AI summary by TwinMind
The Brief Life of the Formosan Communist Party - Part II
Asianometry
8m 23s
Party Decimation and Leadership Crisis (1928-1931)
- FCP suffered immediate decimation from Japanese police in Shanghai and Formosa after founding
- Senior party leaders fled to Shanghai and Japan to hide from police oppression
- Japanese Communist Party (JCP) criticized FCP leadership as "soft spine intellectuals" and "bookworms"
- Accused of fearing police and valuing intellectual privileges over organizing laborers/farmers
- JCP expelled FCP "cowards" and promoted Xie Xuehong to central committee
- Xie was committed Taiwanese nationalist
United Front Strategy vs Class Struggle Debate
- Xie advocated for FCP to establish United Fronts with bourgeois parties sharing anti-imperialist goals
- Similar to CCP's alliance with Kuomintang in 1920s (First United Front)
- Believed united fronts would align with growing anti-Japanese sentiment among native Formosans
- Strategy aimed at eventual revolution and independence
- CCP of late 20s/early 30s disagreed with United Front strategy
- First United Front led to CCP's near destruction by Chiang Kai-shek
- CCP advocated for class struggle and direct organizing of farmers/laborers
- Xie argued back that Formosa's political/historical conditions differed from mainland
- Nationalist united front tactics hadn't been given chance to succeed
Taiwan Cultural Association Infiltration
- Founded 1921 with stated goal of promoting Japanese-Formosan harmony
- Actual goal: awaken Formosan national consciousness, create path to self-determination
- FCP found "rich ground" organizing association's younger members
- Soon took over from inside, turned into hard left organization
Land Seizure and Recruitment Opportunities (1920s)
- Series of clashes between capitalist Japanese elites and native Formosan laborers
- Formosan governor-general declared all lands without established ownership as "condemned"
- Large swathes of valuable land handed to Japanese corporations and landowners
- Sparked tension and helped FCP recruitment
Comintern Reorganization (1928-1931)
- 1928: Stalin defeats Comintern chairman Nikolai Bukharin in power struggle
- Stalin directs Comintern to dump United Front strategies worldwide
- Reasoning: working with bourgeoisie interferes with revolution
- Bourgeoisie would compromise with imperialism to protect their position
- 1931: Comintern reorganizes entire FCP, expelling practically everyone again
- FCP rebooted with new policies:
- Confiscation of all imperialist enterprises and banks
- Various other socialist demands aligned with international class struggle
- Policies caused alienation among original founding members
- Comintern elevated FCP from JCP cadet branch to same level as CCP and JCP
- Declaration by Soviet Union acknowledging Formosa as sovereign entity separate from Japan and China
- Chinese Communist Party had no recorded issue with this arrangement
FCP Political Beliefs and Charter
- 1928 political thesis adopted at founding meeting
- Established Formosa's history as "Formosan nationality" of Han race from southern China
- Historical narrative:
- Worked under feudal system first established by Zheng family (Koxinga)
- Perpetuated by Qing dynasty
- Japanese imperialism brought unequal capitalism
- Created large underclass of Formosans unable to determine their own future
- Goal: overthrow imperialist overlords and rise to power
- Vision of fully independent but Communist Formosan nation
Final Downfall (1931)
- Abandoning Xie's methods meant FCP could no longer hide within legitimate organizations
- CCP's direct recruitment methods forced FCP to work in open
- March 1931: Japanese police arrested first FCP member Chen Deming
- Found CCP documents in his house
- Japanese authorities correctly identified Communist Party cell among Formosans
- Systematic cleansing operation:
- Traced individual members using detective work and confiscated documents
- Arrested members systematically
- Xie among first captured
- June 26: last leading cadre Su Xin captured
- September 13: captured in industrial city of Keelung
- All sentenced to many years in prison
- No further activity until WWII ended
Post-WWII Aftermath
- Xie and fellow comrades like Cai Xiaogan returned to Taiwan island
- Attempted to foment communist revolution as CCP members, not separate FCP
- FCP as independent communist party ceased to exist
