AI summary by TwinMind
Taiwan's 2020 Elections: What You Need to Know
Asianometry
11m 40s
Historical Background of Taiwan Politics
- Kuomintang (KMT) party ruled China proper, founded by Sun Yat-sen, led by Chiang Kai-shek
- KMT led China to victory against Japanese but lost to Mao Zedong's Communist Party
- Over 1 million Chinese retreated to Taiwan island before Communist annihilation
- Taiwan recently ceded back to Chinese government from Japanese after WWII
- KMT leadership took power, suppressed dissent, imposed martial law
- 30 years ago KMT ceded political monopoly after Chiang Kai-shek's son Chiang Ching-kuo died
- Taiwan became democracy, people can now vote for national leaders
Formation of Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)
- New opposition party formed to break KMT monopoly rule
- Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) officially coalesced
- Chiang's hand-picked successor: Lee Teng-hui (native Taiwanese)
- Native Taiwanese = Han Chinese population born on island vs mainland refugees
- Lee handily won 1996 reelection with Communist Party firing missiles in Taiwan Strait
- After Lee stepped down, DPP took advantage of KMT not coalescing around successor
- Chen Shui-bian elected president - historic handover between parties
Chen Shui-bian's Presidency (DPP)
- Administration faced corruption charges
- Deep tensions with US and China over pro-independence stances
- Inability to pass laws due to KMT maintaining hold on legislative branches
- Chen stepped down due to term limits in 2008, later prosecuted for corruption
- DPP hit rock bottom
Ma Ying-jeou's Presidency (KMT)
- KMT candidate Ma Ying-jeou elected president
- Barely won 2012 reelection over DPP candidate Tsai Ing-wen: 52% to 46%
- Came to power promising to revitalize Taiwan's flagging economy
- Communist China reciprocated with economic integrations:
- Direct flights between China and Taiwan
- Tsunami of Chinese tourists
- New free trade deals
- Ceremony between Taiwanese and Chinese presidents (November 2015)
Economic Consequences of Ma's Policies
- Free trade deals benefited economic elites who shifted investments to mainland
- Result: widening economic inequality
- Rich got richer while others foundered
- Taiwan ranks 111th in income inequality (on par with Canada, Poland, Italy, ahead of Japan/US)
- Deep tensions: tens of thousands Taiwanese immigrated to mainland
- Up to 10% of Taiwan's best and brightest work on mainland
- Young people left with stagnant economy struck back
- Sunflower Movement: occupied Taiwanese legislature over trade agreement
- Forced administration to back away from further Taiwan-China economic binding
- By end of presidency, Ma so toxic that 2016 KMT candidate didn't seek his help
2016 Election Results
- Tsai Ing-wen (DPP) elected with commanding majority: 56% of vote
- KMT failed at 31%, third party 12%
- Electoral outcome so certain it was hardly news
- Taiwanese working on mainland didn't bother coming home to vote
- Voter turnout plunged to record low
- KMT legislative majorities annihilated
- Tsai came to power with ability to propose and pass legislation (never happened before in Taiwanese history)
Tsai Ing-wen's Presidency Challenges
- Popularity dropped due to unpopular domestic moves
- Chinese threw fit, withheld economic goodies given to KMT
- Stopped sending tourists
- Took Taiwan's few remaining diplomatic allies (like El Salvador)
- DPP party charter explicitly seeks Taiwan independence
- Tsai pledged to maintain status quo but China threw "hissy fit" anyway
Domestic Issues Under Tsai
- Power outages in major population areas caused huge problems
- Resulted in resignation of one cabinet member
- Brutal during summer when power out (place depends on air conditioning)
- Pension reform legislation cutting pensions for retired military/government workers
- Probably necessary due to low retirement age, tight budgets, generous benefits
- Did not endear her to engaged voter group
- New labor law changing working hours
- Makes young people work even more hours
- Counterintuitive and unnecessary
2018 Midterm Elections and Han Kuo-yu's Rise
- Result of "boneheaded initiatives": DPP dropping in 2018 midterms
- Emergence of KMT challenger Han Kuo-yu
- Han: Taiwanese son of two parents from Hunan
- Served 3 terms as legislator (Taiwan's Congress equivalent)
- 2017: contested KMT party chairmanship, got 5% votes (4th place)
- 2018: won mayorship of Kaohsiung (DPP stronghold for decades)
- Ran with little party support
- Ran on concept of economic development
- Kaohsiung: former industrial heart of Taiwan, economic downturn
- Vast majority workers moved to northern Taiwan or mainland
- Han ran on concept of Kaohsiung becoming rich with little detail
- Said he'd deal with it once in office
- Vague economic promise persuaded desperate former DPP supporters
- Won and sparked "Han Kuo-yu frenzy" - supporters really love him ("pretty Trumpian")
2020 Presidential Campaign
- Han set sights on presidency after 3 months as Kaohsiung mayor
- Beat Terry Gou (Foxconn founder) who started running because sea god Mazu told him to
- Gou backed off after real god showed displeasure
- Han running on campaign of economic revival and change
- Facing incumbent President Tsai
Taiwan Electoral System vs American System
Similarities
- People go to voting stations to vote
Differences
- Must vote at place of household registration (not current residence)
- If born in southern Tainan, must vote there even if working in Taipei for years
- Same for Taiwanese living abroad (including mainland)
- Ironic: Chinese mainlanders encourage Taiwanese workers to return to vote (presuming pro-mainland votes)
- Candidate with plurality wins (no Electoral College)
- No pandering to equivalent of Florida/Ohio
- Candidate with most votes among 23 million people wins
Electoral Analysis and Predictions
- Polls show Han trailing far behind Tsai
- Han needs more votes to beat Tsai (polls say he doesn't have them)
- Taiwanese politics don't follow same divides as America
- Electorate not solidified along party lines like US
- Large contingent of voters don't care for either party, think both trash
- Tend to vote for best candidate (example: Taipei mayor Ko Wen-je, independent)
- Candidate matters more than party
Voter Demographics
- Tsai more popular than Han, especially among younger people
- If in 30s or younger, probably don't like Han
- Han represents "empty headedness and talk without substance" like Trump
- Unpopular with educated voters
- Tsai endeared herself to younger/progressive voters:
- Tough stance on gay marriage (defied recent public referendum)
- Public opposition to Xi Jinping speech advocating "one country, two systems" for Taiwan
China Factor
- China favors KMT in power (supports closer mainland ties)
- CPC created "one country, two systems" policy specifically for Taiwan
- Policy created when island governed by autocratic single party (like Hong Kong)
- Xi Jinping neglected to remember/didn't care how unpopular policy is in Taiwan
- Policy even less popular after 2019 Hong Kong protests
- Saying: Taiwan midterms/local elections about "meat and potato issues"
- National elections about country's relationship with China
- KMT has tough task: China been in news lately "not in good way"
Resources and Conclusion
- Author cannot vote, will "sit and watch with popcorn"
- Recommends Frozen Garlic blog (English blog on Taiwanese elections)
- Written by American professor, great resource
- Elections scheduled for January 11th, 2020
