AI summary by TwinMind
Sophie Williams: The rigged test of leadership | TED
TED
13m 29s
Glass Ceiling vs Glass Cliff Concept
- Speaker focuses on women's experiences in UK/US workplaces, particularly Black women
- Glass ceiling: invisible barrier preventing women from reaching professional pinnacles
- Glass cliff: dangerous position underrepresented leaders find themselves in after breaking through glass ceiling
- Common assumption: breaking glass ceiling leads to "onwards and upwards" success
- Reality: leaders often find themselves teetering on edge of glass cliff
Definition of Underrepresented Leaders
- Most underrepresented at senior business levels
- Includes women and racially marginalized people
- Essentially anyone who's not both white and male
The Times Newspaper Investigation
- Observed pattern: when underrepresented people take over businesses, businesses seem to fail
- Published article: "Women on the Board: A Help or a Hindrance?"
- Concluded women on boards were bad for business
- Speaker notes they were right in one small way, wrong in 100 bigger ways
Research Evidence - University of Exeter
- Studied FTSE 100 companies appointing female leaders
- Businesses much more likely than average to have been in consistent 5-month period of poor performance before appointment
- Poor performance includes:
- Reputational scandals (tarnish passed to new leader)
- Market valuation hits
- Profit declines
Research Evidence - University of Utah
- Studied Fortune 500 companies over 15-year period
- Examined appointments of women and racially marginalized men
- Found identical pattern: businesses appointing underrepresented leaders much more likely to already be in poor performance period
Impact of Narrative
- When underrepresented leaders fail due to predetermined limitations
- Message reinforced: "Someone like that isn't right kind of person to run successful business"
- Creates compounding effect of internalized bias
Why Glass Cliff Happens - Reason 1: Caregiver Stereotype
- In patriarchal societies, women viewed as caregivers/nurturers
- Women appointed for perceived soft skills, not transformational change ability
- Hired to reengage workforce and restore motivation
- Not given tools or time necessary for actual change
- Chances of failure increased by limited imagination of those who hired them
Why Glass Cliff Happens - Reason 2: Scapegoat Theory
- Kristin Anderson (psychology professor, University of Houston): women seen as more disposable/expendable
- Creates win-win scenario for struggling businesses:
- If woman succeeds: business transformed
- If woman fails: blame placed on her shoulders, pushed over cliff
- "Savior effect": woman replaced by white man
- Signals business back in "safe pair of hands"
- White male replacement more likely given tools and time to succeed
Intersectional Analysis - Black Women Leaders
- Focus on people with two marginalized identities
- When Black woman takes senior role (board member/CEO):
- Business likely not in great shape
- Likely managing large team of white men in leadership layer below
Leadership Demographics Statistics
- 2019 Lean In Foundation data:
- White men: 30% of entry-level junior cohort
- White men: 68% of C-suite level
- White men only group whose representation grows with seniority
- Experience opposite of glass ceiling - see themselves reflected at senior levels
Research on White Male Subordinates
- University of Texas and University of Michigan research
- Studied white men getting boss who doesn't mirror both whiteness and maleness
- Results when boss doesn't directly mirror them:
- Feel less personally connected to business
- Less able to personally identify with business
- Less personally invested in business
- Work performance suffered
Double Impact on Team Management
- White male managers stopped developing/mentoring their teams
- Particularly stopped helping racially marginalized team members
- Glass cliff "bites twice":
- Pushes existing leader closer to cliff edge
- Prevents new cohort of underrepresented leaders from advancing
- Unequal support/guidance/mentorship/development
Call to Action
- Businesses, governments, charities are just groups of people
- Change possible through examining conscious and unconscious biases
- Decide to see value in all people all the time
- Not just some people when there's problem to solve or blame to assign
- Angela Davis quote: "act as though [it's possible to change] the world... all of the time"
- Personal commitment to not push anyone closer to their cliff edge
