AI summary by TwinMind
The Apache Wars | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 25s
Apache Background and Structure
- Apache not single nation/tribe - loosely affiliated tribes from western Canada (BC)
- Called themselves "inde" (the people), "Apache" likely from Zuni word meaning "enemy"
- Spread over 15 million square miles with small population
- Western Apache and Chiricahua Apache main groups
- Chiricahua divided into 4 bands: Bedonkohe, Chokonen, Chihenne, Nednhi
- Total Chiricahua population ~1,500 at peak
- Lived in groups of 25-30 people, family-based, matrilineal society
- Produced famous leaders: Geronimo, Cochise, Victorio
Apache Lifestyle and Relations
- Raiding for economic necessity vs. warfare for revenge
- United hatred of Mexico/Spanish - brutal mutual killings
- Chief Mangus Coloradus offered alliance with Americans against Mexico in 1846
- Seasonal migrants, prime territory south of Gila River, Arizona
- Stage set for conflict due to westward expansion, Civil War troop movements
Bascom Affair (1861) - War Catalyst
- Aravapa Apache raided John Ward's farm, kidnapped stepson Felix Ward
- Lieutenant George Bascom (young, inexperienced) sent to negotiate
- Invited Cochise to meeting, accused him despite no involvement
- Cochise offered to find real culprits, Bascom refused
- Bascom held Cochise's family hostage, Cochise escaped
- Cochise captured American hostages, killed Mexican hostages immediately
- Failed hostage exchange negotiations
- Both sides executed hostages - Cochise's favorite brother killed
- Many consider this start of Apache Wars
Mangus Coloradus Death (1863)
- Respected chief who wanted American alliance invited to "peace talks"
- Actually ruse - was captured and executed
- Body grossly mutilated: head cut off, skull boiled, sent to phrenologist in New York
- Showed Americans couldn't be trusted for peace negotiations
- Killed major stabilizing influence among Chiricahua
Civil War Period Fighting
- Union soldiers came west to prevent Confederate control
- Apache raided military supplies and munitions
- 1862 battle typical: Apache retreat as tactic, not defeat
- Apache knowledge of terrain made them nearly impossible to find
- Other Apache groups worked as scouts against Chiricahua
- Confederate soldier actually buried in Arizona from Apache skirmishes
Camp Grant Massacre (1871)
- Aravapa Chief Eskiminzin's people camped peacefully near Tucson army post
- Tucson residents preemptively massacred Apache
- 144 killed, only 8 survivors, mostly women and children
- 27 children kidnapped, sold into slavery to affluent Tucson families
- President Grant furious, threatened martial law in Arizona
- Sent peace delegation to negotiate with Cochise
First Peace Treaty (1871-1875)
- Grant offered truce: move to San Carlos reservation ("Hell's 40 Acres")
- Cochise negotiated separate reservation for Chiricahua with freedom to travel
- Peace lasted ~4 years until Cochise died of stomach cancer
- Treaty violations: two Chiricahua killed white men over whiskey
- Continued raids in Mexico (treaty oversight)
- Death of Cochise weakened peace accord
Second Apache Wars Begin (1875)
- Cochise's son Taza took leadership
- Government abolished Chiricahua reservation, demanded move to San Carlos
- Choice: San Carlos reservation or life on the run
- Taza chose peace, ~1/3 followed him to San Carlos
- 2/3 chose fighting with Geronimo and Chief Juh
- Geronimo served as proxy negotiator for stuttering Chief Juh
Geronimo's Background and Leadership
- Real name: Goyakala, medicine man for Bedonkohe band
- Nickname "Geronimo" from Mexicans (origin unknown, rare Italian form of Jerome)
- Mexicans shouted name during his raids
- Deep trauma: watched Mexicans slaughter mother, wife, children
- Never forgave Mexicans, killed them whenever possible
- Known as "worst Indian that ever lived" to Americans
- Fierce close-combat fighter, charged enemies in zigzag pattern
- Never actually a chief, but became influential leader
- Complicated relationship with own people - sometimes criticized for recklessness
Victorio's War (Concurrent Conflict)
- Chihenne Chief Victorio forced from Ojo Caliente reservation
- Geronimo's escape brought attention to their peaceful settlement
- Given ultimatum: San Carlos or death
- Victorio chose fighting, led 2-year concurrent war with 150 warriors
- Sister Lozen: "Apache Joan of Arc," medicine woman, strategist, fighter
- Lozen claimed mystical ability to sense enemy direction/distance through hand ritual
- Mexico-US cooperation against Victorio (unprecedented)
- Victorio killed by Mexicans when Lozen absent (helping new mother)
- Lozen joined Geronimo after brother's death
General George Crook ("Tan Wolf")
- Respected by Apache, earned name fighting Sioux with Custer
- Skilled tracker, repeatedly found Geronimo in Mexico
- Accidentally stumbled upon Geronimo's camp while hunting alone
- Geronimo chose not to kill him, led to negotiations
- Mutual respect enabled productive talks
Geronimo's Surrenders and Escapes
- Surrendered 4 times total, escaped 4 times
- Hated across America, editorials called for execution
- Weakness for alcohol - when drunk, convinced people would kill him
- Crook negotiated Turkey Creek reservation (Geronimo's birthplace)
- Pattern: better reservation offers accepted, San Carlos offers rejected
Final Campaign (1886)
- President Cleveland: unconditional surrender or death
- Crook resigned over harsh terms, replaced by General Nelson Miles
- $25,000 bounty on Geronimo's head
- Miles had no respect for Apache, led from distant forts
- Final band: only 37 free Chiricahua (18 warriors, 13 women, 6 children)
- Evaded 8,000-10,000 US/Mexican troops for 5 months
- Only 1 death in final summer of freedom
Final Surrender and Aftermath
- Miles used family separation as leverage
- 434 Chiricahua on San Carlos shipped to Florida prison
- Geronimo surrendered to reunite with family
- Negotiated 2-year exile terms, but never honored
- Never returned to ancestral lands despite promises
Post-War Life and Death
- Reunited with family in Alabama, moved to Oklahoma
- 27 years before any Chiricahua allowed to return to ancestral lands
- 1/3 stayed in Oklahoma (Fort Sill), 2/3 moved to Mescalero reservation
- Geronimo became celebrity: toured with Buffalo Bill, sold trinkets
- Rode in Teddy Roosevelt's election parade
- Asked Roosevelt for permission to return home - refused
- Died at Fort Sill (1909) from pneumonia after falling off horse while drunk
- Regretted not fighting to death
War Assessment
- Longest war in US history (25 years)
- 1,500 Chiricahua fought both US and Mexican armies simultaneously
- William Tecumseh Sherman: "We had one war with Mexico to take Arizona and we should have another war to make them take it back"
- Modern Chiricahua tribe identifies as peaceful - peace faction ultimately prevailed
