AI summary by TwinMind
The 3 possible outcomes of the 2022 US election
Vox
7m 42s
Election Overview
- November 8th: 475 separate Federal elections in US
- Results determine control of two houses of Congress
- Post-2020: Democrats controlled House, Senate, and presidency
- Three bodies must align to make new laws
- Even split government gives each body tremendous individual power
Scenario 1: Democrats Keep Both Houses
- Not considered most likely outcome
- Reporter: Lee Zhou, Vox politics reporter, 6+ years covering Capitol Hill
- Democratic achievements possible with continued control:
- Codify Roe v Wade into federal law (national abortion protection)
- Paid Family Leave
- Child care subsidies
- Universal Pre-K
- Pro Act (protects organizing/unionizing rights)
- Filibuster obstacle:
- Senate rule requires 60/100 votes (not 51/100) to pass laws
- Democrats have narrow majority but only 48 willing to change filibuster rules
- Need 52 senators (magic number) to change rules and pass legislation
Scenario 2: Republicans Win House Only
- Reporter: Still Matthews, Fox reporter
- House powers when controlled by opposition party:
- Significant leverage over presidency/Senate
- Control investigations, committees, subpoenas
- Force testimony, obtain documents
- Historical precedent - GOP investigations:
- 2011+ GOP majority extensively investigated Obama Administration
- Fast and Furious gun smuggling scandal
- Benghazi scandal (2012 attacks)
- Democratic precedent:
- 2018 Democrat win led to Trump Administration investigations
- Culminated in first impeachment
- Debt ceiling leverage:
- 2011 debt ceiling fight example
- Debt ceiling = limit on federal government borrowing
- US treasury bonds foundation of international financial system
- Breaching ceiling makes bonds high-risk asset
- Would increase investment/borrowing costs globally
- Major financial crisis potential
- 2011 outcome: $2.1 trillion in cuts
- National parks, Head Start programs
- FBI, National Institutes of Health
- National Science Foundation
- Pandemic prevention budget cuts
- Current Congress expected to be more hardline
Scenario 3: Republicans Win House and Senate
- Reporter: Ian Millhiser, Vox lawyer covering Supreme Court
- Federal judge confirmation power:
- Senate must confirm all federal judges
- President nominates, Senate majority votes to confirm
- 800+ active federal judges total
- District judges (try cases)
- Court of appeals/circuit judges
- Supreme Court justices
- Historical precedent (2015-2016):
- Democratic president (Obama) + Republican Senate
- GOP Senate blocked Supreme Court confirmations
- Blocked nearly all court of appeals confirmations
- Held seats open until Trump took office
- Filled with Republican appointees
- Trump judges' impact:
- Overruled Roe v Wade (abortion now illegal in many states)
- Sweeping Second Amendment reinterpretation
- Striking down gun laws extensively
- Wholesale attack on voting rights
- Attacked Voting Rights Act (prevents race discrimination)
- Three Trump judges declared Consumer Financial Protection Bureau unconstitutional
- Republican strategy:
- Hold judicial seats vacant during Democratic presidency
- Fill when Republican president in office
- Judiciary provides permanent veto power over laws/regulations
- Control regardless of White House/Congress control
- Voting rights concerns:
- Targeting voting rights aggressively
- Without voting rights, citizens lose all recourse
- Disenfranchised voters cannot change government control
- Government controlled by those not sharing their interests
- Current status: Elections still best method to reverse democratic decline
Election Reality
- Out of 475 House/Senate elections, most not close races
- Real decision made by small subset of competitive races
- Only ~1/7 House elections competitive
- Handful of competitive Senate races
- Voters in competitive districts have disproportionate power over outcome
