AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: What's the oldest book? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
11m 54s
Introduction to Show and Topic
- Short Stuff podcast with Josh, Chuck, and Jerry (sitting in for producer Dave C)
- Topic: books, what constitutes a book, oldest book debate
Gold Orphism Book Discovery
- Located in National Museum of History, Bulgaria
- Claims to be world's oldest book
- Physical description:
- 6 pages of actual gold sheets (not gilded paper)
- Pages bound together
- Written in Etruscan language
- Contains illustrations: mermaid, harp, soldiers, horse rider
- Age: 2,500 years old
- Discovery details:
- Found along Stroma River, Southwestern Bulgaria
- Found in tomb
- Donated by anonymous person
- Authenticated by two anonymous scientists
- Etruscans: direct predecessors to Romans, heyday around 500 BCE, writing not yet deciphered
Book Definition Debate
- Central question: what constitutes a book?
- Physical attribute definitions:
- Certain shape
- Bound together (major criterion)
- Some say must be on paper (would discount gold orphism book)
- Content-based definitions:
- Must tell story
- Can be on any material
- Doesn't need binding
Lauren Ferry's Position (Cornell Curator)
- Curator of rare books and manuscripts at Cornell
- Interviewed for HowStuffWorks article 11 years ago
- Definition: book must have binding AND espouse worldview
- Cornell possesses world's largest collection of clay tablets
- Clay tablets mostly contain:
- Tax records
- Financial records
- Legal proceedings
- Don't espouse worldview, therefore not books
- Suggested oldest books: Homer's Iliad or Epic of Gilgamesh
- Contradiction: Epic of Gilgamesh written on unbound clay tablets (7th Century BCE)
Religious Perspective Complications
- Christians might claim Bible as oldest book (young earth view)
- Biblical scholars note Bible written over hundreds of years
- Stories written centuries after events described
- Ferry introduces religious debate as complicating factor
Oral Tradition vs Written Works
- Many books based on oral traditions predating written versions
- Ferry argues oral tradition age irrelevant to book age
- Physical book creation date matters, not story origin date
Chuck's Book Definition
- Doesn't require binding
- Scrolls qualify if complete story with beginning, middle, end
- References papyri 4,500 years old
- Jack Kerouac example: wrote on toilet paper roll over 48-72 hours
- Binding needed for commercial sale, not book definition
Printed Book Category
- Gutenberg Bible as first printed book (Western understanding)
- Chinese wood block printing predated movable type
- Handwritten manuscripts also qualify
- 4th Century biblical manuscripts mentioned
Final Consensus Attempt
- Chuck's refined definition:
- Can be handwritten
- Can be scroll format
- Cannot be oral story
- Doesn't require binding for book status
- Must be connected (pages/scroll continuous)
- Unconnected pages don't qualify as book
- Etruscan gold sheets older than gold orphism book but unbound wouldn't count
Show Conclusion
- Josh reveals joke about being Lauren Ferry
- References to Bob Uecker Miller beer commercials
- Nostalgic TV/radio references
