AI summary by TwinMind

Taiwan's 2020 Elections: What You Need to Know

Asianometry

11m 40s

Historical Background of Taiwan Politics

  • Kuomintang (KMT) party ruled China proper, founded by Sun Yat-sen, led by Chiang Kai-shek
  • KMT led China to victory against Japanese but lost to Mao Zedong's Communist Party
  • Over 1 million Chinese retreated to Taiwan island before Communist annihilation
  • Taiwan recently ceded back to Chinese government from Japanese after WWII
  • KMT leadership took power, suppressed dissent, imposed martial law
  • 30 years ago KMT ceded political monopoly after Chiang Kai-shek's son Chiang Ching-kuo died
  • Taiwan became democracy, people can now vote for national leaders

Formation of Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)

  • New opposition party formed to break KMT monopoly rule
  • Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) officially coalesced
  • Chiang's hand-picked successor: Lee Teng-hui (native Taiwanese)
    • Native Taiwanese = Han Chinese population born on island vs mainland refugees
  • Lee handily won 1996 reelection with Communist Party firing missiles in Taiwan Strait
  • After Lee stepped down, DPP took advantage of KMT not coalescing around successor
  • Chen Shui-bian elected president - historic handover between parties

Chen Shui-bian's Presidency (DPP)

  • Administration faced corruption charges
  • Deep tensions with US and China over pro-independence stances
  • Inability to pass laws due to KMT maintaining hold on legislative branches
  • Chen stepped down due to term limits in 2008, later prosecuted for corruption
  • DPP hit rock bottom

Ma Ying-jeou's Presidency (KMT)

  • KMT candidate Ma Ying-jeou elected president
  • Barely won 2012 reelection over DPP candidate Tsai Ing-wen: 52% to 46%
  • Came to power promising to revitalize Taiwan's flagging economy
  • Communist China reciprocated with economic integrations:
    • Direct flights between China and Taiwan
    • Tsunami of Chinese tourists
    • New free trade deals
    • Ceremony between Taiwanese and Chinese presidents (November 2015)

Economic Consequences of Ma's Policies

  • Free trade deals benefited economic elites who shifted investments to mainland
  • Result: widening economic inequality
  • Rich got richer while others foundered
  • Taiwan ranks 111th in income inequality (on par with Canada, Poland, Italy, ahead of Japan/US)
  • Deep tensions: tens of thousands Taiwanese immigrated to mainland
  • Up to 10% of Taiwan's best and brightest work on mainland
  • Young people left with stagnant economy struck back
  • Sunflower Movement: occupied Taiwanese legislature over trade agreement
  • Forced administration to back away from further Taiwan-China economic binding
  • By end of presidency, Ma so toxic that 2016 KMT candidate didn't seek his help

2016 Election Results

  • Tsai Ing-wen (DPP) elected with commanding majority: 56% of vote
  • KMT failed at 31%, third party 12%
  • Electoral outcome so certain it was hardly news
  • Taiwanese working on mainland didn't bother coming home to vote
  • Voter turnout plunged to record low
  • KMT legislative majorities annihilated
  • Tsai came to power with ability to propose and pass legislation (never happened before in Taiwanese history)

Tsai Ing-wen's Presidency Challenges

  • Popularity dropped due to unpopular domestic moves
  • Chinese threw fit, withheld economic goodies given to KMT
    • Stopped sending tourists
    • Took Taiwan's few remaining diplomatic allies (like El Salvador)
  • DPP party charter explicitly seeks Taiwan independence
  • Tsai pledged to maintain status quo but China threw "hissy fit" anyway

Domestic Issues Under Tsai

  • Power outages in major population areas caused huge problems
    • Resulted in resignation of one cabinet member
    • Brutal during summer when power out (place depends on air conditioning)
  • Pension reform legislation cutting pensions for retired military/government workers
    • Probably necessary due to low retirement age, tight budgets, generous benefits
    • Did not endear her to engaged voter group
  • New labor law changing working hours
    • Makes young people work even more hours
    • Counterintuitive and unnecessary

2018 Midterm Elections and Han Kuo-yu's Rise

  • Result of "boneheaded initiatives": DPP dropping in 2018 midterms
  • Emergence of KMT challenger Han Kuo-yu
  • Han: Taiwanese son of two parents from Hunan
  • Served 3 terms as legislator (Taiwan's Congress equivalent)
  • 2017: contested KMT party chairmanship, got 5% votes (4th place)
  • 2018: won mayorship of Kaohsiung (DPP stronghold for decades)
    • Ran with little party support
    • Ran on concept of economic development
    • Kaohsiung: former industrial heart of Taiwan, economic downturn
    • Vast majority workers moved to northern Taiwan or mainland
  • Han ran on concept of Kaohsiung becoming rich with little detail
  • Said he'd deal with it once in office
  • Vague economic promise persuaded desperate former DPP supporters
  • Won and sparked "Han Kuo-yu frenzy" - supporters really love him ("pretty Trumpian")

2020 Presidential Campaign

  • Han set sights on presidency after 3 months as Kaohsiung mayor
  • Beat Terry Gou (Foxconn founder) who started running because sea god Mazu told him to
  • Gou backed off after real god showed displeasure
  • Han running on campaign of economic revival and change
  • Facing incumbent President Tsai

Taiwan Electoral System vs American System

Similarities

  • People go to voting stations to vote

Differences

  • Must vote at place of household registration (not current residence)
  • If born in southern Tainan, must vote there even if working in Taipei for years
  • Same for Taiwanese living abroad (including mainland)
  • Ironic: Chinese mainlanders encourage Taiwanese workers to return to vote (presuming pro-mainland votes)
  • Candidate with plurality wins (no Electoral College)
  • No pandering to equivalent of Florida/Ohio
  • Candidate with most votes among 23 million people wins

Electoral Analysis and Predictions

  • Polls show Han trailing far behind Tsai
  • Han needs more votes to beat Tsai (polls say he doesn't have them)
  • Taiwanese politics don't follow same divides as America
  • Electorate not solidified along party lines like US
  • Large contingent of voters don't care for either party, think both trash
  • Tend to vote for best candidate (example: Taipei mayor Ko Wen-je, independent)
  • Candidate matters more than party

Voter Demographics

  • Tsai more popular than Han, especially among younger people
  • If in 30s or younger, probably don't like Han
  • Han represents "empty headedness and talk without substance" like Trump
  • Unpopular with educated voters
  • Tsai endeared herself to younger/progressive voters:
    • Tough stance on gay marriage (defied recent public referendum)
    • Public opposition to Xi Jinping speech advocating "one country, two systems" for Taiwan

China Factor

  • China favors KMT in power (supports closer mainland ties)
  • CPC created "one country, two systems" policy specifically for Taiwan
  • Policy created when island governed by autocratic single party (like Hong Kong)
  • Xi Jinping neglected to remember/didn't care how unpopular policy is in Taiwan
  • Policy even less popular after 2019 Hong Kong protests
  • Saying: Taiwan midterms/local elections about "meat and potato issues"
  • National elections about country's relationship with China
  • KMT has tough task: China been in news lately "not in good way"

Resources and Conclusion

  • Author cannot vote, will "sit and watch with popcorn"
  • Recommends Frozen Garlic blog (English blog on Taiwanese elections)
  • Written by American professor, great resource
  • Elections scheduled for January 11th, 2020

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome