AI summary by TwinMind

The Creativity and Community Behind Fanfiction | Cecilia Aragon | TED

TED

14m 56s

Personal Background and Motivation

  • Speaker: 10-year-old lonely, geeky, first-generation Latina in small Midwestern town
  • Parents spoke with thick accents, felt isolated
  • Discovered Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings" trilogy, fell in love with fantasy world
  • Bothered by lack of female characters in the book
  • 7th grade teacher told her: "Why are you working so hard in math? You should be getting a boyfriend!"
  • Rewrote LOTR story in spiral notebook
    • Regendered main characters
    • Added new scenes (female hobbit devising plan to foil Balrog)
    • Created place where someone like her could feel at home
  • Never shared notebook but learned about writing through this process
  • Unknowingly writing fanfiction

Research Origins and Collaboration

  • Speaker became data science professor at University of Washington in 2013
  • Met Professor Katie Davis over lunch
  • Discussed news story claiming "kids today can't write, all they produce is misspelled short texts"
  • Both knew kids whose writing abilities defied stereotypes
  • Talented young people they knew had heavy involvement in fanfiction reading/writing
  • Contradiction sparked exploration into enduring research project

Fanfiction Definition and Historical Context

  • Also known as transformative literature
  • Historical precedent: John Milton's "Paradise Lost" (1600s) used Bible characters
  • Modern fanfiction origins: typewritten zines by "Star Trek" fans in '60s and '70s
  • Internet growth lowered barriers to sharing
  • Popular source materials: "Harry Potter," "Twilight," "Naruto," "My Little Pony," "Pokémon"
  • Example titles: "When Harry Potter Accidentally Started a Cult," "Five Times Hermione Snogged Harry -- And One Time She Didn't"

Scale and Demographics

  • Past 20 years: over 60 billion words written on fanfiction.net alone
  • Comparison: 80 billion words of traditionally published English fiction in all human history
  • Fanfiction.net: 15 million members writing in 44 different languages
  • Median age: 15.5 years
  • Most authors: 13-21 years old, mostly teenage girls
  • 73% identify as female
  • More fanfiction authors identify as gender nonconforming than male

Learning Through Community Feedback

  • Authors motivated by love for characters and worlds
  • Repeatedly told researchers how much they learned about writing from communities
  • Case study 1: Author started at age 13 with crush on fictional character
    • Early writing: "gorgeous cerulean orbs," "manly hunks of muscle"
    • Reviewers provided positive but constructive feedback
    • Learned to avoid clichés and overwriting
    • Now publishes original fiction
    • Quote: "I think if a teacher had simply red-pencilied my childish scribbles, I might have been so discouraged as to never write again"
  • Case study 2: Queer, autistic middle-schooler
    • Started writing fanfiction at age 13
    • Difficulty with social situations
    • Fanfiction communities provided vital social and learning outlet
    • Later published first-author academic paper in top-rated venue as undergraduate

Data Analysis Results

  • Young writers' word usage became more diverse as they received more reviews
  • Personal stories consistent with quantitative data

Distributed Mentoring Discovery

  • Expected to find traditional mentor-mentee pairs (older/experienced mentoring younger/less experienced)
  • Found completely different system: millions of authors and readers communicating via multiple channels
  • People of all ages reviewing each other's work regardless of experience level
  • Termed "distributed mentoring" (also "nanomentoring")
  • Each piece tiny individually, but combination greater than sum of parts
  • Key attribute: abundance of feedback

Feedback Quality and Quantity

  • Author who wrote both traditional and fanfiction: received more feedback in single week on fanfiction than entire year of traditional publishing
  • Individual comments like "loved it" relatively meaningless alone
  • Hundreds/thousands provide valuable feedback
  • Examples: "This chapter made me cry," "it leaves me feeling hopeful"
  • Reviewers build on and reference each other's comments
  • Authors piece together overall supportive yet constructive view
  • Only 1% of comments constituted bullying (surprisingly low for anonymous internet platform)

Impact on Marginalized Communities

  • Black author made all characters from popular TV show Black
  • Received comments filled with readers' sense of freedom and delight
  • Encouraged continued writing and gave conviction work was worthwhile
  • Fanfiction particularly welcoming for marginalized groups

Educational Applications

  • National Assessment of Educational Progress: 73% of US students in grades 8 and 12 lack writing proficiency
  • Adolescence optimal time to improve writing skills
  • Fanfiction popularity in this age group presents learning opportunity
  • Proposed system:
    • Connect students with similar interests across school districts
    • Anonymous feedback system (must be anonymous)
    • Teachers moderate channels for constructive feedback
    • Hierarchical moderation system if teacher workload becomes burdensome
      • Students report negative/abusive comments
      • Volunteer student moderators decide deletions
      • Teachers intervene only when necessary
    • System used in many large online communities, familiar to adolescents

Personal Reflection

  • Fanfiction as private universe becoming welcoming community
  • Particularly meaningful for marginalized groups
  • Speaker contrasts with own isolation growing up Latina in US
  • Wonders what would have been different with access to supportive community of millions of young people and distributed mentoring as child

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome