AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: Brazilian Jars | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
15m 15s
Discovery of Ancient Jars in Brazilian Waters
- 1976: Jose Tashara diving in Guanabara Bay near Rio brought 2 ancient jars to surface
- Fishermen had been pulling similar jars in nets for years, assumed local native origin
- Brazilian Navy kept jars in seawater tank until examined by archaeologist
Robert Marx Investigation
- Robert Marx: underwater archaeologist, "father of underwater archaeology"
- Examined jars, identified as Roman amphora (not local Brazilian pottery)
- Found ~200 intact/broken amphora at 90 feet depth
- Concentrated in area size of 3 tennis courts
- Some buried 5 feet under mud, barnacle-encrusted with dead coral (killed 30-40 years prior)
- Marx convinced not a hoax due to burial depth and marine growth
Expert Analysis
- Elizabeth Will (UMass): expert in ancient Roman amphora
- Traced design to Kouass (present-day Morocco)
- Dated to 3rd Century CE (~1200-1300 years before Cabral's 1500 arrival)
- Specific manufacturing location and time period identified
Historical Implications
- Would rewrite history: Romans reached Brazil 1200+ years before Portuguese
- Similar to Viking settlement discovery in North America
- No prior legends/knowledge of Roman contact with Brazil
- Even fleeting contact would be historically significant
Brazilian Government Response
- Shut down Marx's excavation operation
- Banned him from Brazil
- Accused of stealing artifacts, selling at European auction houses
- Navy dumped fill dirt over site to prevent "plundering"
- Blanket ban on all marine archaeological excavations
The Twist - Hoax Revelation
- 1983: Americo Santarelli (free diver) claimed ownership
- Said jars were his replicas, planted in 1960s to age them
- Claimed only 16 amphora (not 200 as Marx reported)
- Santarelli had spent time in Rome, collected amphora as hobby
Evidence Analysis
- Most evidence came from Marx's testimony alone
- Marx's claims: 200 amphora, tennis court spread, barnacle encrustation
- After Santarelli's revelation, Marx dropped the investigation
- 1992: Marx wrote book on prehistoric Europe-Americas contact, didn't mention Brazilian jars
- Suggests Marx accepted the hoax explanation
Robert Marx Background
- Knighted in 3 countries
- Wrote UNESCO underwater archaeological laws
- Reputable archaeologist, not typical artifact plunderer
- Died 2019 with strong professional reputation
