AI summary by TwinMind

Smartphone Awards 2024!

Marques Brownlee

27m 29s

Introduction & Format

  • 10th annual smartphone awards covering 2024 releases
  • 10 categories with potential runner-ups and honorable mentions
  • Custom trophies for winners, available to tech companies
  • All phones released during calendar year 2024

Best Big Phone Category

  • Challenge: phones getting bigger overall, 6.8"+ screens common
  • Runner-ups:
    • ROG Phone 9: gaming-focused, 6.8" screen, huge speakers, huge battery, headphone jack
    • Vivo X200 Pro: late 2024 release, incredible camera hardware, huge camera bump
  • Winner: Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra
    • Formula perfected over years in Ultra series
    • Excellent screen with anti-reflective coating (underrated feature)
    • Great cameras without excessive protrusion
    • Huge battery + stylus integration
    • Strong software support, One UI 7 beta (Android 15)
    • Released January 2024, still deserving

Best Small Phone Category

  • Sad category - mini iPhones and Zen phones discontinued
  • Context: Galaxy s24 (6.2") bigger than Galaxy Note 4 (5.7") from 10 years ago
  • Considered:
    • Samsung Galaxy s24: 6.2" display, smallest current flagship
    • Vivo X200 mini: over 6" screen
    • Flip phones: small when closed, huge when open
  • Winner: iPhone 16
    • 6.1" display, same body size as 16 Pro
    • Apple elevated base phones significantly this year
    • Great cameras, battery life, flagship chip performance
    • Years of software updates, more RAM than previous base models
    • Preferred matte rails and color variety over Pro models
    • Closest base iPhone has ever been to flagship experience

Best Camera Category

  • Hardware improvements: better periscope cameras, bigger sensors, improved optics
  • AI integration everywhere: scene recognition, portrait mode, background removal
  • Most competitive camera year ever
  • Strong contenders:
    • Google Pixel: would perform well in blind camera test, distinctive look
    • Galaxy s24 Ultra: consistently excellent photos/videos for Android
  • Runner-up: Vivo X200 Pro
    • Serious camera hardware, closest to real camera experience
    • 50MP main sensor, 50MP ultra-wide, 200MP periscope zoom
    • Natural depth of field, quick camera app with options
    • High-res telephoto: 3.7x optical zoom maintains sharpness at higher zoom
    • Portrait lens looks with convincing bokeh styling
  • Winner: iPhone 16 Pro
    • Continues winning streak despite reviewer fatigue
    • Go-to choice for professional photo/video users
    • Easy, simple, reliable shooting experience
    • Consistent look and results
    • New manual controls and shooting formats
    • Unparalleled video: 4K 30fps, autofocus, stabilization, slow-mo

Best Value Category

  • Most competitive category with many budget options
  • Philosophy: maximum value regardless of price point (diminishing returns for expensive phones)
  • Honorable mentions:
    • Pixel 8A: $500, excellent camera system for price range
    • CMF Phone One: $200, unique modular design, fun and accessible
  • Winner: Nothing Phone 2A
    • $350 launch price
    • Big bright 120Hz screen with uniform bezels
    • 5,000mAh battery with 45W charging
    • Serviceable 50MP main camera + ultra-wide
    • Under-display fingerprint reader
    • Smooth software optimization despite modest benchmarks
    • Glyph interface on back
    • Feels as smooth as flagships in daily use
    • Ongoing software updates

Best Battery Category

  • More 5,500-6,000mAh batteries in flagships than ever
  • Award considers overall battery experience: life + charging + maintenance features
  • Strong contenders:
    • Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra: 5,000mAh + stylus, 45W peak charging, wireless charging, all-day usage
    • Oppo Find X8 Pro: 5,900mAh, 80W charging (0-100 in under 1 hour), 50W wireless charging
    • Vivo X200 Pro: 6,000mAh, 90W charging
  • Winner: Red Magic 10 Pro
    • Gaming phone with active cooling fan (sacrifices water resistance)
    • New Snapdragon 8 Elite chip (dramatically more efficient)
    • 7,500mAh battery
    • 2-day phone comfortably at 144Hz
    • 100W peak charging (0-100 in ~30 minutes)
    • Battery maintenance features: 80% charging cap, bypass charging

Best Design Category

  • Response to "smartphones are boring/all the same" criticism
  • Notable mentions:
    • CMF Phone One: fun design differentiating $200 budget phone
    • Nothing Phone 2A: glyph design, transparent elements, special editions, software integration
  • Winner: Huawei Mate XT (Trifold)
    • Audacious engineering feat - triple folding smartphone
    • Mass production and shipping (not just prototype)
    • Super thin with distributed battery through hinges
    • Cameras integrated on back
    • Software features work with 2 and 3 panel configurations
    • Despite durability concerns and potential PR issues

Best Foldable Category

  • Added category due to growing foldable market
  • Samsung no longer dominates after early lead
  • Hardware excellence: Honor Magic V3
    • Current mantle holder for best foldable hardware
    • Extremely thin, flagship feel
    • Minimal crease, excellent battery/camera integration
    • Sturdy hinge construction
  • Winner: Google Pixel 9 Pro fold
    • Second-generation folding Pixel
    • Most polished folding Android experience
    • Improved design: trimmed dimensions, flattened sides, better hinge
    • Enhanced cameras, usable when closed
    • Superior Android software optimization for folding screens
    • Would choose over Honor despite hardware preference

Most Improved Award

  • Hardest category to determine this year
  • Considered:
    • Oppo Find X8 Pro: brighter screen, improved cameras, new chipset/software
    • iPhone 16: closest base model has ever been to Pro versions
  • Winner: Google Pixel 9 Pro fold
    • First Pixel fold was cool concept but flawed execution
    • Thick bezels, didn't fold completely flat
    • Second generation improved every aspect:
      • Much better cameras, thinner hinge, skinnier overall
      • Better bezels inside, folds flat, less crease
      • Improved outside screen brightness
      • Complete hardware glow-up

Bust of the Year Award

  • First year awarding to phone that's not actually bad
  • Winner: Asus Zenfone 11 Ultra
    • Fine phone, adequate performance
    • Represents loss of unique small flagship category
    • Previous Zenfones were interesting, compact flagships
    • Became generic big phone, lost distinctive appeal
    • Symbolic of industry trend away from small phones
    • Questions future of "best small phone" category

MVP Phone of the Year

  • Highest pressure award representing entire smartphone year
  • Philosophy: rewarding overall greatness
  • Strong runner-ups:
    • Vivo X200 Pro: excellent in "can't go wrong" territory - bright screen, great chipset, incredible cameras, battery life, fast charging
    • Pixel 9 Pro fold: major comeback story, daily-driveable foldable
    • iPhone 16: most complete base iPhone ever, best year for not spending $1,500
    • Pixel 9 Pro XL: reviewer's current daily driver (though dinged up)
  • Winner: Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra
    • Scotty Scheffler analogy: excels at everything without being flashy
    • Great screen, chip, battery, cameras, software, support, durability
    • Above-average anti-reflective screen coating
    • Excellent vibration motor and speakers
    • Most-used phone during 2024 (9 months out of year)
    • Most frequently returned-to phone in 6-8 years of reviewing
    • Does everything right, deserves award despite being "boring" choice

Closing Remarks

  • 10th anniversary of smartphone awards
  • Gratitude for audience support enabling phone testing/reviewing
  • Motivation to improve future awards
  • "10 down, 10 more to go"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome