AI summary by TwinMind

The 3-D Transistor Transition

Asianometry

14m 18s

Historical Context and Industry Transition

  • 2011: Intel and leading semiconductor industry made remarkable technical transition to 3D transistors
  • First time producing transistors in three dimensions - thin field effect transistor (FinFET)
  • Transition took over 10 years in the making
  • Industry building block for decades: metal oxide semiconductor field effect transistor (MOSFET)
    • Common in digital circuits: inverters, NAND gates, SRAM cells
    • Components: gate sitting on top of channel connecting source and drain
    • Source/drain: silicon regions doped with other elements to donate/receive electrons
    • Thin insulating layer between gate and channel (usually silicon oxide)
    • Gate doesn't cut through channel - whole structure is flat/planar

Classical Scaling Era and Dennard Scaling

  • First few decades: new process nodes delivered performance, power, area gains by shrinking transistor dimensions
  • Classical scaling: cramming more transistors onto chip
  • Benefits: electric signals had less distance to travel between transistors
  • 1974: IBM researcher Robert Dennard identified secondary benefit - smaller transistors used less power
  • Moore's Law: reduce transistor linear dimensions by half every 3 years
  • 1980s: dimensions fell under 1 micron for first time

Short Channel Effect and Industry Crisis

  • Mid-1990s (350nm process): transistors started acting "funny"
  • Physical dimensions shrinking caused problems:
    • Source and drain getting closer together
    • Insulating layer getting thinner (1.2nm at one point - 5 atoms wide)
    • Channel itself getting thinner
  • Gate's control over current flow weakened
  • Short channel effect: current "dives under the gate" like rabbit burrowing
  • Current could sneak from source to drain even with gate closed
  • Could travel through channel part furthest from gate or through silicon substrate
  • Serious power consumption issues - leakage meant smaller transistors didn't follow Dennard scaling
  • Transistors would consume as much energy in off state as during on state
  • Consumer electronics becoming more portable - higher power efficiency demands

Industry Response and DARPA Initiative

  • Classical MOSFET structure had final endpoint - practical size limit at ~20nm
  • 1996: Leading edge at 259nm, DARPA aware industry had no long-term plan beyond 2002
  • DARPA called for proposals on sub-25nm devices - "25 nanometer switch"
  • Received 10-12 proposals from IBM, AT&T, Stanford
  • All were mere extensions of original MOSFET structure
  • DARPA wanted something ambitious and feasible

UC Berkeley's Winning Proposal

  • Winner: University of California Berkeley team led by Professor Hu Chenming
  • Hu joined Berkeley 1976, initially studied energy/hybrid cars
  • Government funding dried up after Reagan administration, pivoted to semiconductor research
  • 1982: sabbatical at National Semiconductor, saw coming end of planar transistor
  • Proposal created over span of one week
  • Title: "Novel fabrication device structures and the physics of 25 nanometer FETs for terabit scale electronics"

Two Key Ideas from Berkeley Proposal

Fully Depleted Silicon on Insulator (FDSOI)

  • Problem: electrons inappropriately traveling using silicon substrate
  • Solution: add new insulation layer on top of silicon substrate
  • Became moderately successful for specific uses (analog, power electronics)

FinFET Concept

  • Sketched by Professor Hu during long flight
  • Focus: allow gate better control over channel
  • Traditional planar: source, drain, channel are flat with gate on top
  • FinFET: turns planar structure onto its side, rises above surrounding area
  • 3D shark fin appearance gives it name
  • Gate wraps around top and sides of channel vs just sitting on top
  • Primary benefit: gate wraps around channel on three sides vs one side for planar
  • Smaller physical footprint - can stuff more onto same real estate

Historical Precedents

  • Idea not entirely new - two similar proposals made before but never implemented
  • 1990: D. Hisamoto at Hitachi proposed wrapping gate around channel
    • Called it "fully depleted lean channeled transistor" or Delta
  • 1980s: Texas Instruments paper called for "trench transistor"
  • Concept useless without execution - nobody knew if could scale to 25nm or smaller

DARPA Development Phase

  • 4 years prototyping working FinFET device with DARPA financial backing
  • Team had freedom for long-term goal + ability to draw on private/public resources
  • Used equipment/facilities at Stanford and Lawrence Berkeley National Lab
  • 2001: DARPA project completed, team published results
  • FinFET recognized as tremendously innovative but not too disruptive
  • Traditional lithographic and etching tools could still be used
  • Industry could get better performance/power efficiency without abandoning billions in equipment/decades of experience

Industry Adoption Delays and Interim Solutions

  • Conservative semiconductor industry didn't immediately adopt FinFET
  • Opted for short-term measures to extend MOSFET life

Strain/Stress-Based Engineering (90-45nm nodes, early 2000s)

  • Added layers of "strained silicon" to channel
  • Usually on top of silicon germanium buffer layer
  • Strained = silicon crystal atoms being stretched
  • Helped electrons travel faster across channel
  • Required growing strained silicon layers using epitaxy

High-K Metal Gate (28nm node, 2009-2010)

  • Replaced silicon dioxide insulating layer with high-K metal (hafnium oxide)
  • High-K (relative to silicon dioxide) kept opposing charges apart
  • Led to "gate first vs gate last" dilemma splitting industry
  • Caused semiconductor manufacturers to drop off leading edge
  • Benefit was one-time only - needed new solution after 28nm

Intel's FinFET Implementation

  • 22nm node: Intel implemented 3D device called "tri-gate transistor"
  • Descendant of original FinFET
  • Original had two gates on sidewalls (double gate FinFET)
  • Intel's version: three gate layers on all three exposed sides of fin
  • Most people still refer to them as FinFETs

Manufacturing Challenges

  • Prototype to mass production always challenging
  • Critical parameters:
    • Fin geometry (height, etc.)
    • Fin pitch (spacing between fins) ~60nm
    • 22nm process: fin just 10nm wide
  • Millions of nanoscale fins fabricated with extremely little variation
  • New multi-patterning techniques required
  • All foundries struggled with scaling first FinFET products, yield issues, delays

Industry Adoption Timeline

  • 2013: TSMC and Samsung jumped to FinFET (16nm and 14nm processes)
  • 2014: GlobalFoundries joined with 14nm process (licensed from Samsung)
  • FinFET worked well through N7 and N5 generations
  • Recently losing effectiveness at smaller nodes

Current Transition to Gate-All-Around

  • Industry decided on gate-all-around as new architecture
  • FinFET worked by covering more surface area - gate-all-around takes further
  • Completely surrounds channel including bottom
  • Can stack multiple channels/nanowires on top of each other through gate
  • June 2022: Samsung started shipping 3nm process with gate-all-around
  • TSMC sticking with FinFETs for N3 but adopting gate-all-around for N2 (under construction in Baoshan)

Economic Challenges

  • 3D transistors are technical marvels but expensive
  • FinFET's intricate construction: 28nm (last with planar gates) = point where cost per gate stops declining, starts rising
  • Gate-all-around accelerates cost trend further
  • Challenge: building gaps between nanowires when can only etch downward
  • Solution involves super lattices and atomic layer deposition methodology
  • Leading edge becoming economically infeasible for all but biggest companies
  • ASML CTO: reaching end of lithography not due to technology but economic feasibility
  • Can always develop next structure but question is who can pay for it

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome