AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: Pie-In-The-Face Gag | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
12m 41s
Origins in Vaudeville (Late 1800s)
- Started with Canadian performer Doc Kelly in late 1800s
- Kelly saw cook throw pie at stable boy, everyone laughed
- Kelly suggested hitting face instead of shirt would be funnier
- Became popular Vaudeville act, then moved to movies
Early Cinema Era (1909-1913)
- First disputed appearance: 1909 film "Mr. Flip" starring Ben Turpin (cross-eyed comedian)
- Film completely lost/destroyed, only written descriptions exist
- First documented appearance: 1913 "The Noise from the Deep"
- Starred Mabel Norman (known as "female Charlie Chaplin")
- Featured young Fatty Arbuckle
- Produced by Keystone Studios
Keystone Studios Era
- Keystone Studios became synonymous with pie-in-face gags
- Same studio that made Keystone Cops
- Needed own bakery to supply pies for all their movies
- Term "pieing" developed for the gag
Overuse and Decline (1913-1916)
- Became extremely popular, used in every film
- By 1916, Charlie Chaplin's "Behind the Screen" was already parodying the overused gag
- Went out of fashion due to overuse
Laurel and Hardy Revival (1927)
- 1927 "Battle of the Century" - Stan Laurel's ultimate pie fight
- Started with 4,500 pies from Los Angeles Pie Company
- Intended to end all pie-in-face bits by doing ultimate version
- Original version heavily edited in current copies
- Second reel/original version found in USC basement
Second Golden Age (Late 1920s-Early 1930s)
- Little Rascals used the gag
- Three Stooges incorporated it regularly
- Buster Keaton established unwritten rules for the bit
Technical Rules and Methods
- Target must deserve it (phonies, snooty high society people needing comeuppance)
- Person in tuxedo near pie = likely target
- Don't turn around too early or you'll flinch (ruins shot, requires reset/cleanup)
- Pie specifications:
- Baked to brittleness so it shatters on impact
- Double-layered crust for handling (no tin plates - dangerous)
- Darker filling for blonde hair, lighter for dark hair (black/white film contrast)
- Shaving cream preferred over real filling (doesn't spoil under hot studio lights)
Modern Era Challenges
- 1963/64 "The Great Race" attempted bigger pie fight than "Battle of the Century"
- Didn't deliver on promise
- Memorial Day weekend break caused spoiled pies, cast/crew gagging from smell
- Led to increased use of shaving cream instead of real filling
- Modern spoofs often use cheap whipped cream/shaving cream in pie tins
Expert Pie Throwers
- Fatty Arbuckle: could throw pies with both hands in opposite directions, hitting faces simultaneously
- Mo Howard (Three Stooges): so skilled he did off-camera throwing for other movies/shows
- Became hired specialist for pie throwing
Real-World Political Pieing
- Evolved from comedy to political protest
- Targets include powerful figures like Bill Gates, Rupert Murdoch
- Thomas Forsaid (High Times founder) credited as first to pie public figures
- Biotic Baking Brigade (San Francisco, 1980s-90s):
- Organized group promoting political pieing
- Published literature/pamphlets suggesting targets
- Recommended targets: Neo-Nazis, KKK members, homophobic preachers
- Modern security concerns make approach with projectiles extremely dangerous
Cultural Impact
- Remains funny but now more nostalgic nod to comedy history
- Core premise: taking powerful/pompous people down a peg
- Demonstrates they're not "gods among humans"
