AI summary by TwinMind
Should small towns still have volunteer EMS?
Vox
7m 48s
Historical Volunteer Firefighter Decline
- 1984: Nearly 900,000 volunteer firefighters in US
- 2020: Number dropped by more than 220,000 (to ~680,000)
- US population grew by 100 million during same period
- Almost 50% decline per capita in volunteer firefighters
- Crisis developing since 1960s-70s, not sudden
Current Emergency Services Structure
- Urban areas: Majority of EMS agencies staffed entirely by paid employees
- Rural areas: Complete opposite - rely heavily on volunteers
- 70% of rural EMS providers report difficulty recruiting volunteers
- Communities realized they got "free ride for first 30-40 years"
Aging Volunteer Demographics
- Emergency volunteers increasingly older in US
- Some volunteers started ambulance services in 1982, now 70-80 years old
- Towns under 2,500 people: 1 in 3 firefighters over 50
- 1987: Only 1 in 6 firefighters over 50
- Younger people not signing up at previous rates
Increased Training Requirements
- Past: Basic first aid and transport with minimal training
- Current EMT training: 150 hours required
- Firefighter training: 120 hours required
- Emergency responder (basic life-saving): 48 hours required
- EMT training equivalent to nearly 3 weeks full-time work (unpaid for volunteers)
- Training squeezed around full-time jobs and family life
Economic and Social Changes
- Dual income families increasingly common
- More expensive cost of living
- Literally no time left to volunteer
- Young Americans leaving rural areas for urbanized lifestyle
- Technology replacing in-person social interactions
- 2023: Young Americans spend 6 hours alone per day
- Social media/phones reduce need for physical gathering places
Rural Population Decline
- 2/3 of all rural counties lost population 2010-2020
- More people moved out than moved in
- Births diminished, deaths increased
- Big portion of loss is young people
- Fewer people available for volunteering overall
Community Solutions Being Tried
- Recognition programs in local newspapers
- Financial incentives:
- Stipends
- Tuition reimbursements
- Tax credits
- Free housing (Pennsylvania, Maryland)
Regionalization Strategy
- Small rural communities lack tax base per square mile for paid staff
- Neighboring towns pool resources, money, staffing, equipment
- Shared services across multiple towns
- Fewer stations but better coverage overall
Professional Model Transition
- Volunteer time valued at $34.79/hour
- 24/7 staffing needs make costs substantial
- Personnel and benefits highest cost in ambulance services
- Labor donated for four decades by volunteers
- Many experts believe answer is paying people, not recruiting more volunteers
- Randall Hannifan example: Lasted 6 months as volunteer before accepting paid position
Funding Challenges
- State and federal support needed
- Communities send money to federal/state systems, need "give back"
- Similar model needed as roads/schools funding
- Without paid workforce, small towns must rely on volunteers
- Question: What happens if volunteer assistance disappears?
