AI summary by TwinMind
The Billion-Dollar Problem in Education | Tanishia Lavette Williams | TED
TED
15m 16s
Historical Context of Standardized Testing
- Standardized testing = billion-dollar industry in America
- Written assessments began around 1845, but labeling/compartmentalizing children started 150 years earlier
- Testing children occurred before America became a country
- Process embedded in teaching/learning cycle - "as American as apple pie"
Current Testing Impact and Problems
- Personal experience: 203,760 standardized assessments in career (low-ball count)
- Students learned more and teachers performed better during non-testing periods vs. high-stakes testing
- Observed student trauma:
- Student collapsed in tears over "Do-Nothing Presidents" question
- Student broke into hives, needed nurse with ice packs for makeup exam
- Students preferred fighting over taking paper-pencil tests
- Testing used to:
- Define racialized achievement gaps
- Dictate student promotion
- Disseminate school resources
- Determine "good" vs "bad" schools
Research on US History Curriculum in NYC
- Role: Education Stratification fellow at Institute on Race, Power, and Political Economy
- 10 years researching NYC schools, focusing on US history curriculum
- Analyzed three foundation documents: standards, curriculum, assessments
- Data visualization methodology:
- Squares = males, circles = females, triangles = non-binary, diamonds = non-gendered
- Color spectrum representing skin hues (white = lightest, Black/African American = darkest)
- Chronological organization of topics
Curriculum Analysis Results
- Examined people studied in US history course by race and gender
- Assessment data from August 2023, June 2023, January 2020, 2019
- Last cohort analysis showed what students should remember most about US history
- Findings: "distinguishable amount of white squares" - significant overrepresentation
- Bar graph format revealed curriculum inequity origins
Hidden Systemic Issues
- Rituals of normalcy manifesting as:
- Racialized hierarchies of intelligence
- Legislative wars over student reading materials
- Millions of dollars flowing to curriculum companies
- Wealth/income inequities among people of color
- Assessment data feeds political economy more than classroom instruction
- Not building teacher capacity or deepening student knowledge
- Spending billions on ineffective system
Core Argument
- "Color of achievement is green" (economic factors)
- Current assessment system creates memorization test where "most likely answer is the white male"
- System doesn't build thinkers or creators needed for evolving society
- Quality education can improve through strategic disinvestment in standardized testing as accountability
Proposed Solutions by Stakeholder
Federal/State Policymakers
- Sample testing instead of testing every child
- Don't need to test every American child 112 times in compulsory school years
- Sample testing: easier, cheaper, faster, returns more instructional hours
Local Districts/School Boards
- Prioritize standards over standardization
- Don't test every child the same way if it doesn't reveal their gifts/skills
- Mantra: "Standards over standardization"
Principals
- Resource teachers with every tool/skill needed for effective job performance
- Ensure teachers do jobs effectively
- Every teacher interaction builds capacity, affects children who will solve world problems
Teachers
- Ask questions no one knows answers to
- Pose unfathomable scenarios to cultivate future thinkers
- Unanswered questions today = catalyst for tomorrow's solutions
- Innovations for tomorrow start in classrooms
- Build "thinker tinkers"
Students/Families/Community
- Hold policymakers accountable
- History shows can't wait for empowered to make inclusive policy
- Policy/curriculum/people changes can come from and for the people
- "People work" creates change
Final Call to Action
- Divest in standardized assessments
- Invest in humanity
- Use all instructional minutes to create future society leaders
- Radical solution is economic: shift assessment focus back to classrooms for pedagogical decisions
