AI summary by TwinMind
Shrinkflation May Leave Fewer Chips in Your Bag | WSJ Price Index
The Wall Street Journal
5m 55s
Definition and Examples of Shrinkflation
- Shrinkflation = companies reducing product size/quality while maintaining same price to combat higher production costs
- Doritos example: 9.75 ounces → 9.25 ounces (0.5 oz reduction) in February 2021, price unchanged
- PepsiCo characterized as "ongoing product evolution"
- Paper towel rolls with fewer sheets
- Quality reductions: sugar → high fructose corn syrup, fewer car upgrades, hotels eliminating daily towel service/free WiFi
Consumer Behavior and Company Strategies
- Most shoppers focus on overall price, not price-per-weight despite labels
- Consumers becoming more aware, forcing companies to be more creative
- New packaging/redesigns hide size changes from obvious comparison
- Limited edition products (Oreos) in smaller packages at higher cost than regular versions
- Mondelez: consumers drawn to "unique fun forms of value"
- Transflation: existing products in "more convenient" packaging for higher price
Corporate Terminology and Messaging
- Companies avoid term "shrinkflation" due to negative connotation
- Use "price pack architecture" instead
- Broader term covering product line changes
- Includes removing, replacing, adding items of various sizes
- Campbell Soup CEO example: "mega bites on goldfish" and "family size" as new price pack architecture
- Campbell spokesperson: family size gives "more product not less"
Business Reasons for Size Changes
- Competitive pricing alignment
- Chobani: 6 oz → 5.3 oz yogurt containers to match competitors
- Consumer backlash occurred but increased revenue without price increases
- Combat higher production costs
- Tillamook ice cream: 56 oz → 48 oz containers, same price
- CEO (June 2021): needed to pay farmer-owners adequately
Implementation Challenges and Considerations
- Requires production line changes, package design modifications
- Time needed for supply chain flow-through
- Only implemented when "hands are tied" and inflation expected to persist
- Must coordinate with retailers who set final prices
- Consumer perception biggest concern
- 2016 Toblerone example: widened gaps between chocolate peaks in UK
- Social media backlash led to discontinuation in 2018
Long-term Implications
- Changes typically permanent: "sizes do not go back, prices do not go back"
- Companies train consumers on new expectations
- Costs reductions don't reverse changes
- Larger brands lead, smaller brands follow suit
- Consumer loyalty crucial for companies
