AI summary by TwinMind

The Court That’s Sometimes Too Extreme for the Supreme Court | WSJ

The Wall Street Journal

6m 52s

Fifth Circuit Court Overview

  • US Court of Appeals for Fifth Circuit = arguably most conservative appeals court in country
  • Sending multiple controversial cases to Supreme Court: domestic abuser gun access, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau constitutionality, abortion pill legality
  • Previously sent major cases on Affordable Care Act and abortion
  • Paradox: despite conservative Supreme Court, Fifth Circuit rulings frequently overturned for being "too far right" or "too procedurally extreme"

Federal Appeals Court System Structure

  • 12 appeals courts representing different US regions
  • Judges nominated by president, confirmed by Senate (like Supreme Court justices)
  • Historical process required 60 votes + home state senator approval = bipartisan support needed
  • Most federal judges historically were centrist (slightly left/right of center)

Confirmation Process Changes

  • Senate rule changes: 2013 (initial), 2017 (broader application)
  • Judicial nominees now need only 50 votes for confirmation
  • Home state approval rule removed under Trump
  • New norm: "most ideologically extreme person I can get through Senate"
  • Calculus shifted from bipartisan consensus to partisan extremes

Trump's Fifth Circuit Appointments

  • Trump appointed several far-right judges to Fifth Circuit
  • Different backgrounds from traditional appeals court judges:
    • Traditional: private practice or other court experience
    • Trump appointees: political backgrounds (campaigns, White House, governor/attorney general offices)
  • Many Trump/Biden nominees "would never been nominated during prior presidencies of same party"
  • Profound effect on federal judiciary nature

Case Steering and Forum Shopping

  • Litigants strategically file cases in Texas for sympathetic district judges
  • Appeals automatically go to Fifth Circuit
  • Abortion pill case filed in Amarillo, Texas (very conservative district judge)
  • Dobbs case brought in Mississippi
  • Systematic exploitation of court geography

Fifth Circuit Internal Mechanics

  • Cases assigned to random 3-judge panels
  • High probability of conservative majority panels
  • Full court can rehear cases "en banc" (entire court)
  • Example: felon voting rights case
    • 3-judge panel ruled felons should vote
    • Full court scheduled January en banc rehearing to overturn

Procedural Aggressiveness Examples

  • Biden vaccination/testing mandate for large employers:
    • Dozens of identical lawsuits filed across states
    • Triggered literal lottery system (balls in wooden drum)
    • Fifth Circuit "cut ahead" and ruled before lottery
    • Blocked Biden mandate
    • Winning lottery court later reversed decision, allowed policy

Supreme Court Relationship

  • Disconnect between Fifth Circuit conservative judges and Supreme Court conservative justices
  • Supreme Court justices "more particular about procedural formalities"
  • Fifth Circuit taking "procedural shortcuts"
  • Results in frequent Supreme Court reversals of Fifth Circuit decisions

Biden Administration Response

  • Biden appointed polarizing judges using 50-vote rule
  • Democratic Senate reinstated home state approval rule
  • Biden appointments less polarizing than Trump's

Systemic Problems

  • Legal system not designed for "radical polls with no middle"
  • Recipe for chaos vs. coherent uniform legal principles
  • Threatens national unity ("one nation as opposed to 50 different states")
  • Fifth Circuit will continue attracting most conservative cases
  • Many cases will inevitably reach Supreme Court

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome