AI summary by TwinMind
Stock Multiples: How to Tell When a Stock is Cheap/Expensive
The Plain Bagel
9m 47s
Introduction to Stock Valuation
- Challenge: determining when stock price is "low" or "high"
- "Buy low, sell high" advice lacks specific guidance
- No perfect answer for what constitutes low price ($10 vs $100 per share)
- Solution: use multiples to gauge stock expense/value
What Are Multiples
- Definition: ratio comparing stock price to fundamental business metrics
- Function: determine how much paying for underlying business
- Higher multiple = more expensive stock
- Analogy: price per pound at butcher shop for comparing different cuts of meat
- Allows comparison of stock price to underlying fundamentals received
Types of Multiples
- Hundreds of different multiples available
- Examples: EV/EBITDA, price-to-book value, etc.
- Some industry-specific, others broad in nature
- Each carries different implications
- P/E ratio most straightforward and popular
P/E Ratio Fundamentals
- Stands for price-to-earnings ratio
- Calculation: stock price ÷ earnings per share
- Example: Plain Bagel Co
- 1 million shares outstanding
- $30 per share price
- $2 million net income last year
- P/E ratio = 15 times
- Represents how much investor pays per dollar of company profits
Trailing vs Forward P/E
Trailing P/E
- Uses historical earnings data
- Backwards-looking approach
- Shortcoming: markets are forward-looking
- May not account for future improvements/products
Forward P/E
- Uses projected future earnings
- Example: Plain Bagel Co expected $2.5 million earnings next year
- Forward P/E = 12 times
- Problem: relies on forecasts that may not materialize
- Helps gauge payment for company's potential profit
Comparative Analysis Methods
Historical Comparison
- Compare current P/E to company's historical ratios
- Determines if investors value company higher/lower than normal
- Multiple contraction: earnings up, price down (less valuation)
- Multiple expansion: earnings down, price up (paying more for less)
- Mean reversion assumption: multiples return to long-term average
Peer Comparison
- Compare to industry competitors
- Example: Plain Bagel Co (12x) vs competitors
- Sesame Sands: 13x P/E
- Hangul Bagel: 7x P/E
- Peer average: 10x P/E
- Plain Bagel Co more expensive than peer average despite being cheaper historically
Limitations of Multiples
Growth Rate Considerations
- High P/E may be justified by faster growth
- Tech companies typically have higher multiples than utilities
- Growth rate context essential for proper evaluation
Value Trap Risk
- Low multiple doesn't guarantee good investment
- Steak analogy: $3/pound vs $10/pound steak
- Cheaper steak expired and lower quality
- Low P/E may reflect justified devaluation
- Examples of deteriorating fundamentals:
- Industry disruption (keto diets killing bagel industry)
- Regulatory challenges
- Core business deterioration
Accounting Limitations
- P/E uses accounting earnings numbers
- Earnings easily altered by management assumptions
- Non-cash items can distort true picture
- Multiple meaningless without proper context
Investment Approach Recommendations
Proper Strategy
- Find companies based on fundamentals first
- Use multiples to understand valuation after fact
- Avoid chasing low multiples without business understanding
- Warren Buffett quote: "Better to buy wonderful company at fair price than fair company at wonderful price"
Risk of Reverse Approach
- Looking for cheap stocks first leads to low-quality holdings
- Must check fundamentals before investing
- Ensure core business and future prospects remain strong
