AI summary by TwinMind
Short Stuff: Women Pirates | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
16m 14s
Show Introduction and Context
- Short Stuff podcast episode with Josh, Chuck, and Jerry
- Discussion triggered by TV show "Our Flag Means Death" - known as most queer positive show on television
- Show features female character masquerading as male pirate and same-sex relationships
- Led to exploration of whether pirate ships were havens for gay women/trans people in historical context
- Ships considered bad luck to have women aboard, so disguising as men was common practice
Historical Source Challenges
- Primary source: "A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the Most Notorious Pirates" (also known as "General History of the Pirates")
- Written by Captain Charles Johnson (pen name) - likely Daniel Defoe (Robinson Crusoe author) or publisher Nathaniel Mist
- Book was hot seller but mixed fact with lore for entertainment value
- Creates major conundrum for historians - difficult to differentiate truth from embellishment
- Mark Mancini from HowStuffWorks.com noted for avoiding inaccuracies
- Even reputable sources like Britannica contain fabrications added by novelists as late as 1960s
- Italicized sections in original text often indicate fictional elements
Golden Age of Piracy Timeline
- Period: Mid-17th century to first quarter of 18th century
- Anne Bonnie and Mary Reed active during this era
- Both considered among toughest, most ready-to-fight pirates on their ship
- Openly known as women but still dressed as men
- Reputation exceeded even their captain's fighting ability
Anne Bonnie Background
- Born in Ireland near Cork
- Illegitimate daughter of attorney (various names: William Cormack, James Cormack)
- Father married but had affair with maidservant
- Father dressed Anne as boy in childhood to deflect illegitimacy scandal
- Scandal eventually broke, father lost legal practice
- Family moved to Carolina (before North/South split), likely Charleston
- Married pirate James Bonnie (source of surname)
- Later partnered with Captain John "Calico Jack" Rackham
- Documentary evidence confirms she worked as pirate with Rackham
- Romantic relationship with Rackham appears proven
Mary Reed Background
- Also had unusual early life leading to piracy
- Described as more chaste than Anne Bonnie
- Fell in love easily, married multiple times
- Defended herself violently - beat nearly to death a man who tried to assault her
- Known for fighting capability from early age
Disputed Stories and Legends
- Story of both women aboard ship disguised as men
- Anne supposedly developed crush on Mary (thinking she was male)
- Both allegedly revealed true identities simultaneously in private room
- This story likely fabricated (appears in italics in original text)
- 1750s book suggested they were lovers - possibly male writer's imagination
- Many romantic/sexual details appear to be later embellishments
Documented Piracy Activities
- Both women confirmed pirates with Calico Jack Rackham
- Worked on ships Rackham stole
- Trial witnesses testified to their active participation
- Known for cursing and spitting at men
- One witness claimed men hid below decks while women fought above
- Anne Bonnie shot into lower decks, killed crew member for cowardice
- Crew size estimated 5-6 or possibly dozen total members
- Actively engaged in "collecting booty" - genuine pirates, not captives
Capture and Legal Proceedings
- September 1720: Named as pirates and enemies to British Crown
- August 1720: Stole ship named "The William"
- Active piracy run through fall 1720
- Late October 1720: Entertaining mariners from Port Royal
- Incident escalated to fight, drew attention
- Captured by pirate hunter Jonathan Barnett
- Had previously escaped other pirate hunters multiple times
- Tried in Spanish Town, Jamaica
- Multiple trials held for different crew members
- Some French hunters were abducted/forced into piracy but still convicted
- All male crew members found guilty and hanged
Trial Outcome and "Pleading the Belly"
- Both women found guilty
- Simultaneous pregnancy announcement in court ("pleading the belly")
- Legal practice allowing pregnant women to avoid execution
- Medical examination confirmed both pregnancies
- Likely in second trimester according to later historians
- Both avoided execution due to pregnancies
Final Fates
- Mary Reed: Died April following trial, likely in childbirth
- Grave located in Saint Catherine, Jamaica (visitable)
- Anne Bonnie: Released at some point, fate unknown
- Not executed, became obscure after release
- Speculation: Returned to Charleston, married, had 8 children
- Possible descendants living in Charleston area/Isle of Palms
