AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: Feed A Cold, Starve a Fever | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
11m 9s
Historical Origins of the Saying
- Cleveland Clinic traced "starve a fever" back to 1574
- John Wiles dictionary: "fasting is a great remedy of fever"
- Earliest documented reference to fever portion
- Hippocrates connection (questionable relevance)
- "Most exquisitely slender diet" for sharp diseases
- Not specifically about colds/fevers
- 1853: First documentation of "feed/starve" regarding cold and fever
- Original interpretation was warning, not advice
- If you feed a cold → cold turns into fever → must starve fever
- Ambiguity due to comma placement in phrase
- Historical reasoning based on food temperature
- Fever: avoid hot food (only hot food available then)
- Cold: eat warm food to heat body up
Medical Community Opposition
- 1785 Gentleman's Magazine writer called advice "perhaps more destructive to mankind than the plague itself"
- Modern medical consensus: generally bad advice
- Cold feeding issues:
- Don't force eating when not hungry
- Natural appetite loss during illness is normal
- Fever starving problems (more harmful):
- Deliberately avoiding food robs body of needed nutrients/calories
- Fever increases metabolism significantly
- Body raising core temperature to "cook out" virus requires energy
Proper Illness Nutrition Guidelines
- Eat when hungry, regardless of cold or fever
- Appetite fluctuates during illness - take advantage when present
- Hydration absolutely critical (non-negotiable)
- Caloric liquids when solid food unappealing:
- Sports drinks with electrolytes
- Thin broths (chicken, vegetable)
- Nutrient-dense liquids
- Most developed world people have nutritional reserves for few days
- Fluid reserves much more limited - dehydration dangerous
- Historical remedies from 1785 Gentleman's Magazine:
- Barley water
- Small beer (low alcohol/session beer)
- Apple water
- Linseed tea
- Toast in water
- Water gruel sweetened with honey
2002 Dutch Research Study
- First scientific study testing feed/starve hypothesis
- Method: 24-hour fast for both groups, then different treatments
- Cold group: given meal replacement drink
- Fever group: continued fasting
- Results for Interferon Gamma (immune protein):
- Fed group: 450% average increase
- Fasted group: 83% decrease
- Interferon gamma regulates infection response
- Results for Interleukin 4 (different immune cell):
- Fasted group: 400% average increase
- One patient: over 1,000% increase
- Interleukin 4 activates innate immune response/cytokines
- Conclusion: Different immune responses activated by feeding vs fasting
- Can't predict which immune cells needed for specific illness
- Not advisable to "game the system" through strategic starving
- Want both types of immune responses active, ideally more of both
