cover
- Playing format "fast and loose" like old episodes
Caravaggio Mystery (#1)
- Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio - Italian Baroque painter, early 1600s
- Considered father of Modern Art, master of chiaroscuro (light/shadow technique)
- Personal background: gambler, swordsman, murderer, weapons charges
- 1606: Killed Ranuccio Tomassoni over woman named Fillide (who modeled for "Judith Beheading Holofernes")
- Fled Rome to Malta, briefly joined Knights of Malta (~1 month)
- Painted "The Beheading of John the Baptist" (12x17 feet oil on canvas)
- Altarpiece for Order of Saint John as entry fee instead of money
- Mystery: Signed painting in pool of blood - only work he ever signed
- Signature: "F. Michelang" - theories about "F":
- "Frater" (brother) - showing holy status for papal pardon
- "Fecit" (Latin for "did it") - confession to murder
- Art historians favor "Frater" theory - seeking papal pardon to return to Rome
- Kicked out of Knights as "foul and rotten member" after 1 month
- Died from infected wounds, lead poisoning from paints, sun exposure on Tuscan beach
- Painting still hangs at St. John's Co-Cathedral in Malta
Vermeer Mystery (#2)
- Johannes Vermeer - Dutch artist from Delft, never left hometown
- Had wife and 15 children, painted ~36 attributed works
- Theory: Oldest daughter Maria painted ~1/5 of attributed works (lower quality pieces)
- Unique style: Captured mundane daily moments with masterful light technique
- "Girl with a Pearl Earring" (~1665) - multiple names over centuries
- Mystery: Identity of subject
- Theories: Mistress, daughter Maria (age 15-16), or no real person
- Art historians believe it's "troni" - imaginary figure showing off costume/jewelry
- Historical fiction: 1999 Tracy Chevalier novel, 2003 Scarlett Johansson film
- Painting characteristics: Eyes follow viewer, mouth open (unusual for Dutch painting)
- Pearl earring: Improbably large, created with just two brushstrokes reflecting light
- Called "Mona Lisa of the North" but positioned in foreground vs. background
- National Gallery 1995 exhibit poster brought widespread fame
- Tim's Vermeer documentary - theory about projection techniques
Missing Raphael (#3)
- "Portrait of a Young Man" - believed Raphael self-portrait
- Most famous missing art from WWII Nazi plundering
- Originally hung in Princess Czartoryski Museum, Poland
- Stolen with Leonardo's "Lady with an Ermine" and Rembrandt's "Landscape with the Good Samaritan"
- Paintings hidden by Prince when Poland invaded, found by Gestapo
- Went to Hans Frank (Nazi governor of Poland) office
- 1945: Allies arrested Frank, recovered 2 paintings but not Raphael
- Frank executed 1946, couldn't be questioned long
- Mystery: Current location unknown
- Theories: Private collector, destroyed by Nazis
- Only black and white photographs exist - colors unknown
- Oil on panel (couldn't be rolled up)
- 2012 false report about bank vault discovery
- National Museum Krakow bought collection rights 2016 (100 million euros)
- Empty frame hangs in gallery
- Simpsons reference: Featured in "Raging Abe Simpson" episode
Van Gogh Death Mystery (#4)
- Vincent van Gogh died 1890, age 37, sold only one painting in lifetime
- Cut off ear after argument with Paul Gauguin (not to impress sex worker)
- Suffered depression, possibly bipolar disorder
- Official story: Shot himself in chest with revolver
- Alternative theory: 2011 book "Van Gogh: The Life" by Steven Naifeh & Gregory White Smith
- Evidence against suicide:
- Gun never found
- Walked back to room after shooting, lived 30 hours
- Bullet missed organs, deflected off rib cage
- Died of infection, not immediate wound
- Alternative theory: Accidentally shot by 16-year-old René Secrétan
- René had malfunctioning gun, liked playing cowboy after seeing Wild Bill Cody show
- Van Gogh's final words: "Do not accuse anyone, it was I who wanted to kill myself"
- Town protected wealthy Secrétan family vs. outsider Van Gogh
- 1950s: René admitted it was probably his gun
- Supporting evidence: Wrong angle for self-inflicted wound, recent upbeat paintings, anti-suicide writings
- Last words to brother: "The sadness will last forever"
Hitler Paintings Mystery (#5)
- Adolf Hitler rejected twice by Vienna Academy of Arts
- Father opposed artistic career, beat him over it
- After parents died, pursued art - rejection was "bolt from the blue"
- 1909 Vienna: Sold watercolor copies of postcards to tourists
- 1913 Munich: Painted cityscapes/landscapes for tourists
- 1914: Arrested for failing to register for military, failed physical (too weak)
- WWI: Enlisted when standards lowered
- As dictator: Had his artworks collected and destroyed
- 1936 critic: Style "prosaic, utterly devoid of rhythm, color, feeling, spiritual imagination"
- Mystery: Authentication of surviving works
- Problem: No distinctive style, copied postcards, no formal training
- Enormous market for fakes - anyone can forge generic watercolor streetscapes
- Recent sales: 2009 - $150K for 15 sketches; 2015 - $450K for 12-13 watercolors
- Artistic rejection possibly contributed to later psychopathy
- Early backer was Jewish man named Morgenstern
- Connection between failed artistic ambitions and political career
