AI summary by TwinMind
SYSK Selects: How Book Banning Works | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
31m 38s
Introduction and Episode Context
- Josh introduces SYSK Selects episode featuring "How Book Banning Works" from 2012
- Episode remains pertinent today as it was then
- Encourages listeners to read books someone didn't want them to read
- Hosts: Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discussing book banning and censorship
Banned Books Week Overview
- Last week of September is Banned Books Week (September 30th - October 6th)
- Purpose: celebrate intellectual freedom against those who would restrict it
- Displays at bookstores like B. Dalton encourage reading challenged books
- American Library Association (ALA) maintains opposition to censorship
Book Challenge Statistics and Examples
- More than 11,000 books challenged since 1982
- 326 challenges in 2011 alone
- Notable challenged books include:
- The Catcher in the Rye (1951) - teacher fired in 1960 for assigning it
- Color of Earth series - nudity, sex education
- The Hunger Games trilogy
- Brave New World - insensitivity, nudity, racism
- To Kill a Mockingbird - offensive language, racism
- Harry Potter series: most challenged since 2000
- 3,000 challenges from 2000-2010
- Reason: perceived satanic overtones/undertones
- Judy Blume's "Forever" - deals with young girl's sexuality
How Book Challenging Works
- Single person can challenge book at individual library
- Librarian decides whether to ban the book
- No formal process required - can simply say "this book is filth"
- Most librarians err on side of not banning
- When book removed, it's banned for that library's users
- Banning typically local, not nationwide
- Groups sometimes organize with lists to challenge multiple books
American Library Association Role
- Contrary to misconceptions, ALA opposes book banning
- Functions as librarian's lobby committed to no censorship
- Maintains Library Bill of Rights
- Provision for free access to libraries for minors
- Position: parents monitor own children's reading, not others'
- Libraries don't make content judgments - that's parents' responsibility
Legal Framework and Court Cases
- Courts generally support First Amendment protections
- School librarians face pressure from school boards
- Key Supreme Court cases:
- 1982 Board of Education Island Trees v. Pico
- Can't remove library materials just because officials disagree with ideas
- School libraries are "special places" of inquiry
- Books need special protection in educational settings
- 1988 Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier
- High school newspapers don't have same rights as adult newspapers
- Schools can censor student publications and curriculum
- 1982 Board of Education Island Trees v. Pico
Texas Textbook Controversy
- Texas biggest textbook buyer nationally
- Texas and California wield most power due to spending/population
- Textbook manufacturers can't afford separate versions for different states
- Conservative Texas committee (elected positions) held 2009 hearings
- Proposed changes to social studies curriculum:
- Emphasize Christian founders narrative
- Include Black Panthers alongside MLK's non-violent protests
- Remove Thomas Jefferson from revolutionary figures list
- Replace with Thomas Aquinas and John Calvin
- Add Milton Friedman and Friedrich Von Hayek to economics
- Rejected amendment about religious freedom protection
- Documentary "The Revisionaries" (2009/2010) covers controversy
- Mary Helen Berlanga repeatedly denied inclusion of Latino figures
- 2010 walkout: "They can't pretend this is White America"
Historical Context of Book Banning
- Censorship dates back to Socrates (forced to drink hemlock)
- Pre-printing press: burning few existing copies solved problem
- Printing press necessitated official banning processes
- England's Star Chamber (17th century) - elite judges as censors
- Henry VIII created licensing laws for pre-publication censorship
Frequently Challenged Authors
- Judy Blume - sexuality themes
- Robert Cormier - "I Am the Cheese," "The Chocolate War"
- J.K. Rowling - Harry Potter series (satanic concerns)
- Katherine Paterson - "Bridge to Terabithia"
- Stephen King - horror content
- Maya Angelou - "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings" (Alabama: "encourages bitterness toward white people")
- R.L. Stine - Goosebumps series (scary content)
- John Steinbeck - "Of Mice and Men" banned in Chattanooga (1989) for "anti-business attitude"
- Alvin Schwartz - "Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark" (ghoulish content)
Obscenity Laws and Standards
- Obscene literature specifically excluded from First Amendment protection
- 1873 Comstock Laws - banned obscene literature in interstate commerce
- 1950s Roth v. United States - defined obscenity as "utterly without social value"
- 1970s Miller v. California case - mass mailer of adult magazine ads
- Miller Test (three-point standard for obscenity):
- Patently offensive sexual conduct
- Appeals to prurient interest (local standard)
- Lacks literary, artistic, political, or scientific value (national standard)
- Burden of proof on those claiming obscenity
- Third prong (artistic merit) often protects materials
Librarian Community and Advocacy
- Librarians passionate about intellectual freedom
- Industry acts as public service
- Strong professional commitment to knowledge protection
- Difficult to infiltrate with censorship advocates
- Hosts encourage supporting local librarians
Listener Feedback
- Disco episode brought back memories for Diane from Louisville
- 1978 New York City experience - dancing at Third Avenue venue
- Disco provided cheap entertainment during difficult times
- Donna Summer's "MacArthur Park" mentioned as favorite
- Clarification on disco episode - not calling all disco haters homophobic
