AI summary by TwinMind

The Coming AI Startup Bust

Asianometry

13m 18s

AI Startup Bubble Overview

  • AI startup bubble currently forming with unusual valuations that don't make economic sense
  • Products built in highly competitive areas with daunting economics
  • Many startups will fail but this is normal market process
  • Bust ahead but overall AI investment boom benefits are real

Extreme Valuation Examples

  • Sierra (Brett Taylor co-founder): seeking $4+ billion valuation
    • Conversational AI product with minimal revenue (~$1M estimated)
    • 200x revenue multiple
  • Perplexity AI: raising $500M at $8-9B valuation
    • $50M annual revenue pace
    • 160-180x price-to-revenue multiple
  • Poolside: $500M raise at $3B valuation
    • AI-powered software developer platform
  • Imbu: raised $200M+ at $1B valuation in Sept 2023
    • Zero revenue at time of funding
  • Glean: $250M raise, valuation doubled from $2B to $4.5B in 6 months
    • $55M annualized revenue = 82x multiple
  • OpenAI comparison: $157B valuation, $4-5B revenue = 42x multiple

Return Analysis Problems

  • Optimistic exit scenarios: $40-50B valuations (Atlassian/Snowflake level)
  • $4B raise → 8-10x return sounds good but:
    • 10-12 years average SaaS time to market
    • Annual return only 18-25%
    • Not high considering risks involved

Celebrity Founder Phenomenon

  • High valuations/low revenue indicates betting on team/AI celebrity status
  • Examples:
    • Ilya Sutskever (Safe Superintelligence)
    • Mira Murati (former OpenAI CTO raising for new startup)
    • Fei-Fei Li (World Labs): $100M at $1B valuation
  • Streaming bubble parallel: Ryan Murphy, Shonda Rhimes, JJ Abrams deals
    • Warner Brothers paid $250M for Abrams deal (Sept 2019)
    • Logic: deliver Game of Thrones-style hits for subscriber growth
    • Few years later: some hits produced but deals wouldn't be renewed today

Economic Challenges for AI Applications

Cost Side Issues

  • AI apps more expensive to train/run than traditional cloud apps
  • Higher usage = higher costs for provider
  • Must either dilute quality or pass costs to users via price increases/per-use models
  • Specialized labor costs (e.g., legal AI firms need elite in-house lawyers)

Revenue Side Problems

  • Basic thinking: capture cost savings by replacing jobs/salaries
  • AI agents likely need human-in-the-loop, blunting monetary gains
  • Even successful replacements face competition from cheaper AI products
  • Margins get competed away

Technology Competition Dynamics

  • OpenAI started with 2-year lead, still strong revenue but tech lead shortened
  • All researchers talk, access same hardware, follow similar precepts
  • New innovations (like GPT-o1) incorporated by competitors within months
  • Every AI product ~6 months apart from competitors

Overcrowded Categories

AI Coding Assistants Example

  • Poolside + other $100M+ funded players:
    • Magic, Codium, Cognition, Devin, Augment, Tab9
    • Plus GitHub Copilot (market leader)
  • Hard Disk Drive parallel (1977-1984):
    • 43 manufacturers raised $400M from VCs
    • Over half funding in last 2 years
    • Industry grew to 70 firms, too similar to each other
    • Too modular/easy to replicate
    • PC market pullback 1983-1984 killed many startups

Macro Investment Context

  • Mega-cap companies pouring billions into chips/data centers
  • American companies spending $26B/year on data centers (up 60% from last year)
  • Equals spending on retail stores + restaurants combined
  • TSMC Q3 2024: seeing "more demand than ever dreamed about"

Potential Outcomes

Optimistic Scenario

  • Beginning of magnificent investment run
  • Revolutionizes work, brings prosperity across classes
  • Creates glorious future

Pessimistic Scenario

  • Pull-forward demand, data center investment pauses 3-4 years
  • Similar to post-COVID boom pattern
  • Difficult but not devastating

Bubble Comparison to Historical Examples

  • Past major busts: Japanese real estate (1980s), telecom fiber (1990s), US housing (2000s)
  • Those were destructive because involved high leverage
  • Current AI boom: Amazon/Microsoft/Google funding from monopoly profits
  • No "AI bonds to grandmas and pension funds" yet
  • Larger economy should ride out AI startup bust fine

Impact on Different Stakeholders

VCs and Investors

  • Sophisticated investors who know the risks
  • Can engineer soft exits (example: Inflection AI)
    • Raised millions for chatbot competitor to ChatGPT/Claude/Gemini
    • Failed but Microsoft deal helped staff/investors recover money
  • Already rich and diversified, can handle losses

Startup Employees

  • Most vulnerable group: ordinary folks with families
  • Parallel to streaming content bubble fallout
  • Hundreds in film industry (especially LA) left in lurch after bust
  • Advice for startups: manage money prudently, extend runway, focus on revenue streams ASAP

Market Testing Benefits

  • Capital flows help evaluate new businesses through market testing
  • Examples of successful market testing:
    • Prosumer chatbot space: Anthropic's Claude succeeded, Inflection's Pi failed
    • Money shifted to vector embedding models, then AI agents
    • If AI agents fail, flows will reroute (possibly to robotics)
  • Process develops products, gains traction
  • Most fall by wayside but few will stick and change the world

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome