AI summary by TwinMind
Strikes Sweep Labor Market as Workers Flex New Leverage | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
7m 40s
Current Strike Activity Overview
- Union workers striking across multiple sectors: Kellogg's cereal plants (Michigan), coal mines (Alabama)
- Workers demanding: higher wages, better benefits, improved working conditions
- Widespread frustration and distrust of employers revealed during pandemic
- Workers realizing need to advocate for themselves, unions capitalizing on sentiment
Non-Union Worker Organizing Efforts
- Many non-union workers seeking collective action since COVID-19 pandemic
- Industries pursuing unionization: trucking, media, museums, higher education, bookstores
- Workers across wide range attempting to unionize or successfully unionizing workplaces
Historical Context and Pre-Pandemic Labor Conditions
- Labor unrest rising pre-pandemic: 2018 (20 work stoppages), 2019 (25 work stoppages)
- Private sector union membership declining for decades
- Pre-pandemic: workers "beaten down," low unionization numbers, few strikes, weak contracts
- Private sector workers not in position of strength before pandemic
COVID-19 Impact on Worker Leverage
- Economic disruption gave workers new leverage
- Cornell University data: strike numbers increased steadily throughout 2021
- Pandemic revealed employers not looking out for worker interests
Recent Strike Outcomes - John Deere Case Study
- Deere workers ratified new 6-year contract this week
- Strike lasted over 1 month, involved 10,000+ workers
- First major labor activity at Deere in 35 years
- UAW statement: "groundbreaking contract sets new standard for workers"
- Deere CEO John May: offering "best wages and benefits in our industries"
High-Profile Unionization Campaigns
Amazon Alabama Warehouse
- Drive failed despite presidential endorsement
- Workers overwhelmingly voted against collective action
Upcoming Campaigns to Watch
- Amazon warehouse in Staten Island
- Starbucks stores in Buffalo, New York
Employer Anti-Union Tactics
- Bombard workers with text messages and in-app messages
- Require mandatory anti-union presentations during work hours
- No legal requirement for equal time for pro-union messaging
Union Organizing Strategies
- Workers form committees to advance unionization
- Personal advocacy to colleagues
- Pro-union literature, text messages, events
- Social media campaigns
Starbucks Buffalo Campaign Details
- CEO Howard Schultz made personal appeal to Buffalo employees
- Schultz message: "We're not perfect, we learn from mistakes"
- Starbucks executive open letter: "pro-Starbucks partners," not anti-union
- Company culture built on "working directly together as partners"
- November 18: Mesa, Arizona Starbucks employees announced union interest
- Described as facing "massive anti-union onslaught"
Current Strike Wave Assessment
- Too early to determine if this is lasting tipping point
- Promising signs currently visible
- Employers have greater resources and legal support to fight unions
- Very difficult to organize or win strikes
- Current wave not large by historical standards
- 1960s-70s: hundreds of strikes occurred annually
Critics' Concerns About Unionization
- Work stoppages could push up consumer prices
- Could slow production
- Argument: dozens of laws now protect employees (safety, health rules)
- Modern alternatives: EEOC, OSHA, NLRB available for worker protection
- Different world than 1950s when unions were primary protection
Pro-Union Counter-Arguments
- "Typical anti-union talking point" that unions no longer needed
- Workers without union contracts can be fired at any time for almost any reason
- Employment at-will: workers fired for "good cause, bad cause, or no cause at all"
Right-to-Work Laws
- Recent states passing laws: Michigan, Wisconsin, West Virginia, Kentucky
- Give workers freedom to choose union membership
- Make union dues optional even in unionized workplaces
- Opponents argue: allows non-members to benefit without paying costs
- Non-due paying workers lead to union membership decline
Legislative Outlook
- PRO Act (Protecting Right to Organize Act)
- House passed legislation earlier this year
- Supporters: would make unionization easier
- Opponents: would undermine worker rights, stifle business
- Blocked in Senate
- Democrats added elements to Build Back Better Act/budget reconciliation bill
