AI summary by TwinMind
The Creativity and Community Behind Fanfiction | Cecilia Aragon | TED
TED
14m 56s
Personal Background and Motivation
- Speaker: 10-year-old lonely, geeky, first-generation Latina in small Midwestern town
- Parents spoke with thick accents, felt isolated
- Discovered Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings" trilogy, fell in love with fantasy world
- Bothered by lack of female characters in the book
- 7th grade teacher told her: "Why are you working so hard in math? You should be getting a boyfriend!"
- Rewrote LOTR story in spiral notebook
- Regendered main characters
- Added new scenes (female hobbit devising plan to foil Balrog)
- Created place where someone like her could feel at home
- Never shared notebook but learned about writing through this process
- Unknowingly writing fanfiction
Research Origins and Collaboration
- Speaker became data science professor at University of Washington in 2013
- Met Professor Katie Davis over lunch
- Discussed news story claiming "kids today can't write, all they produce is misspelled short texts"
- Both knew kids whose writing abilities defied stereotypes
- Talented young people they knew had heavy involvement in fanfiction reading/writing
- Contradiction sparked exploration into enduring research project
Fanfiction Definition and Historical Context
- Also known as transformative literature
- Historical precedent: John Milton's "Paradise Lost" (1600s) used Bible characters
- Modern fanfiction origins: typewritten zines by "Star Trek" fans in '60s and '70s
- Internet growth lowered barriers to sharing
- Popular source materials: "Harry Potter," "Twilight," "Naruto," "My Little Pony," "Pokémon"
- Example titles: "When Harry Potter Accidentally Started a Cult," "Five Times Hermione Snogged Harry -- And One Time She Didn't"
Scale and Demographics
- Past 20 years: over 60 billion words written on fanfiction.net alone
- Comparison: 80 billion words of traditionally published English fiction in all human history
- Fanfiction.net: 15 million members writing in 44 different languages
- Median age: 15.5 years
- Most authors: 13-21 years old, mostly teenage girls
- 73% identify as female
- More fanfiction authors identify as gender nonconforming than male
Learning Through Community Feedback
- Authors motivated by love for characters and worlds
- Repeatedly told researchers how much they learned about writing from communities
- Case study 1: Author started at age 13 with crush on fictional character
- Early writing: "gorgeous cerulean orbs," "manly hunks of muscle"
- Reviewers provided positive but constructive feedback
- Learned to avoid clichés and overwriting
- Now publishes original fiction
- Quote: "I think if a teacher had simply red-pencilied my childish scribbles, I might have been so discouraged as to never write again"
- Case study 2: Queer, autistic middle-schooler
- Started writing fanfiction at age 13
- Difficulty with social situations
- Fanfiction communities provided vital social and learning outlet
- Later published first-author academic paper in top-rated venue as undergraduate
Data Analysis Results
- Young writers' word usage became more diverse as they received more reviews
- Personal stories consistent with quantitative data
Distributed Mentoring Discovery
- Expected to find traditional mentor-mentee pairs (older/experienced mentoring younger/less experienced)
- Found completely different system: millions of authors and readers communicating via multiple channels
- People of all ages reviewing each other's work regardless of experience level
- Termed "distributed mentoring" (also "nanomentoring")
- Each piece tiny individually, but combination greater than sum of parts
- Key attribute: abundance of feedback
Feedback Quality and Quantity
- Author who wrote both traditional and fanfiction: received more feedback in single week on fanfiction than entire year of traditional publishing
- Individual comments like "loved it" relatively meaningless alone
- Hundreds/thousands provide valuable feedback
- Examples: "This chapter made me cry," "it leaves me feeling hopeful"
- Reviewers build on and reference each other's comments
- Authors piece together overall supportive yet constructive view
- Only 1% of comments constituted bullying (surprisingly low for anonymous internet platform)
Impact on Marginalized Communities
- Black author made all characters from popular TV show Black
- Received comments filled with readers' sense of freedom and delight
- Encouraged continued writing and gave conviction work was worthwhile
- Fanfiction particularly welcoming for marginalized groups
Educational Applications
- National Assessment of Educational Progress: 73% of US students in grades 8 and 12 lack writing proficiency
- Adolescence optimal time to improve writing skills
- Fanfiction popularity in this age group presents learning opportunity
- Proposed system:
- Connect students with similar interests across school districts
- Anonymous feedback system (must be anonymous)
- Teachers moderate channels for constructive feedback
- Hierarchical moderation system if teacher workload becomes burdensome
- Students report negative/abusive comments
- Volunteer student moderators decide deletions
- Teachers intervene only when necessary
- System used in many large online communities, familiar to adolescents
Personal Reflection
- Fanfiction as private universe becoming welcoming community
- Particularly meaningful for marginalized groups
- Speaker contrasts with own isolation growing up Latina in US
- Wonders what would have been different with access to supportive community of millions of young people and distributed mentoring as child
