AI summary by TwinMind
The Blind Smartphone Camera Test Winners!
Marques Brownlee
12m 12s
Test Methodology
- 20 smartphones tested in blind comparison
- All software updated, batteries charged to 100%
- Three photo categories: daytime, low light, portrait mode
- Identical framing/positioning for all shots
- Full auto mode - no manual adjustments, just point and shoot
- Photos stripped of EXIF data and uploaded for public voting
- Over 20 million total votes collected
- ELO rating system used to rank results (chess/tennis ranking system)
- Phones coded by letters A through T during testing
Daytime Photo Results
- Winner: Pixel 7A (highest ELO rating)
- Neutral exposure, excellent dynamic range
- Not too bright/dark, good color reproduction
- 2nd place: Pixel Fold (similar photo quality)
- 3rd place: OnePlus Open (folding phone)
- Host's personal favorite: OnePlus 11 (4th place)
- More contrasty, confident exposure
- Dead last: iPhone 15 Pro
- Darkest photo in comparison
- Not terrible quality but lost in side-by-side votes
- 2nd worst: Galaxy S23 Ultra
- Weirdly overexposed result
Low Light Photo Results
- Winner: iPhone 15 Pro (complete reversal from daytime)
- Reasonable photo quality in challenging conditions
- 2nd place: Pixel 8 Pro
- 3rd place: Pixel 7A
- Problems with many phones:
- Over-brightening/bad HDR effects beyond top 4
- S23 Ultra: too bright with HDR halo effects
- Oppo X6 Pro: extreme over-processing, painted-look exposure
- OnePlus Open: artificial sky darkening
- Zenphone: similar over-processing issues
Portrait Mode Results
- Most challenging test category
- Phones handle portrait mode differently:
- Various focal lengths (1x, 1.5x, 2x, 3x)
- Different bokeh levels/adjustability
- Default settings used for consistency
- Winner: Pixel 8 Pro
- 2nd place: Samsung Z Fold 5 (better cutout quality)
- 3rd place: iPhone 15 Pro (most natural blur)
- Top finishers: subtle portrait effects, good detail/balance
- Worst performer: Sony Xperia 1 Mark 5
- Lowest ELO rating in entire competition
- $1,200 flagship couldn't handle lighting conditions
- Repeated failed attempts, not user error
Overall Rankings & Awards
- People's Champion (highest average ELO): Pixel 7A (1660 rating)
- Won daytime, 3rd in low light, 4th in portrait
- 2nd overall: Pixel 8 Pro
- 3rd overall: Pixel Fold
- Perfect Pixel podium sweep (reverse price order)
- Bottom performers: Sony Xperia 1 Mark 5, Xiaomi 13 Ultra
Bang for Buck Award
- Winner: Pixel 7A (~$500 launch price)
- 2nd: Nothing Phone 2 (upper mid-range pricing)
- 3rd: OnePlus 11
- 4th: Zenphone 10
- Worst value: Z Flip 5 (expensive folding phone with poor performance)
Key Insights
- Pixel dominance across all categories
- Brighter photos generally preferred by voters
- Overexposure can be just as problematic as underexposure
- Portrait mode most difficult to standardize/test
- Price doesn't always correlate with camera performance
- Test limitations: staged photos don't represent full camera capabilities
- Missing: autofocus speed, UI, file formats, video quality, editability
