AI summary by TwinMind
Should Stephen Hawking Have Won the Nobel Prize?
Sabine Hossenfelder
11m 28s
Hawking's Nobel Prize Predictions
- Hawking repeatedly joked about potentially winning Nobel Prize if Large Hadron Collider (LHC) produced tiny black holes
- 2016 lecture quote: "Some collisions might create micro black holes... would radiate particles in pattern easy to recognize... so I might get Nobel Prize after all"
- Philip Ball (British physicist/science writer) attended 2016 lecture, found comment unusually self-promoting/arrogant
- Speaker had different reaction at Stockholm lecture year earlier - thought Hawking was explaining something few knew about and was correct
- Assessment: If LHC had seen tiny black holes decay, Hawking almost certainly would have won Nobel Prize
- However, this was unlikely to happen - more likely to win for something else
Hawking Radiation Discovery (1974)
- 1974: Hawking published calculation showing black holes not perfectly black but emit thermal radiation
- Temperature inversely proportional to mass of black hole
- Larger black hole = smaller temperature = harder to measure radiation
- For astrophysical black holes: temperature way too small to be measurable
- Chances of Nobel Prize for black hole evaporation seemed very small
Tiny Black Holes at LHC Theory
- Late 1990s: Idea emerged that tiny black holes might be produced in particle collisions at LHC
- Only possible if universe has additional dimensions of space (not just 3 we know, but at least 5)
- Extra dimensions would need to be curled up to small radii (otherwise we'd have seen them)
- Connection to string theory: major motivation for considering extra dimensions hypothesis
- Warning: String theory doesn't specify extra dimensions should have size LHC could probe - might be too small
- If extra dimensions had right size: LHC could produce tiny black holes
- Small black holes would be really hot, decay almost immediately (10^-23 seconds before reaching detector)
- Hawking's calculation: decay would follow very specific pattern
- Black holes can decay into any other particle
- No other particle decay looks like this
- Would be easy to recognize in data
- Reality: They did not happen, but if they had, would almost certainly have gotten Hawking Nobel Prize
Why Tiny Black Holes Were Unlikely
- Idea never very plausible - no reason extra dimensions should have just right size for production
- Only reason physicists thought this possible: argument from mathematical beauty called "naturalness"
- Assessment: Tiny black holes at LHC was not Hawking's best shot at Nobel Prize
Alternative Methods to Observe Black Hole Evaporation
- Without curled up extra dimensions (which don't seem to exist): can't make black holes ourselves
- Energy density required way beyond technological limitations
- Natural black holes too large and cold to observe Hawking radiation
Superfluid Black Hole Simulations
- Jeff Steinhauer's group in Israel: simulating black holes with superfluids
- Superfluid mimics black hole horizon
- Black hole horizon: boundary where light cannot escape
- Superfluid: traps sound waves instead of light
- Sound speed depends on fluid density (experimentally controllable)
- Flowing fluid creates regions where sound waves cannot escape (too slow)
- Analogy: Like swimming away from waterfall - boundary beyond which can't swim fast enough
- Superfluid needed (vs normal fluid) for sound to have right quantum properties
- Steinhauer's experiments: Sound waves have properties Hawking predicted
- Hawking's calculation applies to superfluid same way as real black holes
- Assessment: Unlikely to win Nobel Prize - quantum simulation demonstrates calculation correctness but cannot prove prediction correct for real black holes
Singularity Theorems Work
- Before black hole evaporation: Hawking worked with Penrose on singularity theorems
- Penrose's theorem: Black holes unavoidable consequence of stellar collapse (contrary to prevailing belief)
- Before theorems: Physicists thought black holes were mathematical curiosities, not real
- Singularity theorems led to black holes being taken seriously
- Astronomers looked for them, now have solid experimental evidence
- Hawking applied same method to early universe: Big Bang singularity likewise unavoidable unless general relativity breaks down
- Amazing insight about universe origin
- 2020: Penrose won Nobel Prize in Physics
- Assessment: If Hawking hadn't died 2 years earlier, would have won Nobel Prize with Penrose
- Alternative theory: Nobel committee waited for him to die to avoid disentangling Hawking's work from Penrose's
Nobel Prize Significance
- Speaker's view: Nobel Prize primarily opportunity to celebrate scientific discoveries
- Deserving candidates highly deserving with or without medal
- Hawking didn't need Nobel Prize - will be remembered without it
