AI summary by TwinMind
Space-Filling Aether Theory Makes Comeback
Sabine Hossenfelder
8m 23s
Historical Context of Ether Theory
- Ether = Greek word meaning "fresh air" - what gods breathed in heavens
- Newton entertained idea gravitational force transmitted through ether
- 19th century: luminiferous ether proposed to explain light wave propagation
- Scientists knew only 3 wave types: water, air, sound waves
- Light behaved as wave (proven by prisms, interference experiments)
- Question: what medium was waving for light?
Original Ether Theory Properties
- Luminiferous ether defined absolute rest reference frame
- Earth moved through ether on path around Sun, dragging parts along
- Ether drag had to be small due to stellar aberration observations
- Star positions change along Earth's orbit
- Ether would move stars differently than observed
- Predicted: light should move at different velocities depending on direction
- Faster when moving with ether flow
- Slower when moving perpendicular to ether
Michelson-Morley Experiment & Rejection
- Famously proved original ether theory wrong
- Light moves at same speed in all directions
- No ether defining absolute rest frame
- Einstein correct: all motion relative to something else
- Scientists accepted light travels in empty space without medium
Modern Ether Comeback - Cosmic Microwave Background
- Universe filled with electromagnetic radiation from Big Bang
- Cosmic microwave background (CMB) temperature: 2.7 Kelvin in all directions
- Earth moves relative to CMB creating temperature dipole
- Hotter in direction of Earth's movement
- Colder in opposite direction
- CMB defines what means to be at absolute rest with universe
- Technically affects light speed through photon-photon interactions
- Effect ridiculously tiny, unobservable
Einstein Ether Theory
- Introduced by Ted Jacobson and David Mattingley 20 years ago
- Einstein-compatible ether theory
- Usually assumed relative to cosmic microwave background
- Key difference: doesn't affect light (except gravitationally)
- Has gravitational effects like any extra matter in universe
- Can mimic dark energy easily
- Difficult to make work for dark matter
Current Research Applications
- Papers published every couple of weeks
- Physicists testing compatibility with:
- Gravitational lenses observations
- Supergalactic structures
- Other observational data
- Mathematically not advantageous over dark energy/dark matter models
- Very flexible model with many parameters
- Can fit any data with sufficient parameters
Direct Detection Attempts
- Physicists searching for Einstein ether directly
- If interacted with Standard Model particles, would have observable consequences:
- Electrons spontaneously emitting photons
- Particles slowed at different rates based on spin
- Birefringence effects
- None of these effects observed
- Doesn't rule out theory, just means ether as elusive as dark matter
Current Status
- Ether theories still exist and compatible with data
- Not same ether ruled out century ago
- Einstein-compatible ether potential alternative to dark energy/dark matter
- Currently no distinct advantage over existing models
- Remains theoretical possibility without compelling evidence
