AI summary by TwinMind

The Billion-Dollar Problem in Education | Tanishia Lavette Williams | TED

TED

15m 16s

Historical Context of Standardized Testing

  • Standardized testing = billion-dollar industry in America
  • Written assessments began around 1845, but labeling/compartmentalizing children started 150 years earlier
  • Testing children occurred before America became a country
  • Process embedded in teaching/learning cycle - "as American as apple pie"

Current Testing Impact and Problems

  • Personal experience: 203,760 standardized assessments in career (low-ball count)
  • Students learned more and teachers performed better during non-testing periods vs. high-stakes testing
  • Observed student trauma:
    • Student collapsed in tears over "Do-Nothing Presidents" question
    • Student broke into hives, needed nurse with ice packs for makeup exam
    • Students preferred fighting over taking paper-pencil tests
  • Testing used to:
    • Define racialized achievement gaps
    • Dictate student promotion
    • Disseminate school resources
    • Determine "good" vs "bad" schools

Research on US History Curriculum in NYC

  • Role: Education Stratification fellow at Institute on Race, Power, and Political Economy
  • 10 years researching NYC schools, focusing on US history curriculum
  • Analyzed three foundation documents: standards, curriculum, assessments
  • Data visualization methodology:
    • Squares = males, circles = females, triangles = non-binary, diamonds = non-gendered
    • Color spectrum representing skin hues (white = lightest, Black/African American = darkest)
    • Chronological organization of topics

Curriculum Analysis Results

  • Examined people studied in US history course by race and gender
  • Assessment data from August 2023, June 2023, January 2020, 2019
  • Last cohort analysis showed what students should remember most about US history
  • Findings: "distinguishable amount of white squares" - significant overrepresentation
  • Bar graph format revealed curriculum inequity origins

Hidden Systemic Issues

  • Rituals of normalcy manifesting as:
    • Racialized hierarchies of intelligence
    • Legislative wars over student reading materials
    • Millions of dollars flowing to curriculum companies
    • Wealth/income inequities among people of color
  • Assessment data feeds political economy more than classroom instruction
  • Not building teacher capacity or deepening student knowledge
  • Spending billions on ineffective system

Core Argument

  • "Color of achievement is green" (economic factors)
  • Current assessment system creates memorization test where "most likely answer is the white male"
  • System doesn't build thinkers or creators needed for evolving society
  • Quality education can improve through strategic disinvestment in standardized testing as accountability

Proposed Solutions by Stakeholder

Federal/State Policymakers

  • Sample testing instead of testing every child
  • Don't need to test every American child 112 times in compulsory school years
  • Sample testing: easier, cheaper, faster, returns more instructional hours

Local Districts/School Boards

  • Prioritize standards over standardization
  • Don't test every child the same way if it doesn't reveal their gifts/skills
  • Mantra: "Standards over standardization"

Principals

  • Resource teachers with every tool/skill needed for effective job performance
  • Ensure teachers do jobs effectively
  • Every teacher interaction builds capacity, affects children who will solve world problems

Teachers

  • Ask questions no one knows answers to
  • Pose unfathomable scenarios to cultivate future thinkers
  • Unanswered questions today = catalyst for tomorrow's solutions
  • Innovations for tomorrow start in classrooms
  • Build "thinker tinkers"

Students/Families/Community

  • Hold policymakers accountable
  • History shows can't wait for empowered to make inclusive policy
  • Policy/curriculum/people changes can come from and for the people
  • "People work" creates change

Final Call to Action

  • Divest in standardized assessments
  • Invest in humanity
  • Use all instructional minutes to create future society leaders
  • Radical solution is economic: shift assessment focus back to classrooms for pedagogical decisions

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome