AI summary by TwinMind

Short Stuff: Women Pirates | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

16m 14s

Show Introduction and Context

  • Short Stuff podcast episode with Josh, Chuck, and Jerry
  • Discussion triggered by TV show "Our Flag Means Death" - known as most queer positive show on television
  • Show features female character masquerading as male pirate and same-sex relationships
  • Led to exploration of whether pirate ships were havens for gay women/trans people in historical context
  • Ships considered bad luck to have women aboard, so disguising as men was common practice

Historical Source Challenges

  • Primary source: "A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the Most Notorious Pirates" (also known as "General History of the Pirates")
  • Written by Captain Charles Johnson (pen name) - likely Daniel Defoe (Robinson Crusoe author) or publisher Nathaniel Mist
  • Book was hot seller but mixed fact with lore for entertainment value
  • Creates major conundrum for historians - difficult to differentiate truth from embellishment
  • Mark Mancini from HowStuffWorks.com noted for avoiding inaccuracies
  • Even reputable sources like Britannica contain fabrications added by novelists as late as 1960s
  • Italicized sections in original text often indicate fictional elements

Golden Age of Piracy Timeline

  • Period: Mid-17th century to first quarter of 18th century
  • Anne Bonnie and Mary Reed active during this era
  • Both considered among toughest, most ready-to-fight pirates on their ship
  • Openly known as women but still dressed as men
  • Reputation exceeded even their captain's fighting ability

Anne Bonnie Background

  • Born in Ireland near Cork
  • Illegitimate daughter of attorney (various names: William Cormack, James Cormack)
  • Father married but had affair with maidservant
  • Father dressed Anne as boy in childhood to deflect illegitimacy scandal
  • Scandal eventually broke, father lost legal practice
  • Family moved to Carolina (before North/South split), likely Charleston
  • Married pirate James Bonnie (source of surname)
  • Later partnered with Captain John "Calico Jack" Rackham
  • Documentary evidence confirms she worked as pirate with Rackham
  • Romantic relationship with Rackham appears proven

Mary Reed Background

  • Also had unusual early life leading to piracy
  • Described as more chaste than Anne Bonnie
  • Fell in love easily, married multiple times
  • Defended herself violently - beat nearly to death a man who tried to assault her
  • Known for fighting capability from early age

Disputed Stories and Legends

  • Story of both women aboard ship disguised as men
  • Anne supposedly developed crush on Mary (thinking she was male)
  • Both allegedly revealed true identities simultaneously in private room
  • This story likely fabricated (appears in italics in original text)
  • 1750s book suggested they were lovers - possibly male writer's imagination
  • Many romantic/sexual details appear to be later embellishments

Documented Piracy Activities

  • Both women confirmed pirates with Calico Jack Rackham
  • Worked on ships Rackham stole
  • Trial witnesses testified to their active participation
  • Known for cursing and spitting at men
  • One witness claimed men hid below decks while women fought above
  • Anne Bonnie shot into lower decks, killed crew member for cowardice
  • Crew size estimated 5-6 or possibly dozen total members
  • Actively engaged in "collecting booty" - genuine pirates, not captives

Capture and Legal Proceedings

  • September 1720: Named as pirates and enemies to British Crown
  • August 1720: Stole ship named "The William"
  • Active piracy run through fall 1720
  • Late October 1720: Entertaining mariners from Port Royal
  • Incident escalated to fight, drew attention
  • Captured by pirate hunter Jonathan Barnett
  • Had previously escaped other pirate hunters multiple times
  • Tried in Spanish Town, Jamaica
  • Multiple trials held for different crew members
  • Some French hunters were abducted/forced into piracy but still convicted
  • All male crew members found guilty and hanged

Trial Outcome and "Pleading the Belly"

  • Both women found guilty
  • Simultaneous pregnancy announcement in court ("pleading the belly")
  • Legal practice allowing pregnant women to avoid execution
  • Medical examination confirmed both pregnancies
  • Likely in second trimester according to later historians
  • Both avoided execution due to pregnancies

Final Fates

  • Mary Reed: Died April following trial, likely in childbirth
  • Grave located in Saint Catherine, Jamaica (visitable)
  • Anne Bonnie: Released at some point, fate unknown
  • Not executed, became obscure after release
  • Speculation: Returned to Charleston, married, had 8 children
  • Possible descendants living in Charleston area/Isle of Palms

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome