AI summary by TwinMind
The Big Problem with NASA's Monster SLS Rocket
Newsthink
5m 47s
NASA SLS Background and Timeline
- 50+ years since last crewed moon mission
- SLS arrived at Kennedy Space Center launch pad 39B
- Famous for height and delays
- Originally promised launch 2017, postponed repeatedly
- Maiden voyage (uncrewed) scheduled summer (of recording)
- Setting stage for America's moon return by 2025
- May be beginning of end for SLS program
SLS Cost Analysis
- Single SLS + Orion launch cost: $4.1 billion
- NASA Inspector General Paul Martin called cost "unsustainable"
- 8x higher than NASA's original $500 million per launch estimate
- High cost due to non-reusable design
- Drops boosters and core stage after fuel burn (like hiker dropping backpack)
Economic and Political Justification
- Former Senator Bill Nelson (current NASA Administrator) describes as "economic engine for America"
- 2019: supported 70,000 good-paying jobs across country
- Spending reminiscent of 1960s-70s NASA operations
- Apollo program: flew 24 astronauts to moon
- Historical context: Cold War political statement vs Soviet Union
- Current goal different: establishing permanent lunar/Mars presence
Bush Administration Moon Strategy (2004)
- President Bush directed NASA moon return
- Goal: living and working on moon for extended periods
- Establishing presence on moon, eventually Mars
Industry Predictions and Competition
- Former NASA Administrator Charles Bolden (2020 Politico interview): predicted SLS "will go away"
- Could end during Biden or next Trump administration
- Commercial entities catching up
SpaceX Starship Comparison
- Developing giant Starship for moon/Mars missions
- Taller than all planned SLS models (Block 1 cargo through Block 2 cargo)
- Higher payload capacity to low Earth orbit
- Cost difference: Starship $2 million per mission vs SLS $4.1 billion
- Fully reusable: both Super Heavy booster and Starship upper stage
- NASA chose Starship for final lunar landing leg
Current NASA-SpaceX Partnership Plan
- SLS lifts Orion spacecraft, escapes Earth gravity
- Orion meets modified lunar Starship in lunar orbit
- Crew transfers to Starship for moon surface landing
- Return: Starship lifts off, meets Orion in lunar orbit
- Crew transfers back to Orion for Earth return
Alternative Starship-Only Mission Profile
- Starship launches, meets another Starship for refueling
- Continues to moon without SLS/Orion
- Non-lunar model retains heat shield and landing flaps for Earth return
Other Commercial Players
- Blue Origin getting second chance at NASA moon landing contract
- Jeff Bezos's company developing New Glenn heavy lift vehicle
- Attempting full reusability like Starship
SLS as Legacy Technology
- Final hurrah for NASA traditional approach
- Uses Space Shuttle main engines
- Twin solid rocket boosters built on shuttle booster knowledge/experience
- Once reusable rockets succeed, paradigm shift expected
- Future: space travel frequency comparable to airline flights
