AI summary by TwinMind
The Ballad of Grit | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 42s
Introduction and Grit Definition
- Josh and Chuck discuss concept of "grit" - not food grits, but psychological trait
- Grit = determination, perseverance, stick-to-itiveness
- Josh takes critical stance on educational applications
- Chuck notes nuanced view of topic
Origins of Grit Research
- Started with University of Pennsylvania psychologist Angela Duckworth
- Former math teacher who noticed lower-IQ students sometimes outperformed higher-IQ peers
- Observed thread of perseverance in successful students
- Led to graduate psychology studies at UPenn
- Developed concept that grit could be tested and possibly taught
2007 Breakthrough Study
- Duckworth published landmark paper in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
- Studied 1,500+ high-achieving adults and students
- Test groups: West Point cadets, National Spelling Bee participants, Ivy League students
- Found grit scale predicted success better than other factors
- Two main components: consistency of interests + perseverance of effort
- Distinguished from conscientiousness by emphasizing long-term commitment
Media Explosion and Paul Tough
- Study became "summer blockbuster" of academic articles
- 150+ academic articles on grit within decade
- Duckworth's 20 publications cited 60,000+ times (vs. 200 average)
- Journalist Paul Tough championed concept
- Wrote "How Children Succeed" (2012) before Duckworth's book
- Promoted "non-cognitive skills" and character building in schools
Policy Implementation Timeline
- 2007: Initial paper suggests grit "may be teachable"
- Early 2010s: Shift from No Child Left Behind to social-emotional learning (SEL)
- 2015: Obama's Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) replaced NCLB
- Required states to include non-academic outcomes in accountability
- Mandated block grants for SEL programs
- Duckworth became federal education consultant
California Pilot Program Disaster
- California tied school funding to student grit scores
- Used 10-15 point grit questionnaire for assessment
- Questions like "I finish whatever I start" and "My interests change year to year"
- Teacher evaluations and school funding based on student grit levels
- Duckworth opposed high-stakes character assessment
- Condemned the approach in New York Times op-eds
Major Criticisms
Academic Criticisms:
- Grit essentially same as conscientiousness (Big Five personality trait)
- Self-reporting tests problematic, especially for children
- Low-income students under-report grittiness despite showing more actual grit
- East Asian students score low on self-reports but high on objective measures
- 2016 studies: only 0.5% exam score variance attributable to grit
- 95% variance shared between grit and conscientiousness
Deficit Thinking Problem:
- Assumes single "normal" standard all should aspire to
- Blames individual students for systemic problems
- Removes pressure to fix underfunded schools, bad teachers
- "Bootstrap" mentality ignores structural inequalities
- Fifth child of single mom with three jobs needs grit, not resources
Developmental Issues:
- Assessing character of 8-year-olds inappropriate
- Normal for children to change interests frequently
- Teaches never to quit anything vs. learning what's worth pursuing
- May create automatons who persevere without passion
Political Backlash
- Conservative opposition mixed grit with critical race theory concerns
- Resistance to schools teaching behavior/character vs. academics only
- Some legitimate concerns about government role in character education
- Grit caught up in broader SEL and progressive education debates
Current Status and Duckworth's Response
- Duckworth: "enthusiasm getting ahead of science" (2015 NPR)
- Opposed high-stakes character assessment in schools
- Maintains grit is real but distinct from conscientiousness
- Continues research despite criticism and personal attacks
- Concept still used in education though less prominent
Alternative Approaches
- Harvard's Jal Mehta: Focus on inspiring passion, not forcing perseverance
- Schools should change curricula to engage students
- Kids show natural grit for things they care about (relationships, sports)
- Need to make academics as compelling as personal interests
- Passion-driven learning more effective than forced persistence
