AI summary by TwinMind
Silicon Carbide: A Power Electronics Revolution
Asianometry
15m 19s
Tesla's 2018 Silicon Carbide Adoption
- Tesla inverted expectations in 2018 by adopting ST Microelectronics silicon carbide-based inverter for Model 3
- Allowed Tesla to shrink one of EV's most critical components in half
- Sparked renewed interest in silicon technology as old as the industry itself
Silicon Carbide Material Properties and History
- Exists in meteorites but almost nowhere else naturally - almost all synthetically made
- Edward Goodrich Atchison (Thomas Edison's assistant) first produced industrially in 1890
- Heated silica rock and powdered carbon (coke) to 2600°C in electric furnace
- Method still used today (Atchison method)
- Made of equal parts silicon and carbon
- Over 200 known crystal polytypes variants
- Only 3 usable for electronic devices: 3C, 4H, 6H
- 3C wafers not commercially available due to instability at high temperatures
- Most commercial research consolidating to 4H variant
- Extremely hard - hardest synthetic substance until boron carbide creation in 1929
- Industrial uses: body armor, grinding, sandpaper abrasive
Wide Band Gap Semiconductor Properties
- Silicon carbide classified as wide band gap material (along with synthetic diamond, gallium nitride)
- Semiconductor materials have valence band and conduction band
- Band gap = energy needed for electrons to jump from valence to conduction band
- Wider buffer zone = more energy needed to jump bands
- Silicon carbide has super wide band gap + excellent heat conductor (3x better than silicon, second only to diamond)
- Commercial silicon semiconductors top out at ~175°C before breaking out of band gaps
- Silicon carbide can operate up to 300°C and beyond, maybe 900°C with right packaging
- Critical electric field limit 8-10x higher than traditional silicon before avalanche effect
- Can handle voltages many times higher than silicon
Electric Vehicle Power Electronics
- Power electronics one of "big three" technologies enabling practical EVs (with battery and electric traction motor)
- Generally made up of 4 components, most important is inverter
- Inverter converts DC power from EV battery into AC power for EV motor operation
- Two popular power switching devices:
- MOSFET: low voltage, lower power, high frequency applications (dominate <600V market)
- IGBT: high voltage, high power, low frequency applications (dominate 600V-6.5kV market)
- Most EV inverters before Model 3 used IGBT transistors
- Challenge: going beyond 6.5kV limitation makes electrical fields too powerful for traditional silicon
Silicon Carbide Advantages in Power Electronics
- Can operate at:
- Up to 10x higher temperatures
- Up to 10x higher voltages
- Up to 5x higher switching frequencies
- Reduces need for active/passive cooling systems (air-cooled heat sinks, liquid cooling, etc.)
- Cooling systems are heavy, costly, never as effective as desired
- Heavier, more energy-hungry EVs cannot travel as far/fast as traditional cars
Manufacturing Challenges and Solutions
- Silicon carbide sublimes (solid directly to gas) without melting - no liquid melt available
- Cannot use traditional Czochralski method for wafer production
- Historical methods:
- Atchison method (1890s): fine for sandpaper, insufficient purity for electronics
- Lilly method (1954): Jan Anthony Lilly of Philips Electronics discovered method using porous graphite tube
- Modified Lilly method (1978): Soviet scientists Tairov and Svetkov improved process
- Current method: Physical Vapor Transportation (PVT)
- Can grow boules of one pure silicon carbide polytype at few millimeters/hour
- Companies working toward 200mm wafers, defect rates still challenging
- Additional processing challenges:
- Can only cut wafers with synthetic diamonds (adds cost)
- Pure silicon carbide is insulator, needs doping to conduct electricity
- Diffusing dopants requires very high temperatures
Commercial Development Timeline
- Infineon introduced first commercial silicon carbide power device in 2001 (Schottky diode)
- Silicon carbide MOSFET chips first commercialized in 2010 by Cree (renamed to Wolfspeed in October 2021)
- Other companies entered space: ST Microelectronics, Rohm, Infineon, Microsemi
- EV inverter market grown into multi-billion dollar market
- Cost improvements: $700/inverter unit in 2013 → $450 in 2020
- Price gap with traditional silicon devices substantially smaller but still exists
- Can design inverters with far less cooling systems - space, cost, size savings add up
Future Applications and Market Impact
- Solar inverters: convert DC from photovoltaic panels to AC for utility use
- Silicon carbide solar inverters show 20% cost reductions over silicon-based competitors
- Silicon carbide MOSFETs anticipated to challenge silicon IGBTs in traditional market strongholds
- Practical silicon carbide manufacturing less than few decades old
- Still exploring limits of technology capabilities
