AI summary by TwinMind
The beauty and complexity of finding common ground | Matt Trombley
TED
14m 0s
Personal Story and Introduction to Agonism
- Speaker and wife received anonymous complaint letter about their family
- Neighbor assumed they ran illegal daycare seeing adopted children (who looked different) playing outside
- Wife transformed from peaceful to "angry mother grizzly bear"
- Family consists of speaker, wife, and 5 children (2 adopted)
- Incident represents minor racial profiling example
- Introduces concept of agonism: "taking a warlike stance in contexts that are not literally war"
- Comes from Greek root "agon" (same as "agony")
- Contagious condition affecting relationships
Two Beliefs That Create Agonism
- First belief: "If we love someone we must agree with all they do or believe"
- Second belief: "If we disagree with someone it must mean we fear or hate them"
- These beliefs identified by author Rick Warren
- Result: relationships die because people think they must agree or disagree completely
- Examples of divisive topics: Brexit, Hong Kong, Israeli settlements, impeachment
- Challenge: personal relationships strained/ended over these topics
Strategy 1: Cultivate Common Ground
- Definition: focusing on what we share, not total agreement
- Requires intentional work (like farmer cultivating soil)
- Goal: find one unifying thing for relationship foundation
- Sometimes difficult to find but essential for connection
Personal Example: Gender Fluidity and Faith
- Speaker identifies as: Caucasian, cisgender male, middle class, evangelical Christian
- Acknowledges audience may have perceptions about these identities
- Challenge: finding common ground on gender fluidity as evangelical Christian
- Traditional belief: God created man and woman
- Foundational aspects of faith provide common ground:
- 3 billion genes make us human (99.9% shared)
- Believes genes result from intelligent designer
- Gives common ground with anyone
- Each person has right to life from same designer
- Faith teaches starting relationships with love, not argument
- Practical application: using preferred pronouns
- Muhammad Ali example: would address as Muhammad Ali, not Cassius Clay
- Honoring someone's chosen name costs nothing
- Doesn't require converting to their beliefs
- Creates common ground for relationship
Strategy 2: Exchange Extravagant Grace
- Definition: not canceling everything over one mistake
- Quote from Holocaust survivor Corrie ten Boom: "To forgive is to set a prisoner free only to realize that prisoner was me"
- Speaker's faith perspective: humans will never be perfect, need grace from savior (Jesus)
- Alternative definition by radio broadcaster Oswald Huffman: "Grace is the love that loves the unlovely and the unlovable"
- Hypocrisy of accepting unconditional grace from God while putting preconditions on love given to others
- "Extravagant" means over-the-top, not just checking boxes
- Choosing to give grace, not being forced to
Hero of Grace Story (Iran, 2014)
- Samara Allen Ahad: mother of murdered son
- Murderer in public square with noose, blindfold
- Under country's laws, she had sole right to pardon or execute
- Could literally push chair from under his feet
- Murderer weeping, begging forgiveness
- Samara chose to slap him (signaling pardon)
- Her quote: "I felt as if rage vanished from within my heart and the blood in my veins began to flow again"
- Theologian John Piper: "Grace is power not just pardon"
- Grace says relationship more important than things that separate us
- Everyone has power to execute or pardon in relationships
Conclusion and Call to Action
- Never found identity of anonymous neighbor
- If they did, would simply ask "can we have coffee"
- Two strategies taught speaker to exchange extravagant grace and enjoy neighbors' beautiful design
- Chooses relationships over agonism
- Invites audience to join him in this choice
