AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: Skittles and TIO2 | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
11m 40s
Skittles Lawsuit Background
- July 2022: California man filed lawsuit against Mars Incorporated over Skittles containing titanium dioxide
- Class action lawsuit citing health risks from titanium dioxide additive
- First lawsuit dismissed November 2022 without prejudice (allows new lawsuit)
- Summer 2023: Another California woman filed new lawsuit, status unknown
- Mars promised in 2016 to phase out titanium dioxide from candies, specifically Skittles
- 2024: Skittles still contains titanium dioxide despite 8-year-old promise
Titanium Dioxide Basics
- Titanium: naturally occurring element in Earth's crust
- Titanium dioxide: white powder formed when titanium reacts with oxygen
- Used as whitening agent in processed foods
- Functions by reflecting light extremely well across all light types
- Also used in sunscreen, makeup, toothpaste as UV protectant
- Food producers not required to list as "titanium dioxide" - can list as generic ingredient
Nanoparticles and Health Concerns
- Food industry uses titanium dioxide nanoparticles specifically
- Particles approximately 100 nanometers across
- Human hair: 880,000 nanometers across for comparison
- Smaller particles more effective at scattering light
- Concern: tiny size allows particles to travel throughout body
- Potential accumulation in organs, especially liver and kidneys (filtering mechanisms)
- Can enter bloodstream and make it past digestive system
Scientific Evidence Status
- No peer-reviewed evidence proving nanoparticles migrate to/accumulate in liver/kidneys
- Titanium Dioxide Manufacturers Association: no evidence food-grade titanium dioxide harmful to human health
- Studies primarily animal-based, almost exclusively mouse studies
- Mouse studies show damage occurs
- Human studies show tissue inflammation when inhaled (not applicable to food consumption)
- Environmental Working Group: ingredient found in thousands of children's sweets
- Smaller bodies (children) potentially more impacted by accumulation
Regulatory and Industry Response
- FDA position: food-grade titanium dioxide safe if doesn't exceed 1% of food's weight
- 2015: Dunkin Donuts eliminated titanium dioxide from powdered sugar toppings
- EU banned titanium dioxide in food products
- Food-grade titanium dioxide (E171) limited to maximum 40% nanoparticles
- National Poison Control Center: only 0.1% of 1% passes through gut into body
Skittles-Specific Questions
- Purpose in Skittles unclear - not white candy
- Possibly used as flavor enhancer or color enhancer
- One source mentioned mustard flavor enhancement (no mustard Skittles exist)
- Also present in Starburst candy
- Consumer likely wouldn't notice removal
