AI summary by TwinMind

Should Stephen Hawking Have Won the Nobel Prize?

Sabine Hossenfelder

11m 28s

Hawking's Nobel Prize Predictions

  • Hawking repeatedly joked about potentially winning Nobel Prize if Large Hadron Collider (LHC) produced tiny black holes
  • 2016 lecture quote: "Some collisions might create micro black holes... would radiate particles in pattern easy to recognize... so I might get Nobel Prize after all"
  • Philip Ball (British physicist/science writer) attended 2016 lecture, found comment unusually self-promoting/arrogant
  • Speaker had different reaction at Stockholm lecture year earlier - thought Hawking was explaining something few knew about and was correct
  • Assessment: If LHC had seen tiny black holes decay, Hawking almost certainly would have won Nobel Prize
  • However, this was unlikely to happen - more likely to win for something else

Hawking Radiation Discovery (1974)

  • 1974: Hawking published calculation showing black holes not perfectly black but emit thermal radiation
  • Temperature inversely proportional to mass of black hole
    • Larger black hole = smaller temperature = harder to measure radiation
  • For astrophysical black holes: temperature way too small to be measurable
  • Chances of Nobel Prize for black hole evaporation seemed very small

Tiny Black Holes at LHC Theory

  • Late 1990s: Idea emerged that tiny black holes might be produced in particle collisions at LHC
  • Only possible if universe has additional dimensions of space (not just 3 we know, but at least 5)
  • Extra dimensions would need to be curled up to small radii (otherwise we'd have seen them)
  • Connection to string theory: major motivation for considering extra dimensions hypothesis
  • Warning: String theory doesn't specify extra dimensions should have size LHC could probe - might be too small
  • If extra dimensions had right size: LHC could produce tiny black holes
  • Small black holes would be really hot, decay almost immediately (10^-23 seconds before reaching detector)
  • Hawking's calculation: decay would follow very specific pattern
    • Black holes can decay into any other particle
    • No other particle decay looks like this
    • Would be easy to recognize in data
  • Reality: They did not happen, but if they had, would almost certainly have gotten Hawking Nobel Prize

Why Tiny Black Holes Were Unlikely

  • Idea never very plausible - no reason extra dimensions should have just right size for production
  • Only reason physicists thought this possible: argument from mathematical beauty called "naturalness"
  • Assessment: Tiny black holes at LHC was not Hawking's best shot at Nobel Prize

Alternative Methods to Observe Black Hole Evaporation

  • Without curled up extra dimensions (which don't seem to exist): can't make black holes ourselves
  • Energy density required way beyond technological limitations
  • Natural black holes too large and cold to observe Hawking radiation

Superfluid Black Hole Simulations

  • Jeff Steinhauer's group in Israel: simulating black holes with superfluids
  • Superfluid mimics black hole horizon
    • Black hole horizon: boundary where light cannot escape
    • Superfluid: traps sound waves instead of light
  • Sound speed depends on fluid density (experimentally controllable)
  • Flowing fluid creates regions where sound waves cannot escape (too slow)
  • Analogy: Like swimming away from waterfall - boundary beyond which can't swim fast enough
  • Superfluid needed (vs normal fluid) for sound to have right quantum properties
  • Steinhauer's experiments: Sound waves have properties Hawking predicted
  • Hawking's calculation applies to superfluid same way as real black holes
  • Assessment: Unlikely to win Nobel Prize - quantum simulation demonstrates calculation correctness but cannot prove prediction correct for real black holes

Singularity Theorems Work

  • Before black hole evaporation: Hawking worked with Penrose on singularity theorems
  • Penrose's theorem: Black holes unavoidable consequence of stellar collapse (contrary to prevailing belief)
  • Before theorems: Physicists thought black holes were mathematical curiosities, not real
  • Singularity theorems led to black holes being taken seriously
  • Astronomers looked for them, now have solid experimental evidence
  • Hawking applied same method to early universe: Big Bang singularity likewise unavoidable unless general relativity breaks down
  • Amazing insight about universe origin
  • 2020: Penrose won Nobel Prize in Physics
  • Assessment: If Hawking hadn't died 2 years earlier, would have won Nobel Prize with Penrose
  • Alternative theory: Nobel committee waited for him to die to avoid disentangling Hawking's work from Penrose's

Nobel Prize Significance

  • Speaker's view: Nobel Prize primarily opportunity to celebrate scientific discoveries
  • Deserving candidates highly deserving with or without medal
  • Hawking didn't need Nobel Prize - will be remembered without it

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome