Summary by TwinMind · 43m 36s

Summary by TwinMind · 43m 36s

SYSK Selects: Was there a real King Arthur? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

SYSK Selects: Was there a real King Arthur? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

Stuff You Should Know

Introduction and Movie References

  • Chuck introduces Saturday Solex episode from January 14, 2014
  • Josh and Chuck discuss Arthur movies: Excalibur, Monty Python and the Holy Grail, King Arthur (2004)
  • Excalibur featured early appearances by Gabriel Byrne, Liam Neeson, Patrick Stewart
  • Nigel Terry played Arthur, Helen Mirren was Morgana in Excalibur
  • Monty Python Holy Grail considered best Arthurian adaptation
    • Features killer rabbits, coconut-carrying swallows, Knights who say "Ni"
    • Black Knight with "flesh wound," Graham Chapman as Arthur

Arthurian Legend Origins and Structure

  • Legend is syncretized - Catholics added Christianity to existing Celtic mythology
  • Celts had no written language, purely oral tradition
  • Most understanding of Celts comes from outside observers like Pliny the Elder
  • Legend possibly rooted in historical fact

Basic Arthur Legend Summary

  • Arthur saves Britain after Roman Empire crumbles, defeats Saxon invaders
  • Pulls sword from stone or receives Excalibur from Lady of the Lake
  • Father: Uther Pendragon
  • Builds Camelot, gathers Knights of Round Table
  • Round table symbolizes equality (no head of table)
  • Marries Guinevere, affair with Lancelot in some versions
  • Mordred (nephew/son through half-sister Morgana) attempts takeover
  • Final battle at Camlann - Arthur wounded, Mordred killed
  • Excalibur returned to Lady of the Lake by Bedivere
  • Arthur taken to Avalon to die or await Britain's next great need
  • BBC 2002 poll: Arthur voted #51 greatest Briton despite questionable existence

Literary Evolution Through History

  • First mention: 5th-6th century Welsh poem "Gododdin"
  • Historia Britonum (AD 800) and Annales Cambriae mention Arthur
  • Geoffrey of Monmouth's Historia Regum Britanniae (1100s) popularized legend
    • Based on earlier works, accused of fabrication
    • Introduced Christianity, contemporized for his audience
  • French additions (Christian de Troyes, ~50 years after Geoffrey):
    • Romance elements emphasized
    • Lancelot-Guinevere affair
    • Holy Grail quest (12th century addition)
  • Vulgate Cycle (1210-1230):
    • Prose stories focusing on chivalry
    • Galahad (Lancelot's son) discovers Grail
    • Joseph of Arimathea brings Grail to Britain
    • Lady of the Lake and Mordred as Arthur's son added
  • Thomas Malory's Le Morte d'Arthur (compilation):
    • Added stories of Sir Gareth, Sir Tristan
    • Focused on Christian over Celtic mythology
    • Guinevere becomes nun, Lancelot becomes monk
  • Later works: Tennyson's Idylls of the King, T.H. White's The Once and Future King (basis for Disney's Sword in the Stone)

Historical Evidence and Real Locations

Merlin

  • Possibly based on two real people:
    • Myrddin Wyllt: Wild man with PTSD who fled to woods after war
    • Emrys: Druid prophet and advisor
  • Both lived late 6th century

Camelot Candidates

  • Tintagel Castle, Cornwall:
    • Geoffrey of Monmouth's choice
    • 1980s stone inscription: "descendant of Arthur father of descendant of Col"
    • Current castle built 1100s, but area settled from 300 AD
    • Archaeological evidence of trading post/fortified settlement in Arthur's timeframe
  • Winchester Castle:
    • Malory's choice
    • Wooden round table hung there for centuries
    • Castle built 11th century, table carbon-dated to 1340, painted 1500s under Henry VII
  • Cadbury Castle, Somerset:
    • Most likely candidate if real
    • 16-foot thick timber/stone fortress from 5th century
    • Unique construction, documentary evidence
    • Would have belonged to ruler Arthur supposedly defeated

Avalon

  • Glastonbury Tor identification
  • 12th century monks claimed to find Arthur and Guinevere's graves
  • Latin cross inscription deemed 12th century, not 6th century
  • 1980s excavation found pair of 6th century stone-lined graves
  • Evidence graves disturbed in 12th century
  • Bones gone, but timing matches monks' claims

Knights

  • Sir Bedivere: Appears in non-Arthurian historical writings as Bedwyr Bedrodant, member of Royal House of Dyfed (6th century Wales)
  • Sir Kay: Also possibly real, appears in Welsh warrior poems (Mabinogion)

Arthur Himself

  • Possible candidates:
    • Lucius Artorius Castus (Roman leader)
    • Aurelius Ambrosius (Roman name, possibly Arthur's uncle)
    • Arthwys (Welsh king, 7th century per historian Alan Wilson)
  • Theory: Roman commander sent by Pope to restore order
  • "Arthur" possibly title meaning "bear" in Latin, not personal name
  • Likely compilation of multiple real figures

Story's Enduring Appeal

  • Contains romance, chivalry, classic dramatic elements
  • Monty Python's comedic take helps perpetuate legend
  • Represents idealized peaceful kingdom (Camelot as concept)