AI summary by TwinMind

The Coming Semiconductor Bust

Asianometry

11m 51s

Semiconductor Industry Volatility & Current Context

  • Industry highly volatile with boom-bust cycles occurring at frightening speed
  • Normal times still unpredictable: shipments can soar 70% one year, crash 40% next
  • Currently working through major chip shortage, questioning when it turns to glut
  • Everyone racing to build/expand fabs, potentially sooner than expected

Demand Dynamics & Forecasting Challenges

  • End users don't directly buy microchips in large quantities
  • Chips purchased by vendors for consumer goods (PCs, smartphones)
  • Short product lifecycles - always new products threatening obsolescence
  • Missing annual launch cycles can have dire company consequences (AMD mid-2000s example)
  • Foundry customers want products made/shipped immediately
  • Double booking orders common in uncertain times
    • TSMC Chairman Mark Leo cites as major reason shortage not as bad as appears
    • Driven by pandemic and China-America trade tensions
    • Trade tensions bigger concern with no end in sight

Macro Economic Impact

  • Electronics are consumer items - fewer purchases during tough times
  • Three recent semiconductor downturns attributed to oil shocks: 1975, 1982, 1991
  • Fourth downturn from Asian financial crisis 1998
  • March 2020: stock market down 25%, experts predicted economic collapse
  • Companies cutting expenses, hunkering down
  • Stimulus packages and money printing caused faster-than-anticipated Q3 2020 recovery

Supply-Side Factors More Significant Than Demand

  • 2005 study found semiconductor down cycles triggered more by oversupply than under-demand
  • Surges in semiconductor inventory levels and fab capacity more significant than demand decreases
  • Industry nature/economics force companies to overproduce until collapse

Fab Economics & Moore's/Rock's Laws

  • Fabs cost enormous amounts to build
  • Moore's Law: transistor count doubles every 2 years
  • Rock's Law (Moore's Second Law): semiconductor tool costs double every 4 years
    • Tools represent 75% of total fab cost
    • 2000: leading edge fab cost $1 billion (2x from 1995)
    • 2005: $3 billion
    • TSMC N5 fab in Tainan: ~$17 billion
    • TSMC N3 process fab in Tainan: estimated $19.5 billion
  • Research ongoing to slow Rock's Law while accelerating Moore's

Market Dynamics & Pricing Collapse

  • Foundries need billion-dollar fabs to recoup investments
  • Fabs lose value almost immediately after construction
  • Fixed construction costs high, marginal chip production cost essentially nil
  • Incentive to maximize production to amortize fixed costs
  • Supply exceeds demand → price collapse → reduced profits
  • Foundries still sell every possible chip for survival
  • Samsung and TSMC prioritize market share over profitability
  • Refuse to mothball capacity to prevent competitor gains
  • Massive economies of scale allow survival pricing below competitors
  • Results in fierce down cycles, bankruptcies, buyouts, supply rebalancing

Government Subsidies & Policy

US Initiatives

  • CHIPS Act and American Foundries Act in development
  • Establish R&D fund and 20-40% tax credit for semiconductor production equipment
  • Tax credit effects: shorter term (3-5 years, one fab generation)
  • R&D fund preferred for longer-term effects, public-private partnerships (like EUV creation)
  • Mixed feelings about venture - understands national sovereignty value
  • Concern about commercial viability after subsidies end
  • Subsidies create market distortions (intentionally)
  • Question whether subsidized fabs can stand independently afterward

Global Subsidy Competition

  • China: $20 billion semiconductor plan
  • US: $50 billion in Biden stimulus plan
  • EU: €145 billion for 2nm cutting-edge fab

Current Global Fab Buildout

Major Projects

  • TSMC Arizona fab: ongoing for 1 year
    • Originally 20,000 wafer capacity, whispers of upscaling
    • Final capacity: 25,000-100,000 wafer starts/month
  • Samsung Austin fab: major investment buildout, tens of billions planned
  • Global Foundries: $1.4 billion expansion, moving up IPO
  • SMIC: $2.35 billion Shenzhen government-funded project
    • Expected 40,000 wafers/month capacity by 2022

Capacity Analysis

  • Hundreds of thousands of wafers coming to market over next 1-2 years
  • TSMC Arizona alone at 50,000 wafers/month = theoretical 3.5 billion dies/month
  • US Department of Defense buys only $1.9 billion semiconductors/year
  • Questions whether demand creation matches capacity expansion
  • Doubt about sustained demand from returning students/workers, PC enthusiasts, crypto miners

Market Outlook Concerns

  • Chip shortage widely publicized (Wall Street Journal, The Verge)
  • Semiconductors currently "super hot"
  • Curiosity about boom duration and inevitable bust timing
  • Watching buildout with interest given historical boom-bust patterns

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome