AI summary by TwinMind

Short Stuff: Pie-In-The-Face Gag | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

12m 41s

Origins in Vaudeville (Late 1800s)

  • Started with Canadian performer Doc Kelly in late 1800s
  • Kelly saw cook throw pie at stable boy, everyone laughed
  • Kelly suggested hitting face instead of shirt would be funnier
  • Became popular Vaudeville act, then moved to movies

Early Cinema Era (1909-1913)

  • First disputed appearance: 1909 film "Mr. Flip" starring Ben Turpin (cross-eyed comedian)
    • Film completely lost/destroyed, only written descriptions exist
  • First documented appearance: 1913 "The Noise from the Deep"
    • Starred Mabel Norman (known as "female Charlie Chaplin")
    • Featured young Fatty Arbuckle
    • Produced by Keystone Studios

Keystone Studios Era

  • Keystone Studios became synonymous with pie-in-face gags
  • Same studio that made Keystone Cops
  • Needed own bakery to supply pies for all their movies
  • Term "pieing" developed for the gag

Overuse and Decline (1913-1916)

  • Became extremely popular, used in every film
  • By 1916, Charlie Chaplin's "Behind the Screen" was already parodying the overused gag
  • Went out of fashion due to overuse

Laurel and Hardy Revival (1927)

  • 1927 "Battle of the Century" - Stan Laurel's ultimate pie fight
  • Started with 4,500 pies from Los Angeles Pie Company
  • Intended to end all pie-in-face bits by doing ultimate version
  • Original version heavily edited in current copies
  • Second reel/original version found in USC basement

Second Golden Age (Late 1920s-Early 1930s)

  • Little Rascals used the gag
  • Three Stooges incorporated it regularly
  • Buster Keaton established unwritten rules for the bit

Technical Rules and Methods

  • Target must deserve it (phonies, snooty high society people needing comeuppance)
  • Person in tuxedo near pie = likely target
  • Don't turn around too early or you'll flinch (ruins shot, requires reset/cleanup)
  • Pie specifications:
    • Baked to brittleness so it shatters on impact
    • Double-layered crust for handling (no tin plates - dangerous)
    • Darker filling for blonde hair, lighter for dark hair (black/white film contrast)
    • Shaving cream preferred over real filling (doesn't spoil under hot studio lights)

Modern Era Challenges

  • 1963/64 "The Great Race" attempted bigger pie fight than "Battle of the Century"
  • Didn't deliver on promise
  • Memorial Day weekend break caused spoiled pies, cast/crew gagging from smell
  • Led to increased use of shaving cream instead of real filling
  • Modern spoofs often use cheap whipped cream/shaving cream in pie tins

Expert Pie Throwers

  • Fatty Arbuckle: could throw pies with both hands in opposite directions, hitting faces simultaneously
  • Mo Howard (Three Stooges): so skilled he did off-camera throwing for other movies/shows
  • Became hired specialist for pie throwing

Real-World Political Pieing

  • Evolved from comedy to political protest
  • Targets include powerful figures like Bill Gates, Rupert Murdoch
  • Thomas Forsaid (High Times founder) credited as first to pie public figures
  • Biotic Baking Brigade (San Francisco, 1980s-90s):
    • Organized group promoting political pieing
    • Published literature/pamphlets suggesting targets
    • Recommended targets: Neo-Nazis, KKK members, homophobic preachers
  • Modern security concerns make approach with projectiles extremely dangerous

Cultural Impact

  • Remains funny but now more nostalgic nod to comedy history
  • Core premise: taking powerful/pompous people down a peg
  • Demonstrates they're not "gods among humans"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome