AI summary by TwinMind
The dark history of Mount Rushmore - Ned Blackhawk and Jeffrey D. Means
TED-Ed
5m 13s
Mount Rushmore Construction (1927-1941)
- 400 workers blasted 450,000 tons of rock from mountainside
- Used chisels, jackhammers, and dynamite
- Monument now draws nearly 3 million people to South Dakota's Black Hills annually
- Project led by sculptor Gutzon Borglum (had KKK ties)
- Work stopped October 1941 after Borglum died from surgical complications
- Project left unfinished - no torsos on four figures, rubble piled below
Indigenous History and Sacred Significance
- Native Americans inhabited Black Hills for ~10,000 years
- Especially sacred to Lakota people (western branch of Sioux Nation)
- Lakota believed cave within Black Hills was their emergence point
- Named mountain peak "Six Grandfathers" after sacred directional spirits
- Mount Rushmore carved into this sacred Six Grandfathers Mountain
Treaty Violations and Land Seizure
- 1800s: White settlers expanded territories through violence/negotiation
- Late 1700s-ongoing: US ratified hundreds of treaties with Native nations
- Often broke treaties or created through coercion
- 1866-1868: Lakota successfully defended land from US military
- 1868 Treaty at Fort Laramie established:
- Vast territory including Black Hills belonged to Sioux Nation
- Lakota allowed US travelers safe passage
- Assimilation incentives: hunting→farming, abandon nomadic lifestyle, wear US-provided clothes
- 1875: US broke treaty after expedition found gold in Black Hills
- Miners established camps
- Military attacked and defeated Lakota
- US passed legislation illegally seizing land
Presidential Anti-Indigenous Legacies
- George Washington: Called "Town Destroyer" by Iroquois Confederacy
- Encouraged military campaigns burning 50 villages in 1779
- Theodore Roosevelt: Championed forced assimilation
- Quote: "I don't go so far as to think that the only good Indians are dead Indians, but I believe nine out of 10 are"
- Original historian proposed including Western figures like Lakota Chief Red Cloud
- Borglum chose his own heroes instead
Legal Resolution Attempts
- 1980: Supreme Court ruled after Sioux Nation sued for treaty violations
- Black Hills unlawfully taken
- Sioux entitled to compensation
- Compensation amount reached over $1 billion
- Sioux Nation refused money, maintained claim to Black Hills
- Position: lands "never for sale"
Current Debate and Proposed Solutions
- Tribal leaders and Borglum's great-granddaughter: call for Mount Rushmore removal
- Others: view as important patriotic symbol vital to South Dakota's economy
- Many Lakota: want 1868 Treaty honored, federally controlled lands returned
- Alternative proposal: Lakota-US co-management of Black Hills parts
- Currently no plans for change
- Faces expected to remain for thousands of years if untouched
Broader Context
- US broke many promises with Indigenous nations (common issue)
- Native people fighting for broken treaty honor for generations
- Some major victories achieved along the way
