AI summary by TwinMind
The End of Roe v. Wade -- and What Comes Next | Kathryn Kolbert | TED
TED
16m 52s
Speaker Background and Credentials
- Argued 2 abortion cases in US Supreme Court
- Including 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey case (credited with saving Roe v. Wade)
- Co-founder of Center for Reproductive Rights
- 20 years career arguing for women needing abortions and reproductive healthcare
Prediction: Roe v. Wade Will Be Overturned
- Roe v. Wade will be dead within the year
- Constitutional right to choose abortion will no longer be protected by US Constitution
- Court likely to overrule Roe and Casey or undermine meaning until effectively unavailable
- Federal Constitution will no longer protect reproductive freedom
Broader Vision of Reproductive Freedom
- More than just abortion rights
- Ability to make decisions about becoming parents for all people
- Regardless of race, gender, who they love
- Social supports necessary to raise children with dignity and safety
Critique of Abortion Opposition Arguments
Religion
- World's religions have wide variety of views on abortion
- Many support abortion in various circumstances
- Opponents imposing their specific religion on others
Fetal Rights Protection
- If truly cared about fetal rights, would work to eliminate high infant mortality rate
- US has one of highest infant mortality rates in developed world
- Should support programs for children once born
Women's Health Protection
- Abortion already extremely safe surgical procedure
- Safer than childbirth
- New restrictions only make abortion less safe
- Real issue is controlling women
- Women cannot be equal participants in society without control over reproduction timing
Supreme Court Vote Counting Analysis
- Key lesson from "Sesame Street": learn to count
- Only number that matters is 5 (majority of justices)
1992 Casey Case Details
- Speaker convinced 5 justices prepared to overrule Roe
- After argument, 7 justices voted to uphold Pennsylvania restrictions
- Chief Justice Rehnquist wrote draft opinion effectively repudiating Roe's central holding
- Justice Anthony Kennedy changed mind at last minute
- Kennedy joined with Justices Sandra Day O'Connor and David Souter
- Joint opinion upheld women's right to abortion until viability (24-28 weeks) in all 50 states/territories
- Casey permitted states to enact barriers as long as not "undue burdens"
Post-Casey Consequences
- Following 3 decades: states passed hundreds of abortion restrictions
- Increasingly conservative courts upheld restrictions
- Dwindling abortion availability
- Today: only 11% of counties have abortion provider
Current Accessibility Issues
- Before Roe: women with means could get abortions
- Today's disadvantaged groups with difficulty accessing safe, affordable abortion:
- Low-income women
- Women in rural areas
- Teenagers
- Women of color
- Women with disabilities
Current Supreme Court Cases
Texas Cases (2 pending)
- Texas banned abortion at 6 weeks pregnancy
- Allowed any individual to sue abortion providers
- Vigilantes collect $10,000 bounty for law violations
- Many/most Texas clinics closed or decreased services
- 5 justices already voted to permit Texas law to take effect
- Justices not considering constitutionality, only procedural issues (who can be sued, where)
Mississippi Case (1 pending)
- Ban on abortion at 15 weeks pregnancy
- Arguments heard this week
- Likely to see at least 5 justices overrule Roe and Casey
- Send abortion question back to states
- No Justice Kennedy to save the decision this time
Post-Roe Predictions
- About half of US states will ban all/most abortions
- Ban stretching from Georgia west to Texas, Idaho south to Arizona
- Women forced to travel to 15 states controlled by pro-choice legislators/governors
- Other women will seek medication abortion via internet/gray/black markets
- Some states will criminally prosecute women
- Other women will carry unintended pregnancies to term
New Strategic Approach
Strategy 1: Build Social Justice Movement
- Stop "Save Roe" strategy (no longer feasible)
- Build "badass social justice movement"
- Loudly cry for rights, claim ownership
- Learn from Black Lives Matter and marriage equality movements
- Coalition building is key
- Find allies to protect rights
Strategy 2: Electoral Politics (More Important)
- Elect legislators throughout states and Congress who champion reproductive health
- Get politically active beyond just knowing how
- Target 500,000 elected seats in US government:
- School boards
- Town councils
- State legislatures
- Congress
- White House
- All seats need champions of reproductive rights
Vision for Pro-Choice Political Control
Family-Friendly Policies
- Childcare and universal childhood education in every community
- Paid maternity and paternity leaves for all working parents
- Programs to reduce maternal mortality (African American women die at 3x rate of white women from pregnancy-related causes, most preventable)
- Eliminate systemic racism in healthcare system
- Special programs for women with infertility
- Healthcare services for all women at all life stages
Reproductive Health Specific Policies
- Birth control pill available over-the-counter (easy as Tylenol)
- Quality sex education in every public school
- Abortion affordable and available:
- No bans, barriers, or funding restrictions
- Medication abortion available at pharmacies without prescription
- Available at walk-in health centers
- Available on every college campus
Constitutional Amendment
- Gender equity amendment guaranteeing all persons ability to make decisions about:
- Abortion
- Pregnancy
- Marriage
- Sexuality
- Parenting
- Permanent part of US Constitution
- Rights not controlled by politicians
- Not dependent on location, income, race, or sexual orientation
- Universal fundamental human rights guaranteed in law
- Supreme Court cannot arbitrarily remove them
Call to Action
- Vote and engage in political campaigns
- Write postcards, make phone calls, knock on doors
- Run for office
- End of Roe not end of story
- Quote Joan Baez: "best antidote to despair is action"
- Action can preserve reproductive freedoms for current and future generations
