AI summary by TwinMind
Small Phones are Dead and We Killed Them
Marques Brownlee
8m 42s
Evolution of Phone Sizes
- Phone screens evolved rapidly: 4-inch → 5-inch → 6-inch flagships mainstream
- 7-inch phones not mainstream but largest flagships approaching that size
- Manufacturers repeatedly realized bigger screens created opportunity for smaller alternatives
Historical Small Phone Attempts
- Samsung introduced Galaxy S Mini when main line got big (now discontinued)
- Apple created iPhone Mini for 2 years after introducing huge iPhones (now discontinued)
- Pattern: small flagships consistently fail after 1-2 years
ZenPhone as Last Small Flagship
- ZenPhone 9 (2022): nearly perfect flagship phone
- Flagship specs, incredible performance
- Physics-defying battery life, rock solid cameras
- Won small phone of the year by landslide
- Flaws: back material less durable, no wireless charging
- ZenPhone 10 (2023): perfected the formula
- Fixed back material, added wireless charging
- Latest flagship chips, nothing lost
- Singular excellent flagship phone with <6-inch screen
ZenPhone 11 Ultra: End of an Era
- 2024 ZenPhone 11 Ultra: massive 6.8-inch phone
- Lost defining characteristic of being small and reachable
- Now requires huge pockets/hands for comfortable daily use
- Essentially ROG phone minus gaming features
- Blends into sea of other giant phones
Apple iPhone Mini Case Study
- 2020: Apple released 4 new iPhones (12, 12 Pro, 12 Pro Max, 12 Mini)
- Tim Cook's supply chain expertise: complex studies to estimate sales
- Apple already knew small phones don't sell well
- iPhone 12 Mini reviews: extremely positive from tech reviewers and users
- Sales reality: Mini had ~5% of total iPhone 12 lineup sales
- Became least successful new iPhone of all time
- iPhone 13 Mini performed even worse than 12 Mini
- Quietly discontinued, replaced with plus-sized iPhone
Market Reality
- Positive reviews ≠ commercial success
- Negative reviews ≠ reason for failure
- Most popular new iPhone today: Pro and Pro Max (biggest, most expensive)
- ZenPhone 9 and 10 likely didn't sell well despite positive reception
Current Landscape
- Budget phones also getting bigger
- Pixel 7A: 6.1-inch phone
- Nothing Phone 2A: ultra-sized phone
- Next iPhone SE rumors: not small
- Enthusiast phone dilemma: hot small audience vs. mainstream success
- Manufacturers lose core fans when branching out for broader appeal
Future Outlook
- Small flagship phone void now completely open
- Someone might briefly fill void with new small flagship
- Don't expect it to last long based on historical pattern
