AI summary by TwinMind
The Court That’s Sometimes Too Extreme for the Supreme Court | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
6m 52s
Fifth Circuit Court Overview
- US Court of Appeals for Fifth Circuit = arguably most conservative appeals court in country
- Sending multiple controversial cases to Supreme Court: domestic abuser gun access, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau constitutionality, abortion pill legality
- Previously sent major cases on Affordable Care Act and abortion
- Paradox: despite conservative Supreme Court, Fifth Circuit rulings frequently overturned for being "too far right" or "too procedurally extreme"
Federal Appeals Court System Structure
- 12 appeals courts representing different US regions
- Judges nominated by president, confirmed by Senate (like Supreme Court justices)
- Historical process required 60 votes + home state senator approval = bipartisan support needed
- Most federal judges historically were centrist (slightly left/right of center)
Confirmation Process Changes
- Senate rule changes: 2013 (initial), 2017 (broader application)
- Judicial nominees now need only 50 votes for confirmation
- Home state approval rule removed under Trump
- New norm: "most ideologically extreme person I can get through Senate"
- Calculus shifted from bipartisan consensus to partisan extremes
Trump's Fifth Circuit Appointments
- Trump appointed several far-right judges to Fifth Circuit
- Different backgrounds from traditional appeals court judges:
- Traditional: private practice or other court experience
- Trump appointees: political backgrounds (campaigns, White House, governor/attorney general offices)
- Many Trump/Biden nominees "would never been nominated during prior presidencies of same party"
- Profound effect on federal judiciary nature
Case Steering and Forum Shopping
- Litigants strategically file cases in Texas for sympathetic district judges
- Appeals automatically go to Fifth Circuit
- Abortion pill case filed in Amarillo, Texas (very conservative district judge)
- Dobbs case brought in Mississippi
- Systematic exploitation of court geography
Fifth Circuit Internal Mechanics
- Cases assigned to random 3-judge panels
- High probability of conservative majority panels
- Full court can rehear cases "en banc" (entire court)
- Example: felon voting rights case
- 3-judge panel ruled felons should vote
- Full court scheduled January en banc rehearing to overturn
Procedural Aggressiveness Examples
- Biden vaccination/testing mandate for large employers:
- Dozens of identical lawsuits filed across states
- Triggered literal lottery system (balls in wooden drum)
- Fifth Circuit "cut ahead" and ruled before lottery
- Blocked Biden mandate
- Winning lottery court later reversed decision, allowed policy
Supreme Court Relationship
- Disconnect between Fifth Circuit conservative judges and Supreme Court conservative justices
- Supreme Court justices "more particular about procedural formalities"
- Fifth Circuit taking "procedural shortcuts"
- Results in frequent Supreme Court reversals of Fifth Circuit decisions
Biden Administration Response
- Biden appointed polarizing judges using 50-vote rule
- Democratic Senate reinstated home state approval rule
- Biden appointments less polarizing than Trump's
Systemic Problems
- Legal system not designed for "radical polls with no middle"
- Recipe for chaos vs. coherent uniform legal principles
- Threatens national unity ("one nation as opposed to 50 different states")
- Fifth Circuit will continue attracting most conservative cases
- Many cases will inevitably reach Supreme Court
