AI summary by TwinMind

The End of Roe v. Wade -- and What Comes Next | Kathryn Kolbert | TED

TED

16m 52s

Speaker Background and Credentials

  • Argued 2 abortion cases in US Supreme Court
    • Including 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey case (credited with saving Roe v. Wade)
  • Co-founder of Center for Reproductive Rights
  • 20 years career arguing for women needing abortions and reproductive healthcare

Prediction: Roe v. Wade Will Be Overturned

  • Roe v. Wade will be dead within the year
  • Constitutional right to choose abortion will no longer be protected by US Constitution
  • Court likely to overrule Roe and Casey or undermine meaning until effectively unavailable
  • Federal Constitution will no longer protect reproductive freedom

Broader Vision of Reproductive Freedom

  • More than just abortion rights
  • Ability to make decisions about becoming parents for all people
    • Regardless of race, gender, who they love
  • Social supports necessary to raise children with dignity and safety

Critique of Abortion Opposition Arguments

Religion

  • World's religions have wide variety of views on abortion
  • Many support abortion in various circumstances
  • Opponents imposing their specific religion on others

Fetal Rights Protection

  • If truly cared about fetal rights, would work to eliminate high infant mortality rate
  • US has one of highest infant mortality rates in developed world
  • Should support programs for children once born

Women's Health Protection

  • Abortion already extremely safe surgical procedure
  • Safer than childbirth
  • New restrictions only make abortion less safe
  • Real issue is controlling women
  • Women cannot be equal participants in society without control over reproduction timing

Supreme Court Vote Counting Analysis

  • Key lesson from "Sesame Street": learn to count
  • Only number that matters is 5 (majority of justices)

1992 Casey Case Details

  • Speaker convinced 5 justices prepared to overrule Roe
  • After argument, 7 justices voted to uphold Pennsylvania restrictions
  • Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote draft opinion effectively repudiating Roe's central holding
  • Justice Anthony Kennedy changed mind at last minute
  • Kennedy joined with Justices Sandra Day O'Connor and David Souter
  • Joint opinion upheld women's right to abortion until viability (24-28 weeks) in all 50 states/territories
  • Casey permitted states to enact barriers as long as not "undue burdens"

Post-Casey Consequences

  • Following 3 decades: states passed hundreds of abortion restrictions
  • Increasingly conservative courts upheld restrictions
  • Dwindling abortion availability
  • Today: only 11% of counties have abortion provider

Current Accessibility Issues

  • Before Roe: women with means could get abortions
  • Today's disadvantaged groups with difficulty accessing safe, affordable abortion:
    • Low-income women
    • Women in rural areas
    • Teenagers
    • Women of color
    • Women with disabilities

Current Supreme Court Cases

Texas Cases (2 pending)

  • Texas banned abortion at 6 weeks pregnancy
  • Allowed any individual to sue abortion providers
  • Vigilantes collect $10,000 bounty for law violations
  • Many/most Texas clinics closed or decreased services
  • 5 justices already voted to permit Texas law to take effect
  • Justices not considering constitutionality, only procedural issues (who can be sued, where)

Mississippi Case (1 pending)

  • Ban on abortion at 15 weeks pregnancy
  • Arguments heard this week
  • Likely to see at least 5 justices overrule Roe and Casey
  • Send abortion question back to states
  • No Justice Kennedy to save the decision this time

Post-Roe Predictions

  • About half of US states will ban all/most abortions
  • Ban stretching from Georgia west to Texas, Idaho south to Arizona
  • Women forced to travel to 15 states controlled by pro-choice legislators/governors
  • Other women will seek medication abortion via internet/gray/black markets
  • Some states will criminally prosecute women
  • Other women will carry unintended pregnancies to term

New Strategic Approach

Strategy 1: Build Social Justice Movement

  • Stop "Save Roe" strategy (no longer feasible)
  • Build "badass social justice movement"
  • Loudly cry for rights, claim ownership
  • Learn from Black Lives Matter and marriage equality movements
  • Coalition building is key
  • Find allies to protect rights

Strategy 2: Electoral Politics (More Important)

  • Elect legislators throughout states and Congress who champion reproductive health
  • Get politically active beyond just knowing how
  • Target 500,000 elected seats in US government:
    • School boards
    • Town councils
    • State legislatures
    • Congress
    • White House
  • All seats need champions of reproductive rights

Vision for Pro-Choice Political Control

Family-Friendly Policies

  • Childcare and universal childhood education in every community
  • Paid maternity and paternity leaves for all working parents
  • Programs to reduce maternal mortality (African American women die at 3x rate of white women from pregnancy-related causes, most preventable)
  • Eliminate systemic racism in healthcare system
  • Special programs for women with infertility
  • Healthcare services for all women at all life stages

Reproductive Health Specific Policies

  • Birth control pill available over-the-counter (easy as Tylenol)
  • Quality sex education in every public school
  • Abortion affordable and available:
    • No bans, barriers, or funding restrictions
    • Medication abortion available at pharmacies without prescription
    • Available at walk-in health centers
    • Available on every college campus

Constitutional Amendment

  • Gender equity amendment guaranteeing all persons ability to make decisions about:
    • Abortion
    • Pregnancy
    • Marriage
    • Sexuality
    • Parenting
  • Permanent part of US Constitution
  • Rights not controlled by politicians
  • Not dependent on location, income, race, or sexual orientation
  • Universal fundamental human rights guaranteed in law
  • Supreme Court cannot arbitrarily remove them

Call to Action

  • Vote and engage in political campaigns
  • Write postcards, make phone calls, knock on doors
  • Run for office
  • End of Roe not end of story
  • Quote Joan Baez: "best antidote to despair is action"
  • Action can preserve reproductive freedoms for current and future generations

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome