AI summary by TwinMind
Sociologists Want to Establish Scientific Consensus
Sabine Hossenfelder
6m 38s
Study Overview and Methodology
- Group of philosophers and sociologists conducted proof of concept study to regularly poll scientists on scientific consensus
- Participants asked to agree/disagree with statement: "Science has put it beyond reasonable doubt that COVID-19 is caused by virus"
- Method: short email/text with link to 5-point scale (strongly agree to strongly disagree)
- Invited 20,000+ scientists from various disciplines across 12 countries
- Received ~7,000 replies
- Only 23.2% agreed or strongly agreed with the statement
- Results consistent across different areas of expertise
Fundamental Problem with the Question
- COVID-19 defined by WHO as infectious disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 virus
- Wikipedia confirms this definition
- Physical images of virus exist
- COVID-19 is by definition whatever disease the virus causes
- Only way to disagree: misunderstanding the question
- Could misinterpret as "all symptoms attributed to COVID-19 are virus-caused"
- But that's not what was asked
Study Results and Expansion Plans
- Researchers consider study "great success"
- Expanded network to 80 institutions with 50,000 scientists worldwide
- Aim to make tool regular feature of global science communication
- Goal: inform society on critical scientific issues
Critique: Philosophical Problems
- Science not done by consensus but by argument
- Einstein example: 1931 book "100 Authors Against Einstein"
- Einstein's response: "If I were wrong, it would only take one"
- Evidence and argument matter, not opinion counts
- YouTube subscribers, polls don't determine scientific truth
- IPCC doesn't use consensus mechanism - examines evidence for scientific claims
- IPCC has problems but at least not consensus-based
Critique: Sociological Problems
- Poll results impact scientific community inappropriately
- Scientists lack training to prevent social biases
- Most will adjust opinions to fit supposed consensus
- Will further streamline scientific community beyond current level
Proposed Alternative and Concerns
- Should create institution that:
- Collects and evaluates scientific evidence
- Provides confidence values based on evidence
- Constantly evaluating consensus is horrible idea
- Will always find scientists who:
- Misunderstand questions
- Like annoying sociologists
- Answer randomly (e.g., "C" on 1-5 scale)
- Science deniers can now claim "7% of scientists don't agree COVID caused by virus"
Sponsor Segment: Imprint App
- Learning efficiency app for personal development, science, technology
- Features: courses, visual book summaries, quick read articles
- Example learning: schedule non-work activities in calendar to avoid procrastination/overwork
- Offer: first 200 subscribers get 7-day free trial + 20% off annual subscription
- Link: imprint.app.com/sabina
