AI summary by TwinMind

Should TSMC Have Built a Foundry on the Mainland? A Case Study

Asianometry

12m 9s

Historical Context & Political Background

  • 1999: China entered WTO, changed world economy forever
  • Exploding Chinese market attracted Taiwanese investors
  • Policy makers saw potential threat to Taiwan's semiconductor industry (crown jewel of high-tech sector)
  • 2000: Chen Shui-bian (DPP) ended 50 years of Kuomintang rule, became president
    • Previously illegal opposition party now in presidency
    • Divided government: Kuomintang dominated legislature
    • Clashed over almost everything
  • Chen's policies: pro-welfare, pro-environment
    • Expanded Taiwanese social welfare budget
    • Stopped construction of Taiwan's fourth nuclear plant
    • Continued Li Denghui's path of cultural/educational changes
    • Goal: remake Taiwanese society into own identity vs Chinese province
  • Business class uncomfortable with changes → continued capital flight across strait
  • Taiwan's economy struggled, unemployment rose to 5%

Investment Restrictions & Legal Framework

  • Until early 2000s: Taiwanese foundries limited to $50 million investments in mainland
  • 1991 rule by Lee Denghui: "Don't rush, be patient"
    • "Nice smile but sharp teeth"
    • Investors not reporting cross-strait investments faced fines/imprisonment
    • UMC president Robert Tsao prosecuted under this law
  • Central question: Should Taiwan allow semiconductor manufacturers to establish foundries on mainland?

New Chinese Competitors (2000)

  • Two new semiconductor foundries opened in China, sent shockwaves across Taiwan
  • Grace Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (Hongli)
    • Co-founders: Wang Wen-yang (son of Formosa Plastics founder) & Jiang Mianheng (son of Communist Party General Secretary Zhang Zemin)
    • Names alone shook foundations of Taiwanese semiconductor industry
  • Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC)
    • Founded by former TSMC vice president
    • First of many major cross-strait defections
  • Both companies used "near unlimited bank accounts" for massive employee poaching
    • Mainland firms offered 4-5x compensation packages vs Taiwanese firms
    • Employees brought entire teams + proprietary technology to China
    • Problem continues to this day

Cost Advantages & Market Factors

  • China's foundries had substantial cost benefits over Taiwan:
    • Construction costs in Shanghai: 35% cheaper than Taiwan
    • Water supply: 60% less cost
    • Bulk gas: 30% less cost
  • Market opportunity: TSMC & UMC wanted first-mover advantage in China
    • Major share serving local integrated chip designers
    • Chinese market brand new with "infinite possibilities"
  • Frank Huang (PowerChip CEO): "China market is growing, Taiwanese companies can't miss out... we have to be there"

Technology Transfer Concerns

  • Morris Chang (TSMC CEO/Chairman/Founder) argued most forcefully for market entry
  • China's requirement: manufacture wafers locally to enter market
  • "Market for technology" - had to give China something to get something
  • Historical precedent: Taiwan's own technology transfer experience
    • 1976: Taiwan called for help establishing domestic semiconductor market
    • RCA won bid (7 companies), trained 37 engineers for over a year
    • US allowed advanced technologies to flow to Taiwan for $10 million
    • Different political/economic times, friendly US-Taiwan relations helped
  • Now Taiwan faced same situation but on other side
  • Taiwanese foundries' argument: Could be responsible
    • Transfer older 8-inch wafer technology vs cutting-edge 12-inch
    • US technology export restrictions prevented transferring latest fabrication tech anyway
    • At time: 0.25 micron or smaller restricted
    • US restricting technology transfers to China since 2003 (not new)

Employment & Labor Concerns

  • Management vs labor had different goals/views
  • Taiwanese employees vociferously opposed the idea
    • Saw as management's attempt to pay them less
    • Less investment in Taiwan = fewer jobs for Taiwanese in Taiwan
    • Force workers to go abroad for work
  • Taiwanese Engineers Union estimates: Transfer of 8-inch wafer technology would cost Taiwan 30,000 jobs over next 2 years
  • Union VP led protest of 1,000 engineers: "We lost 6-inch production facilities already, going to lose 8-inch, then 12-inch. How much more can we lose?"
  • Real impact: Loss of learning opportunities ("walk before run")
  • Result: Highly paid executives/specialty engineers at top + poorly paid people at bottom
  • Hollowing out of middle class

Government Decision & Implementation

  • Final decision: Taiwanese government allowed establishment of 8-inch fabs on mainland
  • Conditions: Foundry first had to invest substantial money to upgrade to 12-inch wafer capability
  • Political divisions: Extremely divisive, strange bedfellows
    • DPP President Chen + his minister supported it
    • Lee Denghui opposed it
    • Head of Mainland Affairs Council opposed (unknown Tsai Ing-wen)
    • Tsai: "Lifting ban on wafer investment like releasing two tigers. Once they eat up rabbits in China, they'll come back and eat Taiwanese rabbits"
  • Public opinion shift: 50-50 support → 27% support (1/3 said didn't know enough)

Outcomes & Results

  • Opening marked start of friendlier cross-strait relations
  • Further supported during subsequent Kuomintang President Ma Ying-jeou administration
  • Financial success for foundries:
    • 2007: TSMC built first fab on mainland (Shanghai)
    • 2017: Second fab opened (Nanjing)
    • Nanjing fab alone: $500 million revenue in 2019
    • Made it 3rd largest foundry on mainland by itself
  • Relations chilled when President Ma left (least popular president on record)
  • Tsai Ing-wen cruised to 2016 victory

Economic & Political Assessment

  • Economic impact: Hard to find clear support in data
    • Some sectors gained, others lost (normal for any economy)
    • Data extremely messy
  • Overall assessment: Move helped Taiwan economically/financially but at political cost
  • Many companies got richer
  • Improved mainland relations better for business (Taiwanese business class view)
  • Ironically gave assurance to continue investing in Taiwan itself
  • Societal/political costs extremely high:
    • Taiwanese businesses continued investing in China
    • Issue caught up with struggling economy problems
    • Wages stagnated, house prices soared
    • Young people moved to America/mainland
    • Taiwanese people saw continued struggle
    • Eventually culminated in momentous Sunflower Student Movement (2014)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome