AI summary by TwinMind
The End of the SAT?
PolyMatter
11m 34s
COVID-19 Impact on College Admissions
- College admissions significantly affected by coronavirus pandemic
- High school juniors/seniors face lifetime consequences beyond single year hardship
- Airlines/workplaces can adapt, but students face unique challenges
AP Test Changes
- College Board announced AP tests going online after 8 weeks preparation
- Format changed from 3-hour (multiple choice + written) to 45-minute written-only
- Tests sent to teachers for grading
- Fairness concerns raised:
- All students took exams simultaneously globally
- California students: 11 AM start time
- Tokyo students: 3 AM start time
- Technology access disparities
- Wi-Fi/device failures requiring retakes
SAT Disruptions
- March testing centers forced to close (short/no notice)
- May and June SATs canceled
- College Board initially planned online format, then reversed decision
- New plan: monthly in-person tests August through year-end
Test Optional Policies Adoption
- Major schools dropping SAT/ACT requirements:
- Dartmouth, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Stanford, Cornell
- All UC schools + hundreds others
- Test optional for at least next year
- Coronavirus accelerating 5-15 year trend toward test flexibility
Test Optional Policy Spectrum
- Test required: All applicants must submit scores
- Test optional: ~700 schools allow student choice
- Test blind: Scores only used for financial aid, not admissions
- Variations by GPA threshold, class rank, major
Effects of Test Optional Policies
Application Volume Increase
- More students apply when requirements removed
- Acceptance rates decrease (appear more selective)
Score Inflation
- Students with higher scores submit them
- Students with lower scores don't submit
- Average reported scores increase artificially
- 7.75% of US News ranking formula based on SAT/ACT scores
- 15% discount if <75% students submit scores
- Bond rating agencies use scores for creditworthiness assessment
Diversity Impact (Disputed)
- Debate whether standardized tests alleviate or amplify inequality
- Mixed research conclusions
Academic Performance Predictors
- High school classes (AP, IB, honors) = best predictors
- Semester/year-long courses better than 3-hour exam
- Challenges:
- Teacher/school grading variations
- Grade inflation over time (fewer C's/D's, more A's/B's)
- SAT provides national comparison standard
Socioeconomic Factors
- Students benefiting from test optional policies:
- First-generation college students
- Women
- Low-income families
- Second language speakers
- Income strongly correlated with test performance
- Test prep increases scores 20-30 points
- Wealthy students take SAT multiple times
- Low-income students get 2 free SAT exams
- Test coaches help obtain learning disability accommodations
Alternative Inequality Concerns
- Test optional emphasizes high school curriculum/extracurriculars
- These factors less accessible in some areas/socioeconomic groups
- May introduce new forms of inequality
UC System Changes
- University of California announcement:
- Test optional: next 2 years
- Test blind: following 2 years
- Complete SAT/ACT phase-out after that
- Creating own standardized test instead
- Similar to 2001 UC president speech against SAT
- Prompted College Board test redesign
- Negotiations between schools and College Board
Market Dynamics
- College Board's customers are schools, not students
- Schools can create own tests if unsatisfied
- Current changes may extend beyond pandemic
