AI summary by TwinMind

SYSK’s Summer Movie Playlist: How the MPAA Works | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

43m 2s

Introduction & Context

  • Chuck introduces summer movie playlist feed drop covering MPAA workings
  • Episode from June 2014 exploring "dark art" of movie rating decisions
  • Hosts Josh Clark, Chuck Bryant discussing MPAA practices
  • Referenced documentary "This Film Is Not Yet Rated" as influential critique

PG-13 Rating Creation (1984)

  • Steven Spielberg created PG-13 rating in 1984
  • Two films sparked controversy: Indiana Jones Temple of Doom, Gremlins
    • Both rated PG despite disturbing content (heart removal scene, snake feast, terrifying elements)
  • Spielberg approached MPAA requesting intermediate rating between PG and R
  • PG-13 became the "strike zone" for maximum profitability
    • Targets young teenage boys who bring girls to movies
    • PG-13 films earn more money than all other ratings combined
    • Violence in PG-13 movies tripled over decades
    • Now contains more violence than R-rated counterparts

Historical Development

  • 1922: Motion Picture Association (MPA) formed
  • Will Hayes established Hayes Code (moral/immoral binary system)
    • Government always portrayed positively
    • Sexuality repressed
    • Clear good vs evil divisions
    • Created to prevent local municipalities from banning films

Post-WWII Changes (1950s)

  • Society loosened moral standards after WWII
  • Frank Sinatra Oscar nomination for heroin addict role (The Man with Golden Arm)
  • "Some Like It Hot" (1959) further eroded Hayes Code
  • Hayes Code effectively dead by end of 1950s

Modern Rating System Birth (1968)

  • Ginsburg v. Supreme Court case: store owner prosecuted for selling magazines to minors
  • Supreme Court ruled local municipalities could decide minor exposure standards
  • Jack Valenti (MPAA head for 40 years) created current rating system
  • Original ratings: G, PG, R, X
  • Intended to prevent censorship while protecting profits

Current Rating System (2014)

  • G: General audience, anyone can see
  • PG: No drug use, minimal violence, family-friendly
  • PG-13: Stronger content but accessible to teens
  • R: No one under 17 without parent (suggestion, not law)
  • NC-17: Adults only, replaced X rating in 1990
    • First NC-17 film: "Henry & June"
    • Associated with foreign films, LGBTQ+ content
    • X rating became synonymous with pornography

MPAA Structure & Process

  • Classification and Rating Administration (CARA) operates under MPAA
  • 8-13 anonymous raters overseen by senior rater
  • Raters supposedly parents with children ages 5-17
  • Process conducted in complete secrecy
  • Submission fees: $750 (shorts) to $25,000 (major releases)
  • Voluntary system but de facto mandatory for theater distribution

Rating Process

  • Submit film to anonymous panel
  • Raters watch, take notes, vote on rating
  • Senior rater communicates decision to distributor
  • Options: accept rating, edit film per recommendations, reject and release unrated
  • Appeal process exists but historically unsuccessful
  • Pre-2014: couldn't reference other films during appeals

Major Criticisms & Controversies

Secrecy & Accountability

  • Rater identities completely secret
  • No written standards provided to filmmakers
  • Kirby Dick's documentary exposed fraudulent practices
  • Many raters didn't meet stated requirements (proper age children)

Bias Issues

  • MPAA represents six major studios earning 95% of $10.9 billion annual ticket sales
  • Accused of harsher ratings for independent/foreign films
  • Conflict of interest: rates competitors while lobbying for major studios

Content Double Standards

  • Violence more acceptable than sexuality/profanity
  • Misogynistic bias: male sexual gratification acceptable, female pleasure heavily penalized
  • Homophobic bias: LGBTQ+ content routinely receives harsher ratings
  • Examples of rating inconsistencies:
    • "Once" (Dublin musicians singing) vs "Hostel 2" (torture porn) - both rated R
    • "Rushmore" rated R for brief Playboy centerfolds
    • "Longtime Companion" (gay couple, no explicit content) - NC-17
    • "Blue Is the Warmest Color" (lesbian story) - NC-17
    • "Philomena" (elderly woman searching for son) - R for F-bombs

Marketing Contradictions

  • "Check the Box" descriptions potentially advertise inappropriate content to minors
  • R-rated movies marketed on youth-oriented websites
  • PG-13 movies tied to children's toys despite age-inappropriate content

Anti-Piracy Efforts

  • MPAA serves as lobbying arm against online piracy
  • Digital distribution threatens traditional rating system power
  • Successfully lobbied for Digital Millennium Copyright Act (2000)
  • Cracked down on camcorder recording in theaters
  • Screener DVD tracking systems implemented
  • Public performance licenses required for any non-home viewing
  • Historical opposition to new technology (VCRs in 1980s)

Industry Impact & Future Challenges

  • Theater chains refuse to show unrated films
  • Video on demand/internet distribution bypassing traditional system
  • MPAA losing power while needing it more than ever
  • Filmmakers manipulate system by including intentionally objectionable content as decoys
  • Calls for transparency rather than elimination of ratings
  • Chris Dodd (new MPAA head) defending current system despite criticism

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome