AI summary by TwinMind

SYSK Selects: How the MPAA Works | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

44m 7s

Introduction and PG-13 Rating Origins

  • Chuck introduces weekend "Stuff You Should Know Selects" episode from June 26, 2014
  • Selected due to Chuck's new show "Movie Crush" and interest in movie-related topics
  • Josh and Chuck discuss their negative views of MPAA practices
  • Both support film content rating for parents but criticize MPAA's methods

PG-13 Rating Creation (1984)

  • Steven Spielberg created PG-13 rating after backlash from two 1984 films
    • "Indiana Jones and Temple of Doom" (directed) - criticized for heart removal scene, snake scenes
    • "Gremlins" (produced) - considered terrifying for children
  • Both films rated PG despite inappropriate content for that rating
  • Spielberg approached MPAA requesting intermediate rating between PG and R
  • PG-13 became the "strike zone" for maximum profitability
  • PG-13 movies pull in more money than all other ratings combined
  • Targets young teenage boys who successfully get girls to attend movies
  • PG-13 violence has tripled over past few decades
  • PG-13 movies now contain more violence than R-rated counterparts

MPAA Historical Development

Early Period (1922-1950s)

  • MPAA formed in early 1920s in Hollywood
  • Will Hayes installed "Hays Code" - pass/fail moral/immoral system
  • Extensive code requirements:
    • Government always portrayed positively
    • Sexuality repressed and heterosexual only
    • Clear good vs. evil divisions
    • Good guys always win
  • Created to prevent local municipalities from passing obscenity laws
  • Self-policing system to control exhibition and profits

Post-WWII Changes (1950s)

  • Society loosened up after WWII
  • Frank Sinatra won Oscar nomination for heroin addict role in "The Man with the Golden Arm"
  • "Some Like It Hot" (1959) with cross-dressing themes
  • Hays Code effectively dead by end of 1950s

Modern Rating System Birth (1968)

  • Ginsburg Supreme Court case regarding selling adult magazines to minors
  • Court ruled local municipalities could decide minor exposure standards
  • Jack Valenti (MPAA head for ~40 years) created current rating system
  • Original ratings: G, PG, R, X
  • Intention to stop censorship and local restrictions
  • Money-centered motivation to ensure wide theatrical release

Current Rating System Structure

Rating Definitions

  • G: General audience, anyone can see
  • PG: No drug use, minimal violence, parental guidance suggested
  • PG-13: Introduced 1984, allows more violence but restricts language/sex
  • R: No one under 17 admitted without parent (suggestion, not law)
  • NC-17: Adults only, replaced X rating in 1990
    • First NC-17 film: "Henry and June" - commercially unsuccessful
    • Associated with foreign films and LGBTQ+ content

Rating Process

  • Classification and Rating Administration (CARA) handles ratings
  • 8-13 anonymous "Raiders" watch films and take notes
  • Overseen by senior Raider
  • Supposed to have children ages 5-17 (many don't meet requirements)
  • Vote on ratings, communicate through senior Raider to distributors
  • Completely secret process - no Raider names released
  • Kirby Dick's documentary "This Film Is Not Yet Rated" exposed fraudulent practices

Submission and Appeals

  • Voluntary system but de facto required for theatrical release
  • Fees: $750 for shorts to $25,000 for big budget films
  • No major theater chains show unrated movies
  • Three options after rating: accept, edit film, or reject rating
  • Appeals process historically conducted in secret
  • Before Kirby Dick's film, couldn't reference other movies in appeals
  • Appeals board includes industry insiders and theater owners

MPAA Bias and Controversies

Violence vs. Sex/Language Double Standard

  • MPAA more lenient with violence than sexuality or profanity
  • PG-13 movies contain more violence than R-rated films
  • Homophobic and misogynistic tendencies in ratings
  • Male sexual gratification more acceptable than female
  • LGBTQ+ content routinely receives harsher ratings

Specific Rating Examples

  • "Once" (romantic musical) and "Hostel 2" (torture porn) - same R rating
  • "Philomena" rated R for f-bombs, reduced to PG-13 after cuts
  • "Rushmore" rated R for brief Playboy centerfolds in background
  • "Happiness" - director Todd Solondz refused NC-17, released unrated
  • "Longtime Companion" (1989) - NC-17 for gay themes, no explicit content
  • "Blue Is the Warmest Color" - NC-17 for lesbian content
  • "Wolf of Wall Street" - R rating despite graphic heterosexual content

Industry Conflicts of Interest

  • MPAA represents six major Hollywood studios (95% of $10.9 billion US box office)
  • Accused of favoring major studios over independents and foreign films
  • Raiders supposedly unaffiliated with industry but appeals board includes industry insiders
  • Secret process eliminates accountability

MPAA Beyond Ratings - Anti-Piracy Efforts

Historical Technology Opposition

  • Jack Valenti lobbied against VCR legality in early 1980s
  • Pattern of opposing new technology to protect studio profits
  • Current focus on digital distribution and online piracy

Anti-Piracy Measures

  • Digital Millennium Copyright Act (2000) - made peer-to-peer sharing federal crime
  • Crackdown on camcorder recording in theaters
  • Academy screener tracking with name coding
  • Public performance licenses required for any non-home screening
  • Even churches need licenses to show films like "Frozen"

Modern Challenges

  • HBO's relaxed attitude toward password sharing
  • Video on demand and internet distribution bypass MPAA control
  • Industry made $10.9 billion in 2013 ticket sales alone
  • Public sympathy low for industry piracy complaints
  • Precarious time for MPAA - losing power while needing it most

Marketing and Check the Box System

  • New "Check the Box" descriptions explain rating reasons
  • Critics say it's advertising disguised as warnings
  • Examples: "intense sci-fi action," "brief nudity," "some drug use"
  • Accused of marketing R-rated content to underage audiences
  • Tie-ins between PG-13 movies and toys for under-13 children
  • Undermines supposed moral compass protection

Transparency and Reform Calls

  • Filmmakers want transparency, not elimination of ratings
  • Secrecy enables manipulation and gaming of system
  • Directors intentionally include extreme content to distract from desired content
  • No written standards available to filmmakers
  • Subjective system without clear guidelines
  • Recent minor concession: possibly releasing 3 out of 13 Raider names per film

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome