AI summary by TwinMind
Smartphone Awards 2024!
Marques Brownlee
27m 29s
Introduction & Format
- 10th annual smartphone awards covering 2024 releases
- 10 categories with potential runner-ups and honorable mentions
- Custom trophies for winners, available to tech companies
- All phones released during calendar year 2024
Best Big Phone Category
- Challenge: phones getting bigger overall, 6.8"+ screens common
- Runner-ups:
- ROG Phone 9: gaming-focused, 6.8" screen, huge speakers, huge battery, headphone jack
- Vivo X200 Pro: late 2024 release, incredible camera hardware, huge camera bump
- Winner: Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra
- Formula perfected over years in Ultra series
- Excellent screen with anti-reflective coating (underrated feature)
- Great cameras without excessive protrusion
- Huge battery + stylus integration
- Strong software support, One UI 7 beta (Android 15)
- Released January 2024, still deserving
Best Small Phone Category
- Sad category - mini iPhones and Zen phones discontinued
- Context: Galaxy s24 (6.2") bigger than Galaxy Note 4 (5.7") from 10 years ago
- Considered:
- Samsung Galaxy s24: 6.2" display, smallest current flagship
- Vivo X200 mini: over 6" screen
- Flip phones: small when closed, huge when open
- Winner: iPhone 16
- 6.1" display, same body size as 16 Pro
- Apple elevated base phones significantly this year
- Great cameras, battery life, flagship chip performance
- Years of software updates, more RAM than previous base models
- Preferred matte rails and color variety over Pro models
- Closest base iPhone has ever been to flagship experience
Best Camera Category
- Hardware improvements: better periscope cameras, bigger sensors, improved optics
- AI integration everywhere: scene recognition, portrait mode, background removal
- Most competitive camera year ever
- Strong contenders:
- Google Pixel: would perform well in blind camera test, distinctive look
- Galaxy s24 Ultra: consistently excellent photos/videos for Android
- Runner-up: Vivo X200 Pro
- Serious camera hardware, closest to real camera experience
- 50MP main sensor, 50MP ultra-wide, 200MP periscope zoom
- Natural depth of field, quick camera app with options
- High-res telephoto: 3.7x optical zoom maintains sharpness at higher zoom
- Portrait lens looks with convincing bokeh styling
- Winner: iPhone 16 Pro
- Continues winning streak despite reviewer fatigue
- Go-to choice for professional photo/video users
- Easy, simple, reliable shooting experience
- Consistent look and results
- New manual controls and shooting formats
- Unparalleled video: 4K 30fps, autofocus, stabilization, slow-mo
Best Value Category
- Most competitive category with many budget options
- Philosophy: maximum value regardless of price point (diminishing returns for expensive phones)
- Honorable mentions:
- Pixel 8A: $500, excellent camera system for price range
- CMF Phone One: $200, unique modular design, fun and accessible
- Winner: Nothing Phone 2A
- $350 launch price
- Big bright 120Hz screen with uniform bezels
- 5,000mAh battery with 45W charging
- Serviceable 50MP main camera + ultra-wide
- Under-display fingerprint reader
- Smooth software optimization despite modest benchmarks
- Glyph interface on back
- Feels as smooth as flagships in daily use
- Ongoing software updates
Best Battery Category
- More 5,500-6,000mAh batteries in flagships than ever
- Award considers overall battery experience: life + charging + maintenance features
- Strong contenders:
- Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra: 5,000mAh + stylus, 45W peak charging, wireless charging, all-day usage
- Oppo Find X8 Pro: 5,900mAh, 80W charging (0-100 in under 1 hour), 50W wireless charging
- Vivo X200 Pro: 6,000mAh, 90W charging
- Winner: Red Magic 10 Pro
- Gaming phone with active cooling fan (sacrifices water resistance)
- New Snapdragon 8 Elite chip (dramatically more efficient)
- 7,500mAh battery
- 2-day phone comfortably at 144Hz
- 100W peak charging (0-100 in ~30 minutes)
- Battery maintenance features: 80% charging cap, bypass charging
Best Design Category
- Response to "smartphones are boring/all the same" criticism
- Notable mentions:
- CMF Phone One: fun design differentiating $200 budget phone
- Nothing Phone 2A: glyph design, transparent elements, special editions, software integration
- Winner: Huawei Mate XT (Trifold)
- Audacious engineering feat - triple folding smartphone
- Mass production and shipping (not just prototype)
- Super thin with distributed battery through hinges
- Cameras integrated on back
- Software features work with 2 and 3 panel configurations
- Despite durability concerns and potential PR issues
Best Foldable Category
- Added category due to growing foldable market
- Samsung no longer dominates after early lead
- Hardware excellence: Honor Magic V3
- Current mantle holder for best foldable hardware
- Extremely thin, flagship feel
- Minimal crease, excellent battery/camera integration
- Sturdy hinge construction
- Winner: Google Pixel 9 Pro fold
- Second-generation folding Pixel
- Most polished folding Android experience
- Improved design: trimmed dimensions, flattened sides, better hinge
- Enhanced cameras, usable when closed
- Superior Android software optimization for folding screens
- Would choose over Honor despite hardware preference
Most Improved Award
- Hardest category to determine this year
- Considered:
- Oppo Find X8 Pro: brighter screen, improved cameras, new chipset/software
- iPhone 16: closest base model has ever been to Pro versions
- Winner: Google Pixel 9 Pro fold
- First Pixel fold was cool concept but flawed execution
- Thick bezels, didn't fold completely flat
- Second generation improved every aspect:
- Much better cameras, thinner hinge, skinnier overall
- Better bezels inside, folds flat, less crease
- Improved outside screen brightness
- Complete hardware glow-up
Bust of the Year Award
- First year awarding to phone that's not actually bad
- Winner: Asus Zenfone 11 Ultra
- Fine phone, adequate performance
- Represents loss of unique small flagship category
- Previous Zenfones were interesting, compact flagships
- Became generic big phone, lost distinctive appeal
- Symbolic of industry trend away from small phones
- Questions future of "best small phone" category
MVP Phone of the Year
- Highest pressure award representing entire smartphone year
- Philosophy: rewarding overall greatness
- Strong runner-ups:
- Vivo X200 Pro: excellent in "can't go wrong" territory - bright screen, great chipset, incredible cameras, battery life, fast charging
- Pixel 9 Pro fold: major comeback story, daily-driveable foldable
- iPhone 16: most complete base iPhone ever, best year for not spending $1,500
- Pixel 9 Pro XL: reviewer's current daily driver (though dinged up)
- Winner: Samsung Galaxy s24 Ultra
- Scotty Scheffler analogy: excels at everything without being flashy
- Great screen, chip, battery, cameras, software, support, durability
- Above-average anti-reflective screen coating
- Excellent vibration motor and speakers
- Most-used phone during 2024 (9 months out of year)
- Most frequently returned-to phone in 6-8 years of reviewing
- Does everything right, deserves award despite being "boring" choice
Closing Remarks
- 10th anniversary of smartphone awards
- Gratitude for audience support enabling phone testing/reviewing
- Motivation to improve future awards
- "10 down, 10 more to go"
