AI summary by TwinMind

The Ballad of Grit | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

50m 42s

Introduction and Grit Definition

  • Josh and Chuck discuss concept of "grit" - not food grits, but psychological trait
  • Grit = determination, perseverance, stick-to-itiveness
  • Josh takes critical stance on educational applications
  • Chuck notes nuanced view of topic

Origins of Grit Research

  • Started with University of Pennsylvania psychologist Angela Duckworth
  • Former math teacher who noticed lower-IQ students sometimes outperformed higher-IQ peers
  • Observed thread of perseverance in successful students
  • Led to graduate psychology studies at UPenn
  • Developed concept that grit could be tested and possibly taught

2007 Breakthrough Study

  • Duckworth published landmark paper in Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
  • Studied 1,500+ high-achieving adults and students
  • Test groups: West Point cadets, National Spelling Bee participants, Ivy League students
  • Found grit scale predicted success better than other factors
  • Two main components: consistency of interests + perseverance of effort
  • Distinguished from conscientiousness by emphasizing long-term commitment

Media Explosion and Paul Tough

  • Study became "summer blockbuster" of academic articles
  • 150+ academic articles on grit within decade
  • Duckworth's 20 publications cited 60,000+ times (vs. 200 average)
  • Journalist Paul Tough championed concept
  • Wrote "How Children Succeed" (2012) before Duckworth's book
  • Promoted "non-cognitive skills" and character building in schools

Policy Implementation Timeline

  • 2007: Initial paper suggests grit "may be teachable"
  • Early 2010s: Shift from No Child Left Behind to social-emotional learning (SEL)
  • 2015: Obama's Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) replaced NCLB
  • Required states to include non-academic outcomes in accountability
  • Mandated block grants for SEL programs
  • Duckworth became federal education consultant

California Pilot Program Disaster

  • California tied school funding to student grit scores
  • Used 10-15 point grit questionnaire for assessment
  • Questions like "I finish whatever I start" and "My interests change year to year"
  • Teacher evaluations and school funding based on student grit levels
  • Duckworth opposed high-stakes character assessment
  • Condemned the approach in New York Times op-eds

Major Criticisms

Academic Criticisms:

  • Grit essentially same as conscientiousness (Big Five personality trait)
  • Self-reporting tests problematic, especially for children
  • Low-income students under-report grittiness despite showing more actual grit
  • East Asian students score low on self-reports but high on objective measures
  • 2016 studies: only 0.5% exam score variance attributable to grit
  • 95% variance shared between grit and conscientiousness

Deficit Thinking Problem:

  • Assumes single "normal" standard all should aspire to
  • Blames individual students for systemic problems
  • Removes pressure to fix underfunded schools, bad teachers
  • "Bootstrap" mentality ignores structural inequalities
  • Fifth child of single mom with three jobs needs grit, not resources

Developmental Issues:

  • Assessing character of 8-year-olds inappropriate
  • Normal for children to change interests frequently
  • Teaches never to quit anything vs. learning what's worth pursuing
  • May create automatons who persevere without passion

Political Backlash

  • Conservative opposition mixed grit with critical race theory concerns
  • Resistance to schools teaching behavior/character vs. academics only
  • Some legitimate concerns about government role in character education
  • Grit caught up in broader SEL and progressive education debates

Current Status and Duckworth's Response

  • Duckworth: "enthusiasm getting ahead of science" (2015 NPR)
  • Opposed high-stakes character assessment in schools
  • Maintains grit is real but distinct from conscientiousness
  • Continues research despite criticism and personal attacks
  • Concept still used in education though less prominent

Alternative Approaches

  • Harvard's Jal Mehta: Focus on inspiring passion, not forcing perseverance
  • Schools should change curricula to engage students
  • Kids show natural grit for things they care about (relationships, sports)
  • Need to make academics as compelling as personal interests
  • Passion-driven learning more effective than forced persistence

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome