AI summary by TwinMind
Stacking Dies on Glass Panels
Asianometry
15m 47s
Advanced Packaging Crisis & Solutions
- Advanced packaging identified as roadblock in NVIDIA AI chip production affecting stock price
- TSMC accelerated construction on several Advanced packaging fabs across Taiwan to address bottleneck
- Industry moving toward cost-cutting technology: glass panel interposers
- Most intriguing theme of 2024 Semicon show: panels chips on panels
Chiplet Approach Fundamentals
- Cost-saving method: fabricate chiplets using appropriate node, integrate in single package
- Contrast to monolithic chip where one node makes whole chip at once
- Advantages:
- Only most complicated parts need most advanced node (lowest yields)
- Not every part needs N3E node
- Design migration benefits for annual refresh cycles (especially AI boom companies like NVIDIA)
- Can update most value-added parts without redoing entire package
2.5D vs 3D Integration Methods
- Industry has two integration philosophies for chiplets
- 3D Integration:
- Stack components vertically
- Smallest size package, fastest connections
- Issues: heat retention, failure analysis (can't see into package)
- 2.5D Integration:
- Package disparate parts (digital logic, memory, I/O) side by side on substrate
- Originally seen as layover to true 3D, now permanent solution
- Modern AI accelerators use mix of 3D and 2.5D
- Example: 3D integrate memory chips (HBM stacks), then 2.5D integrate with other portions
- TSMC prediction: by 2027, systems with 12+ stacks
Communication & Interconnect Technologies
- Redistribution Layer (RDL):
- Copper interconnect layers for horizontal signal redistribution across package
- Fan-out capability: match densely packed small connections to larger solder balls
- TSMC breakthrough: Integrated Fan Out (InFO) technology for Apple
- Can sit on top, below, or be part of interposer
- Through Vias:
- Vertical copper interconnects running through substrate/interposer
- Rule of thumb: RDLs horizontal, through vias vertical
- Interposer:
- PCB-like component, sits on top of substrate
- Sometimes combined with substrate functions
- Substrate:
- Provides mechanical backbone, prevents delicate silicon die bending
- Must have through vias for PCB communication
Intel's Glass Substrate Innovation
- Late 2023: Intel announced glass core substrate panels for advanced packaging
- Historical Context:
- Early Intel CPUs: ceramic substrates
- 1995: Intel led industry change from ceramics to organics (epoxy resin with glass fibers)
- New proposal: pure glass substrate panel cores
- Glass Advantages:
- Better heat tolerance
- Super flat surface supporting denser interconnect/bump networks
- Optical benefits: transparency enables easier package inspection
- Major problem solved: visibility into complicated packages
- Intel credited as trendsetter, TSMC and Samsung followed
Silicon Interposer Analysis
- Current industry standard: silicon wafer-based interposers
- Advantages:
- Mature technology, best performance
- Densest interconnect layers possible
- Decades of established techniques
- Active interposers: can include transistors
- Passive interposers: just interconnects
- Disadvantages:
- Expensive, wasteful process
- Requires Czochralski process: slow crystal pulling from melt
- Expensive cutting, polishing, wafer preparation steps
- Complicated through-via drilling (copper diffusion protection needed)
- Size limitations: 200mm or 300mm wafer standard
- Yield issues: only ~4 large rectangular interposers per 300mm wafer
- Wasted space: cutting rectangles from round wafers
- Economic inefficiency
Panel-Based Interposer Economics
- Rectangular panels enable major cost savings
- Better space utilization
- Up to 8x more usable panels possible
- Significant per-panel cost reduction
- Challenge: identifying optimal panel materials
Organic Interposer Technology
- Materials:
- Bismaleimide triazine (BT) resin
- BT epoxy (circuit board material)
- FR4 substrate: epoxy resin with fiberglass (flame retardant)
- Multi-layer construction similar to PCB manufacturing
- Advantages:
- Cheaper than silicon (financial and complexity)
- Easier processing, fewer specialized steps
- Major Disadvantages:
- Performance limitation: 2-micron minimum line width/spacing
- Cannot achieve silicon-level interconnect density
- Warpage problems from thermal management issues
- Poor heat conduction/dissipation vs silicon
- Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE) mismatch with silicon die/substrate
- Hot spots cause organic warping, package failure
Glass Panel Technology Deep Dive
- Industry Background:
- Microelectronics familiar with glass panels from LCD production
- Thin Film Transistors (TFTs) layered on glass substrates
- Display panels: ~200 micrometers thick, strong, portable
- Corning's Role:
- 1960s: invented/patented fusion draw process for car windshields
- Process: molten glass in V-shaped trough, overflow both ends, fuse at bottom
- LCD industry decline (OLED dominance) drove packaging R&D pivot
- Research Timeline:
- Since 2010: 3D Systems Packaging Research Center at Georgia Tech investigating glass interposers
- Focus: high-performance computing applications
Glass Interposer Manufacturing Process
- Start with special glass panel core
- Drill thousands of Through Glass Vias (TGVs)
- Fill TGVs with copper
- Laminate RDLs and patterns on both sides
- Current applications: MEMS, RF (high compute would be "major leagues")
Glass Interposer Advantages & Challenges
- Advantages:
- Better CTE matching via composition adjustment
- Reduced warpage vs organic interposers
- Superior thermal properties
- Major Challenge: Cracking
- Cutting glass panel dies from large panels problematic
- Mechanical saw causes edge cracks
- "Seare" failures: Japanese term for back splitting
- Crack propagation ruins entire panel
- Failure Causes:
- Deep sharp defects from cutting process
- Tensile stresses from RDL/copper interconnect layers
- Potential Solutions:
- Disco Corporation experiments: diamond grit dicing blades (specific size)
- Pulse lasers effective
- Need to accommodate tens of thousands of TGVs without cracking
TGV Manufacturing Challenges
- Drilling Methods Investigated:
- Lasers
- Acids
- Mechanical drilling (probably won't work due to cracking)
- Via Types:
- Through holes: drill completely through
- Blind holes: stop short, grind down opposite surface
- Industry hasn't found right tool/technique for scale production
Market Opportunities & Industry Developments
- Panel warpage/cracking issues create metrology opportunities
- Companies pivoting from declining LCD panel industry
- TSMC Major Investment:
- ~$500 million acquisition of LCD panel fab in Taoyuan from InnoLux
- Intended for advanced packaging (panel level packaging)
- Industry Trend:
- Taiwanese LCD industry slow decline
- Panel level packaging prominently featured at Semicon 2024
- Industry calling technology "inevitable"
Timeline & Outlook
- Challenges formidable but surmountable
- Expected timeline: 2-3 years for commercial deployment
- Intel leading glass substrate race
- Likely significant behind-scenes glass interposer work
- Rest of industry catching up rapidly
